Weather Afternoon: 10°c Sunny spells Tonight: 4°c Partly Cloudy Night

Music

London,

English National Opera: Madam Butterfly

Description: Edward Gardner conducts Puccini's tragic tale, starring Judith Howarth as Cio-Cio-San and Christine Rice as Suzuki. Sung in English.



Rating: 3 out of 5 Nick Kimberley's rating
Rating: 3.5 out of 5

Reader rating

Your rating

one star two star three star four star five star

Click on a star to rate

Other reviews:

Dir: Anthony Minghella.

Cast: English National Opera, Judith Howarth (Cio-Cio-San), Christine Rice (Suzuki), Edward Gardner (cond)

London Coliseum St Martin's Lane, WC2N 4ES

Phone: 0871911 0200

Website: www.eno.org

Email: box.office@eno.org

Extra info: Pub, Food

Transport: Rail/Tube: Charing Cross; Tube: Leicester Square/Embankment Transport for London , Tube / Bus: 3, 6, 9, 11, 12, 13, 15, 23, 24, 29, 53, 77a, 88, 91, 139, 159, 176 Transport for London

Minghella's Madam Butterfly visionary moments

Madame Butterfly
Love turns to tragedy: Judith Howarth (Butterfly) and Gwyn Hughes Jones (Pinkerton)

By Nick Kimberley
1 Feb 2008


When you ask a celebrated film director to stage one of the cornerstones of the operatic repertoire, the last thing you want is timid reticence. What you look for is boldness, colour, vision.

Anthony Minghella's English National Opera production of Puccini's Madam Butterfly is certainly bold and colourful, and it has its visionary moments. The sloping mirror that forms the back of the stage creates some telling split-screen effects, and the images of Butterfly that open and close the opera are heart-breaking in their directness. So far, so good.

This is an opera with everything: a clash of cultures, under-age sex, single motherhood, forced adoption, suicide. Yet Minghella seems reluctant to deliver the story straight, and for every telling detail there are a dozen touches of kitsch. As for having Butterfly's three-year-old son played by a puppet, it is either crass misjudgment or a masterstroke. At least the puppet looks involved, which is rarely the case when the role is taken by an overawed schoolboy.

For this revival, staged by Minghella's wife Carolyn Choa, you sense that so much attention has been lavished on peripherals that the singers have been left to get by with standard issue Puccini-isms.

Conductor David Parry whips the orchestra into a fine frenzy, sometimes overwhelming the voices, but the emotional temperature is slow to rise.

Perhaps the most expressive singing comes from Karen Cargill as Suzuki, Butterfly's maid, which is not quite what Puccini had in mind. As Pinkerton, the American sailor who is Butterfly's downfall, Gwyn Hughes Jones is more abrasive than tender, and at first it is hard to believe that Judith Howarth's Butterfly can have fallen for him.

As her situation gets desperate, though, Howarth locates the intensity that finally hits home, so that Butterfly's freeze-frame suicide seems horribly real.

Until 8 March (0871 911 0200).

Details are correct at the time of publication - please check with venue before booking.

Reader views (0)

 Add your view

No comments have so far been submitted.


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

Music top five
Cher Lloyd
Cher Lloyd

IndigO2
SE10
Apr 8, 7pm

Chris Rea

HMV Apollo
W6
Apr 5, 6.30pm

Miles Kane

HMV Forum
NW5
Apr 28, 7.30pm

Example

The O2 Arena
SE10
Apr 27, 6.30pm

Lightning Seeds

02 Shepherd's Bush Empire
W12
Feb 18, 7pm