Weather Morning: 7°c Drizzle Afternoon: 9°c Drizzle

Five of the Best...Films
1. An Education
Nick Hornby's sensitive adaptation of journlaist Lynn Barber's excellent memoir of her first boyfriend.
2. Tales From The Golden Age
Portmanteau film with five stories about the horrific final 15 years of the Ceausescu regime in Romania.
3. Fantastic Mr Fox
Wes Anderson’s take on Roald Dahl is full of quirky magic — with a sly George Clooney voicing Mr Fox.
4. Bright Star
Jane Campion's imaginative portrayal of the Keats/Brawne love affair.
5. Disney's A Christmas Carol
Starring Jim Carrey as Scrooge.

Critics' Choice

Restaurants

Fay Maschler

quoteWith a single dessert and just two glasses of wine our bill was kept in check - but the effort of doing so was not much funquote

Fay Maschler Babbo Film

Andrew O'Hagan

quoteThis is a film with beautiful performances and a visual style that urges you towards reflectionquote

Andrew O'Hagan Bright Star Theatre

Henry Hitchings

quoteAlthough the first half of Kwei-Armah’s production is pacy, funny and intelligent, the energy level then drops offquote

Henry Hitchings Seize The Day

Reader reviews

Film

Squiz, Islington

quoteI loved this film from start to finish. Take the girlfriend, tell your mum - I'd see it again tomorrow and will buy the dvd.quote

An Education Theatre

Joe, London

quoteI saw this last night and can't remember the last time I was so moved in the theatre.quote

This Much Is True Restaurants

Hiroshi Sugiyama

quoteI have been to many of London's so-called best Japanese restaurants and none have been as good as the food that I've had at Aqua Kyotoquote

Aqua Kyoto

Film news and reviews London,

Brideshead Revisited

Your rating
one startwo starthree starfour starfive star
Click on a star to rate
Cert:

Evening Standard rating Derek Malcolm's rating
Evening Standard rating Reader rating
 Add your review

 
Please wait the page is loading extra content
  • Showing at

Stop bashing Brideshead

By Derek Malcolm, Evening Standard  02.10.08
 
Brideshead Revisited

Tragic love story: Charles (Matthew Goode), Julia (Hayley Atwell) and Sebastian (Ben Wishaw)

Brideshead Revisited

Professional: Emma Thompson stars in the new production

Other reviews

Look here too

I don’t think Evelyn Waugh would spin in his grave if heaven showed him Julian Jarrold’s version of his best known novel. But it wouldn’t surprise me if a little smoke was seen issuing from it.

However, I would reprimand those — and there will be a fair number — who compare it to the 1981 television version. That was more than 600 minutes long, in 11 episodes, and could linger over Waugh’s words and themes in a way a film cannot. This adaptation, written by Andrew Davies and Jeremy Brock and decked out with an able cast and production values no one could decry, is a different entity. If you haven’t read the book or seen the TV series, you’ll probably enjoy the film most.

In his book, Waugh, a conservative Catholic with one or two unlikely radical inclinations, told us how he regretted the smashing, largely by the war, of the care-free days of the middle class in the Thirties and also of the importance of a certain kind of Catholicism which was not so much a matter of faith as a way towards Godliness that cannot be shirked.

He said a lot of other things as well. But this film boils it all down into a tragic love story where, towards the end, religion figures more than worldly affection. Ultimately, Julia Flyte (Hayley Atwell) refuses to marry Charles Ryder (Matthew Goode) not because it would be betraying her class but because she has just seen Michael Gambon’s old rebel Lord Marchmain come back from Venice to die and make peace with his maker in his last moments. This is her life, and no one and nothing can tear her away from it.

While Waugh clearly approves of her sacrifice, Jarrold’s film, which looks at the tragedy with 21st-century eyes, seems to be asking us to disapprove. Which, of course, is easy to do. Even so, whichever way you judge it from the moral point of view, the death and its direct aftermath is among the finest sequences in the film.

The other distraction on screen is the stolidity of Goode’s performance. His is not a bad portrait and he sustains it well enough. But either because of the writing or, more probably, the casting, there’s a lack of real emotion that deprives this handsome production of one of its main struts. You understand what’s happened to him but you don’t feel it enough.

That is not true of Ben Wishaw’s charming but hopelessly unsettled Sebastian Flyte — very different from Anthony Andrews’s upper-class toff on television. Wishaw’s Flyte is a young man tortured by his inability to knuckle under his mother’s all-embracing faith and is as desperate to get away from the ancestral pile as Charles, whom he loves, is enamoured of it.

Mother is played by Emma Thompson, whom some might say was imperfectly cast but whose performance is riveting. She has the capacity to underline both the horror and the justice of her spiritual position even when Ryder, the avowed atheist, tells her she has wrecked the happiness of both her daughter and son in this world even if it has prevented damnation in the next.

Class, of course, comes into the proceedings a lot, though it is now difficult for us to see much difference between Ryder’s middle-class manners and those of the aristocratic Flyte and Marchmain brood. However, there is a good moment when, sitting down to dinner at Brideshead in a flannel suit and apologising for being wrongly dressed, Charles is told by Lady M not that it’s all right but that she is sure Sebastian can lend him something in the future.

All the other performances are more than adequate, laid out before us in a film that pleases the eye like so many British period pieces that take more care with the visuals than with the heart and soul of their stories. Castle Howard again stands in for Brideshead and Jess Hall’s cinematography and a bevy of art directors and designers give the production considerable class.

In the end, however, this is a film which though less ambitious than Atonement is very much the equal of The Duchess. Its weakness is the same as that of the latter: it has no guiding hand prepared to take risks and make it distinctive. It is so competent and professional that Waugh’s essential flair disappears within its magnificent visuals.

More


Details are correct at the time of publication - please check with venue before booking.

 

Other reviews

[ 1 ] [ 2 ] [ 3 ]

Reader reviews (3)

 Add your review

A wonderful movie ! Enjoyed it very much Wow, an elegant place at a different time

- Dave Novak, Brookfield, IL USA

I saw it last night and thoroughly enjoyed it. The scenes shot in Venice are spectacular, in fact the whole film was shot in a spectacular way. Some people have called it period porn, I call it attention to period details. Overall I thought the performances were very good and hope Emma Thompson gets an Oscar nomination for her part.

- Patricia, London, England

I was lucky enough to be invited to the Regional Premiere held at Castle Howard on 1st October. What a privilege to see it in that splendid setting. I thought the film was excellent and had the effect of making you think very deeply about religion and the effects it has on peoples lives. The actors were faultless and caught the essence of the plot very well. Very good, it could not have been a better setting

- Joan Rambridge, York. England


Add your comment

 

Your email address will not be published

Terms and conditions make text area bigger You have  characters left.


 
 
 
London's Weather
Morning
Drizzle
7°c
Afternoon
Drizzle
9°c
5 day forecast
 
 

Daily Mail Mail on Sunday Travel Mail This is Money Metro

Loot | Jobsite | Homes & property | London jobs | FindaProperty.com | Primelocation.com | Educate London | Holiday Villas