1. Tulpan: Remarkable romantic comedy set among a nomadic tribe in Kazakhstan.
2. An Education: Nick Hornby's sensitive adaptation of journlaist Lynn Barber's excellent memoir of her first boyfriend.
3. The White Ribbon: Michael Hameke's Palme d'Or winner at Cannes is set in a German village just before the start of the First World War.
4. 2012: Roland Emmerich's thrilling apocalypse movie with John Cusack as the hero.
5. Fantastic Mr Fox: Wes Anderson’s take on Roald Dahl is full of quirky magic — with a sly George Clooney voicing Mr Fox.

Critics' Choice

Film

Andrew O'Hagan

quote New Moon is nothing if not an international advertisement for the hungry virtues of virginity and young people can’t get enough of it quote

The Twilight Saga: New Moon Theatre

Henry Hitchings

quote A smart, prickly and rewarding view of sexual and emotional confusion quote

Cock Restaurants

David Sexton

quote Kitchen W8 is a bargain for this area, if such sophistication is what you crave quote

Kitchen W8

Reader reviews

Film

Adam, Harrow

quote Too long and drawn out but very entertaining with excellent special effects quote

2012 Theatre

Rob, London

quote This is a peculiar play and does not work for me. Some of it is very funny but there are real flaws quote

The Habit Of Art Music

Bernard, London

quote Alex has a strong powerful voice and was faultless, she is far better now than she was on the X-Factor quote

Alexandra Burke

What our reviewer, a father of two, thought

By Jeremy Langmead, Evening Standard Last updated at 00:00am on 07.11.05

Add your view

Harry Potter: facing new terrors

The demise of one of Hogwarts' more wholesome (and handsome) characters and the darker air that pervades this film have landed director Mike Newell with a 12A certificate.

The rating seems just: we are subjected to the sight of Mad-Eye Moody torturing screaming spiders, a Hungarian Horntail dragon trying to tear poor Potter apart, Ron and Hermione drowning at the hands of some merciless merpeople, a hungry hedge that prefers flesh to fertiliser, and a severed limb.

I took my two sons, aged nine and 12 and neither said that they were bothered by the gloom and gore. Of course they were alarmed by the ferocious dragon, and no fan of Voldemort's antics, but I think the fact that one now teenage character was pulling gooey eyes at a girl was the most disturbing part of the movie as far as they were concerned.

Newell said the 12A certificate was a sign that he had succeeded. He argued that the children who had grown up watching the Potter films were now older and more sophisticated and that the movie needed to reflect that. He's right; and it does.

And at least there's an underlying morality. As well as the conflict between good and evil, Harry learns that friendship is more important than winning competitions, that weedy boys can get dates, and the importance of trust - all of which kept my mother-in-law, who also saw the film, satisfied that this was more than just a Harry House of Horror feature.