The man killing new music on Radio One
Paul Connolly, London Lite15 Jan 2007
I've always been a vocal fan of BBC Radio One and taken its side when the conservative beancounters of commercial radio have whinged about the licence fee. Because if it weren't for the risk-takers at RadioOne, commercial radio would have us listening to a steady diet of Cliff Richard and James Blunt. Nearly all of the interesting new major acts of the past two decades have been broken by RadioOne - stations such as Capital and Heart only latch onto a song once it's a proven listener favourite, the spineless philistines.
Of course, the BBC is not driven by commercial imperatives, and that offers it the luxury of not pandering to the lowest common denominator (otherwise known as "doing an ITV"). Its remit for public-service broadcasting also ensures that its commitment to new music has, until recently at least, been adhered to.
But there have been some very worrying signs since the appointment 14 months ago of the station's new head of music, George Ergatoudis, not least of which is the station's pretentious, inane slogan, In New Music We Trust. I mean, come on, what does that actually mean? That it's acceptable to leave the new Amy Winehouse album at home to babysit the kids while you go out on the lash?
Even more concerning is the station's playlist policy (by which it is decided which records will be played by DJs). There's been much excitement recently that, of the top 10 selling albums of 2006, seven were of UK provenance. Some have even heralded it as the finest era for UK music since Britpop.
For Radio One, oddly enough, it's as if 1997 never ended. Of its top 10 most-played songs of 2006, six were cheesy dance anthems, none were by the biggest-selling British artists, and only three were by British artists at all, the veteran Isle of Wight DJ, Dave Lee (aka Joey Negro with Make A Move On Me), The Automatic and Meck, whose take on Leo Sayer's Thunder In My Heart was another nail in the coffin of creativity in dance music.
There were four American acts in the top 10 and, astonishingly, almost as many Dutch acts as there were British. Since when has Holland been a pop powerhouse?
Where on earth was the support for new British music? Indeed, where was the support for new music full stop?
Even if daytime Radio One has become disproportionately enamoured with dance music why couldn't it at least ignore the cheese and feature genuinely brilliant dance tracks such as Ame's Rej and Justice vs Simian's We Are Your Friends?
And it's not getting any better. What was at the top of the RadioOne playlist chart last week? Proper Education, Eric Prydz's wretchedly humdrum cover of Pink Floyd's Another Brick In The Wall, followed closely by the gurning atrocity that is Sharam's PATT.
Seriously, Mr Ergatoudis, what are you on? Because, whatever it is, I don't want any.
• Do you think RadioOne has lost the plot? Or are you happy with all the cheese? Email me on soundingoff@thelondonlite.co.uk
Reader views (3)
Couldn't agree more with this. Radio 1 should definitely be more risk taking in what they play.. surely the BBC is all about supporting creativity and UK creativity at that. I'm not hearing any on Radio 1 and it's killing music.. no wonder everyone's heading for the internet to get their musical kicks.
- Ed Lonsdale, St Albns, 18/01/2010 10:18
Report abuse
Because Radio 1 has a licence fee it should be able to support new, quality independent music, not just bands/musicians signed to big labels with big budgets.
As for commercial radio - forget the music, they just play the same records, by the same bands, all the time, for months after they've been released. You never hear a new band on your local radio station. Radio 1 is only slightly better, they do play records first, but not enough of them in the daytime.
It's embarrassing hearing radio presenters rave about the latest act when clearly it's the first time they've heard it themselves and they've been told that it's the next new big thing! Radio 1 in the evenings is great, but we need some decent music in the daytime.
- Mc, Eastbourne, 16/01/2007 11:25
Report abuse
This article is spot on!
Radio 1 has just become a home for egos and terrible music.
It's about time something was said. Now something needs to be done.
- Becky Braine, London UK, 16/01/2007 09:28
Report abuse
Tonight:
5°c






