- My Account
- Logout
- Register
- Login
ALEX BRUMMER: The day banking changed for ever
Related Articles
16 September 2008
The convulsions on Wall Street over the weekend represent the greatest challenge to free market capitalism since the Great Crash of 1929. In a shocking 72 hours of turmoil, the frantic year-long effort by policymakers and governments to restore confidence in the safety of the world's banking system came apart at the seams.
The global financial system is a very different place now that Lehman Brothers, an institution which traces its roots back to 1850, has filed for bankruptcy.
Nowhere was this clearer than in Canary Wharf, where 4,500 Lehman employees were instantly fired - losing not just their jobs but much of their savings, since one-third of the company was owned by staff. The disdain among employees for Dick Fuld, the chairman and chief executive who led the house to oblivion, was palpable.
Bags packed: A worker leaves the Canary Wharf offices of Lehman brothers
Even more startling, in many respects, was the sight of Merrill Lynch, the world's largest stockbroking firm with 16,000 brokers, being rescued from oblivion by Bank of America.
The 'thundering herd', as Merrill Lynch is known, with its logo of a bull to represent bullish or buoyant markets, is not just another Wall Street giant. Its investment arm was developed from its retail banking division, so Merrill is still a presence on every high street across America - the place where 'Mom & Pop' savers go to invest their savings and buy their pension plans.
The loss of these two giant banks, together with that other Wall Street giant Bear Stearns which collapsed in March this year, means there are only two global investment banks left - Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs.
They might have been smarter and more cautious than their rivals but
the truth is investment banking itself - in which giant financial institutions risk everything by making complex bets on the future performances of their investments - must now be in severe doubt.
A trader reacts on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange as the markets fall
As if all of this were not enough in one day, a terrible crisis also erupted at AIG, the group regarded as the world's largest and most sophisticated insurer. Last night it won an £11billion lifeline from Wall Street's private banks. But its balance sheet is loaded up with 'toxic' securities - it has pledged vast amounts of insurance against bad loans - which cannot be valued.
It is this uncertainty over valuations which is the most disturbing aspect of the credit crunch. The crunch began on August 9 last year after the leading French bank BNP Paribas announced it could not value assets in two of its investment funds because of the toxic securities they contained.
The City and Wall Street immediately became concerned that, hidden in the funds and balance sheets not just of banks but of insurance companies and pension funds, there were tens if not hundreds of billions of assets which have turned bad and might be worthless.
Only now at Lehman, Merrill Lynch, AIG and elsewhere is the true size of the black hole being recognised. At Lehman, for example, the figure for suspect or toxic assets more than doubled from £17billion to £44billion in the course of last weekend alone.
It is the lack of credible and verifiable information about the health of the balance sheets of major banks around the world, including our own high street lenders, which is so terrifying.
Tourists take pictures in New York's Times Square as the days financial news is displayed on the news-ticker
These doubts about asset values mean professional investors have become allergic to financial shares of all kinds.
At one stage yesterday, Britain's biggest mortgage lender Halifax Bank of Scotland (HBOS), suffered a 25 per cent drop in its share price even though it raised £4billion of new capital earlier this year.
Throughout the financial crisis the Bank of England has taken a tougher line than other central banks in Europe and the Federal Reserve in America which looked determined to try to prop up failed institutions - not least with this month's multi-billion dollar takeover of the two biggest mortgage companies in the U.S., Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
But now the Federal Reserve is no longer willing to subsidise investment banks such as Lehman which, in their search for profits, over-extended themselves by borrowing up to 30 times their capital, only to invest the cash in foolish securities and real estate.
By allowing Lehman to go to the wall, the Fed is making clear that it is no longer in the business of bailing out 'wholesale' banks where it is Wall Street players - rather than high street consumers - who are directly affected by the failure.
The message is stark: The Fed means to purge the system of firms who abandon prudence for profit.
In the past, this approach has worked: after the Wall Street investment house Drexel Burnham Lambert was allowed to go bust in the late 1980s, others cleaned up their act by investing more judiciously. The same thing happened after Britain's oldest investment bank Barings failed in 1995.
People look out of the window at the Lehman Brothers Holdings as they consider their future
But today it is more difficult because of the modern practice where loans are repackaged and disguised by one institution, then sold on over and over again to others.
It means the contagion of toxic securities has infected any number of finance houses and disaster in one may spell trouble for others. The closure of Lehman Brothers, for example, immediately triggered multi-million-pound losses at the Swiss bank UBS. Another problem is that
City and Wall Street banks are now so absorbed in trying to sort out their own problems that funds are being diverted from keeping the wheels of commerce turning.
Billions of dollars is being lavished by the investment banks on support operations within the banking sector itself - which means the supply of credit to ordinary consumers and businesses is drying up.
The U.S. is experiencing a deep downturn. Germany and Spain, two of the UK's biggest export customers, are already in recession. In Britain, both the OECD and the European Commission forecast that recession is on the way.
Worryingly, Britain is most vulnerable because, over the last couple of decades, we chose to develop the financial services sector as the nation's chief strategic industry. We are therefore set for an extraordinarily painful adjustment - far worse than for several decades.
The shape of banking will be changed for ever by the events of the last year. The fashion for exotic financial instruments, which disguise the true nature of bad debt, will go. So will the habit of over-ambitious gambling by Wall Street and City investment houses.
The good thing about the free market is that it is self-correcting in the end. We might all have to endure several years of pain - banking crises typically take up to a decade to repair themselves - but eventually the demand for improved living standards will stimulate growth again.
This crunch might - as the former Fed chairman Alan Greenspan says - be a 'once in a century' event. But in what is becoming an ever-growing crisis, the optimist can at least argue that the deeper and longer the downturn the stronger the eventual bounce back.
Comments
Top stories in News
Top stories in News
-
Locked up and banned: The Tube drunk whose vile racist rant was caught on film (video)
-
British housewife facing FIRING SQUAD over Bali drugs smuggling charge was 'neighbour from hell' -
London 2012 Olympics: Raising the bar and the Games haven't even started yet. Price of toasting Team GB is £6 a pint! -
Video: Intruder bursts into Leveson Inquiry to brand Tony Blair a war criminal -
Ken Clarke: Tories demanding EU poll are extreme nationalists
-
First victory for campaign to save famous pie and mash shop -
'Normal' clothes inspire new designer at Central Saint Martins fashion show -
Usain Bolt is quick to tell fans he’ll be lightning fast again -
Invasion of the book snatchers: Brent Council sneaks into Kensal Rise library at 2am to strip it bare -
Video: Is this the World's most OTT marriage proposal? Hilarious film
The O2
Check out the cool stuff happening under our tent such as the hottest gigs, comedy, sport, films, clubs, bars, restaurants and much more.
A home to be proud of with Halifax
Download the Halifax's brilliant, free new Home Finder app, and take all the pain out of finding your dream home.
Can you imagine a career in teaching?
Be inspired to teach - let real teachers show you how rewarding the job can be.
Playing a game-changing role during the Games
Cisco is providing the solutions for London 2012's complex IT needs.
Win a Silverstone track day with Zantac 75
Feel the burn of a different kind - 20 Silverstone motoring experiences to be won
Celebrate with MARTINI®
This weekend toast one royal with another and make your Jubilee sparkle with a MARTINI Royale.
Reader Offers email A fantastic selection of
offers, giveaways and
promotions.
Hulk to Chelsea is '90 per cent done'
TV Baftas - in pictures