Morning:
8°c
A rioter who terrorised diners with an axe at McDonald's has been jailed for five years and three months - one of the toughest sentences for last summer's disturbances
More...
Row over ethnic minority only swimming sessions for women and children
Last updated at 23:52pm on 28.12.06
How is it that taking a dip has become so complicated?
A council has been fiercely criticised for holding ethnic-minority only swimming sessions.
Wolverhampton City Council employs special life-guards and instructors for the sessions, which are open to the city's black and Asian residents only.
It claims the weekly periods are for women and children with "religious or cultural issues which would otherwise prevent them from taking part."
But furious pool-users say they amount to racial segregation and claim they are being prevented from using the pool - simply because they may be white.
The hour-long, Thursday evening sessions at Wolverhampton's Central Baths replace an aqua-aerobics session that was previously open to all.
They are financially supported by Kellogg's Swim Active programme, which has funded the installation of special blinds around the pool, designed to protect swimmers' privacy.
The special sessions started in November and run every Thursday evening. It is not known exactly how many people take part.
Yesterday, swimmer Leslie Waugh, from Walsall, said: "It's wrong. The council bangs on about integration but then does something like this. The women even have their own instructor and lifeguard brought in for the sessions and the regular workers have to leave."
Local councillor Malcolm Gwinnett said: "It's one thing to have an all-women session, that's fine. But it should be all women of whatever religion, not just one religion, which leaves everyone else out in the cold."
Conservative MP Andrew Rosindell said: "This seems to be exactly the sort of thing that creates division and resentment rather than bringing people together.
"I'd like to know what the logic behind this is. It sounds like a pretty bad idea to me and just the sort of thing that councils should not be doing."
A Wolverhampton City Council spokesman said complaints about the scheme had been received by reception staff at the baths.
She said: "It is one of the most ambitious schemes in the country and aims to tackle childhood obesity, engage the city's ethnic minority communities and work with children who fear water.
"An initial trial of eight weeks is providing an opportunity for women and children from ethnic minorities, who may not otherwise participate for cultural and religious reasons."
The Wolverhampton ethnic-minority swim sessions come after leisure centre in Croydon, South London, opened its pool to Muslims only for two hours every week.
Thornton Heath Leisure Centre insist that men wear shorts which hide the navel and extend below the knee. Women wear a swimming costume that covers their body from the neck down to the ankle. There are separate sessions for men and women.
In common with the Wolverhampton plan, the sessions were condemned by local people for encouraging segregation.
Reader views (8)
Madness. Absolute madness. I consider myself very much left wing but this is ridiculous. What about sessions for a few of my gay mates? Or sessions for short people and those with hairy backs.
I've had some wonderful times swimming in rivers and lakes in Egypt and Morocco with locals and the women wear what they want depending on their level of conformity to religious dress. And when I took my mother, I made her wear a shirt and shorts just like the local ladies. No issue.
But we live in the UK and up until now pools were NOT segregated based upon sex/creed/colour or religion. Why start?? This is leftist nonsense. This is not equality, this is pandering to special interest groups rather than a sense of liberal equality.
Putney Leisure centre has this type of nonsense and I for one will not be rejoining. They can subsidise the the gym/pool with people who put up with this rubbish.
This wouldn't happen back in australia....
- James, Putney London, 26/05/2010 14:42
Report abuse
Most programs do cater to "white", Western cultural norms and suit the patrons that frequent them and the reality is that countries like Canada, the UK and the US are made up of citizens of many different backgounds. This centre has created a program to reach those who feel they are unable to take part in traditional swim programs for religious or cultural reasons. The idea is to make the pool accessible for these women and children so they can get their exercise. Regular programs don't meet the needs of these groups so providing them with their own safe space for recreation should be applauded. Giving marginalized groups an hour of pool time is really not a big deal in the grand scheme of things for most of us, but may mean the world to others who didn't feel that they could take part before. Inclusion is not the same thing as integration nor does it mean assimilation. Show some tolerance.
- Kelly, Canada, 18/02/2010 21:15
Report abuse
I don't know why people is making such a fuss. How on earth is it racist if there are other sessions for people to go to. It's not like they don't have anywhere to swim. This session also lets people who wouldn't otherwise be able to.
Sorry if i might have offended you but I'm only expressing my opinion. And I'm not over 14
- Jamala, London, 08/01/2010 19:39
Report abuse
I'm a Muslim female and as part of my religion I choose to dress modestly in the company of others, and not uncover in front of men. Just one hour a week in a swimming pool (stricltly ladies only - any ethnicity!!!) would be a facility I would be grateful to recieve from the council, as a honest, working, tax-paying, British born Londoner. It's a shame this has to be dealt with insensitively and made into a hoo-ha.
- Faaiza, London, 07/01/2010 11:46
Report abuse
Brighton and Hove Council has recently introduced sessions at St Luke's swimming pool. This pool is mainly used for teaching during the day but adult sessions have been available on three lunchtimes. One of these sessions is now classed as women only but it is really for Muslim women but the council does not have the courage to say so. Other women are allowed in the pool. However, unlike some comments I do not understand the need for women only sessions. This pool now has 4 hours in the day for women and only 2 hours for men. How can this be reasonable from a council that claims to support equality for all?
- Alan, Brighton, 04/02/2008 17:47
Report abuse
This is a worthwhile experiment, and if it encourages young Asians to learn to swim, and enjoy that form of exercise it is very worthwhile.
It would probably be helpful if pools also had private sessions for overweight white people who feel embarrassed going to general sessions at pools.
We should endeavour to make sports and exercise facilities work for everyone.
- Jonathan Jones, Richmond, 29/12/2006 12:33
Report abuse
This "catering to the Muslims" is way out of hand. They chose to move to the country they are in. They chose NOT to live in an Islamic country. Pools are public pools; for ALL people.. if you don't like the rules, swim somewhere else! Or, buy your own pool, and make your own rules for that pool!
- William Lowe, Irving (Dallas area), TX, 29/12/2006 12:08
Report abuse
This is racism under a new guise - it's called Apartheid. Just imagine the fuss that would be made if it were for Whites Only?
- Graham, Newbury, Uk, 29/12/2006 10:59
Report abuse
