Proms 2009: Mahler's unfinished rhapsody - Music - Arts - Evening Standard
       

Proms 2009: Mahler's unfinished rhapsody

Critic Rating
Reader Rating 0

When is a Mahler symphony not a Mahler symphony? When it’s his Tenth. He left it incomplete at his death in 1911, and so it stayed until, in the 1960s, Deryck Cooke diligently fleshed out a "performing version".

Many conductors refuse to touch Cooke’s Mahler. Riccardo Chailly embraces it; his performance with the Gewandhaus Orchestra fully justified his faith.

Holding every section of the orchestra in perfect balance, Chailly achieved a miraculous abundance of detail. At times the brass resembled a celestial organ, while the opening movement's piercing trumpet solos seemed to awaken ghosts hidden in the Albert Hall’s rafters. Later, the fourth movement’s stuttering waltz grew ever more tormented until a finely weighted flute solo brought temporary balm, while the bass drum’s shattering blows shook the building’s foundations.

Yet the tiniest sounds — a shudder of cymbal, a single plucked harp string — contained a world of feeling. The work closed as gently as a feather floating on a cushion of air, Chailly holding the final silence as if defying us to break it.

The Gewandhaus Orchestra has a special relationship with Felix Mendelssohn, who was its music director for the last years of his life. In his First Piano Concerto, the young Palestinian-Israeli pianist Saleem Abboud Ashkar fully endorsed Mendelssohn’s instruction that the opening should be played "with fire", and if the result was an occasional hardness in the piano’s tone, there were also moments of contemplative searching. The orchestra, meanwhile, was a steely fist in a silken glove.

www.bbc.co.uk/proms

Mahler's Tenth: Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra/Chailly
Royal Albert Hall

Comments

Don't Miss
Gala night for the Queen of arts - stars turn out in their hundreds to pay tribute

Happy & glorious

Stars turn out in their hundreds to pay tribute to Queen
Prints charming: patterned trousers for summer

Prints charming

Patterned trousers for summer
Promethipedia: the lowdown on Ridley Scott's new blockbuster Prometheus

Promethipedia

The lowdown on Ridley Scott's new blockbuster Prometheus
The Middletan: Kate Middleton has the most requested tan in London

The Middletan

Kate Middleton has the most requested tan in London
Amy Childs bares all like Britney

Dare to bare

Amy Childs vajazzles like Britney
Thais go Gaga: singer’s ‘fake rolex’ tweet sparks new tour row... but fans still mob her at airport

Thais go Gaga

Singer mobbed at airport
Trip the bright fantastic - in vertiginous neon

Fashion

Trip the bright fantastic - in vertiginous neon
Chelsea Champions League celebrations - in pictures

Victory parade

Chelsea Champions League celebrations
High-flying heroes

High flying heroes

David Oyelowo reveals all about new film Red Tails
The Twitter Diaries: Think Bridget Jones tries social networking

The Twitter Diaries

Think Bridget Jones tries social networking