Weather Morning: 9°c Sunny spells Afternoon: 10°c Sunny spells

Film

London,

Copying Beethoven

Cert: 12A

Description: Ed Harris is in full "genius artist" mode again, this time to explain how the ailing composer wrote his 9th, with the help of hottie muse Diane Kruger. Pure highbrow tosh.



Rating: 3 out of 5 Derek Malcolm's rating
Rating: 3.5 out of 5

Reader rating

Your rating

one star two star three star four star five star

Click on a star to rate

Dir: Agnieszka Holland.

Cast: Diane Kruger, Ed Harris, Matthew Goode

Country: US/Ger/Hun.

Year: 2006.

Duration: 104mins

Showing at

New backstory for Beethoven

Diane Kruger
Helpmeet: Anna (Diane Kruger) writes compositions of her own

By Derek Malcolm
16 Aug 2007


It can't be comfortable to work with a genius, and Agniezka Holland's fiction makes it very uncomfortable indeed. The genius is the ill, deaf and cantankerous Beethoven (Ed Harris) and the put-upon co-worker is Anna (Diane Kruger), who helps to copy out his scores. She also has to empty his slops, clean out his rat-ridden apartment and persuade him to listen to compositions of her own.

Fortunately, Beethoven begins to see her value as a helpmeet and she begins to understand just why his music is unmatchable.

The film could have been risible in less sensitive hands, and there are one or two giggles to be had. But the period is well and extravagantly evoked, Harris is pretty damned good as Beethoven, and Holland's understanding of his copiously illustrated music, which includes the Choral Symphony and, more daringly, decent extracts from his late piano sonatas and quartets, makes this a film that sounds as good as it looks.

Is there any point to it, though, considering it is pure fiction and not fact? Well, Holland obviously thinks so and paints Anna as a figure who is at first derided and becomes a worthy participant in history through sheer persistence. And even the least sensitive filmgoer ought to respond to the music, and perhaps to Beethoven's dictum that academic shape and form is nothing compared to the sheer inspiration of dazzling sounds.

Both Harris and Kruger are much more than adequate, with Harris not only looking like Beethoven but spitting out his well-written lines with real panache. You can mock this film if you like, but it remains watchable throughout. And the ears have it when the eyes don't.

Details are correct at the time of publication - please check with venue before booking.

Reader views (1)

 Add your view

Any movie that brings Ludwig Van Beethoven's astounding Ninth Symphony to the attention of the general public deserves an Oscar!

Once hooked the born again music lovers will search out Beethoven's "Irish" Symphony, the magnificent Seventh.

Then they will be ready to view the very rare portrait of Beethoven being serenaded by a Nymph, just waiting for a journalist with imagination.

- Maurice Colgan, Swords, Ireland., 17/08/2007 14:03
Report abuse


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.