Weather Morning: 14°c Overcast Afternoon: 15°c Drizzle

Five of the Best...Films
1. Tulpan
Remarkable romantic comedy set among a nomadic tribe in Kazakhstan.
2. An Education
Nick Hornby's sensitive adaptation of journlaist Lynn Barber's excellent memoir of her first boyfriend.
3. The White Ribbon
Michael Hameke's Palme d'Or winner at Cannes is set in a German village just before the start of the First World War.
4. 2012
Roland Emmerich's thrilling apocalypse movie with John Cusack as the hero.
5. Fantastic Mr Fox
Wes Anderson’s take on Roald Dahl is full of quirky magic — with a sly George Clooney voicing Mr Fox.

Critics' Choice

Film

Andrew O'Hagan

quoteNew Moon is nothing if not an international advertisement for the hungry virtues of virginity and young people can’t get enough of itquote

Andrew O'Hagan The Twilight Saga: New Moon Theatre

Henry Hitchings

quoteA smart, prickly and rewarding view of sexual and emotional confusionquote

Henry Hitchings Cock Restaurants

David Sexton

quoteKitchen W8 is a bargain for this area, if such sophistication is what you crave quote

David Sexton Kitchen W8

Reader reviews

Film

Adam, Harrow

quoteToo long and drawn out but very entertaining with excellent special effectsquote

2012 Theatre

Rob, London

quoteThis is a peculiar play and does not work for me. Some of it is very funny but there are real flawsquote

The Habit Of Art Music

Bernard, London

quoteAlex has a strong powerful voice and was faultless, she is far better now than she was on the X-Factorquote

Alexandra Burke

Film news and reviews London,

World Trade Center

Your rating
one startwo starthree starfour starfive star
Click on a star to rate
Cert: 12A

Evening Standard rating Derek Malcolm's rating
Evening Standard rating Reader rating
 Add your review

Dir: Oliver Stone. Cast: Michael Pena, Jay Hernandez, Nicolas Cage

 

Description: Dumb, reactionary, crassly self-important take on 9/11, restaging the true story of two cops buried in the rubble of the Twin Towers.

Country: US. 2006. 129mins
Please wait the page is loading extra content
  • Show details
  • Hide details
  • Showing at

Is this one 9/11 movie too far?

By Derek Malcolm, Evening Standard  28.09.06
 
Nicolas Cage

Terror: Nicolas Cage plays fireman John McLoughlin

Look here too

You wouldn't guess that this film was made by Oliver Stone. Certainly not the Stone of the coruscating Platoon or the banal Alexander. It bears no marks of a conspiracy theory and its politics are shrouded in a conventional disaster movie.

It will, of course, be more painful for New Yorkers to watch than for the rest of us, since the shock of 9/11 was greater for them. But, while the more conservative voice of America might have cried "too soon" to make a movie of the real-life rescue of two Port Authority policeman, among the last of 20 to be pulled alive from the rubble of the Twin Towers, we are at liberty to ask, is it too late?

Haven't we just seen Paul Greengrass's excellent United 93 on the screen and a good few 9/11 recreations on television? Do we really want much more?

What Stone does is orthodox Hollywood story-telling - but that's not meant as an insult. It begins with Will Jimeno (Michael Peña) and Sergeant John McLoughlin (Nicolas Cage), his boss, each making their way to work as they did on any other morning.

After the first plane strikes, McLoughlin leads a team to midtown Manhattan and five volunteers, including Jimeno and McLoughlin, bravely enter one of the buildings.

They go swiftly from storeroom to storeroom collecting up equipment, and are ready to begin work when their tower collapses. Only the two central characters survive, buried beneath tons of concrete and twisted metal.

They keep each other from falling unconcious by talking about their families and their work, until a maverick rescuer, an ex-Marine from Connecticut called Karnes (Michael Shannon), locates them and calls for help.

All this is accomplished without too much melodrama or false heroics, moving back and forth with practised ease from the trapped men to their anxious families at home. A certain cynicism sets in, however, when you see who are playing the wives.

Maggie Gyllenhaal is the pregnant Allison Jimeno and Maria Bello is Donna McLoughlin. While both are good actresses, they're too beautiful and well groomed to ring entirely true. Casting lesser-known faces, with less immaculate hairdos, might have spared one the feeling that this is a movie capable of exploiting its story rather than simply telling it well.

There are other moments when doubts set in. One is when Stone illustrates far too literally the trapped and choking Jimeno's conviction that he saw Jesus holding out a bottle of water to him. Another occurs, once the two are saved, when the marine says that America will need good men to revenge the attack.

His little speech sends a shiver down the spine at the thought of what eventually transpired in Afghanistan and Iraq, good men or no.

Related articles

More


Details are correct at the time of publication - please check with venue before booking.

 

Reader reviews (0)

 Add your review

No comments have so far been submitted.


Add your comment

 

Your email address will not be published

Terms and conditions make text area bigger You have  characters left.


 
 
 
London's Weather
Morning
Overcast
14°c
Afternoon
Drizzle
15°c
5 day forecast
 
 

Daily Mail Mail on Sunday Travel Mail This is Money Metro

Loot | Jobsite | Homes & property | London jobs | FindaProperty.com | Primelocation.com | Educate London | Holiday Villas