Morning:
20°c
Johnny Depp has become, in his young middle age, like a star of the movies’ golden period
Secret deal hatched by News of the World to hush up details of phone-tapping was sealed in a tiny room at the Royal Courts of Justice
More...
Yard rocked by race row as senior Muslim officer fails to win promotion
Last updated at 09:37am on 08.03.07
No promotion: Chief Superintendent Ali Dizaei, whose controversial book has been serialised by a newspaper, has missed out on promotion
Scotland Yard was plunged into a race row last night after one of the country's most senior Muslim officers failed in his bid for promotion.
Chief Superintendent Ali Dizaei, an outspoken critic of racism in the Met, was one of ten officers hoping to be selected for the rank of Commander.
Scroll down for more...
No promotion: Chief Superintendent Ali Dizaei, whose controversial book has been serialised by a newspaper, has missed out on promotion
Read more... • Met 'anarchy' as Muslim officer lashes out in book
• Met attacks Dizaei's witch hunt claims
• Racism claim troops 'to form union'
But yesterday he was turned down for the £95,000-a-year post prompting a furious backlash from his supporters in the powerful National Black Police Association, to which he is legal adviser.
A senior official in the NBPA alleged Iranian-born Mr Dizaei, 44, may have been the victim of a 'personal vendetta' and demanded urgent talks with Met chief Sir Ian Blair to discuss the promotion snub. He also indicated the case could end up at an employment tribunal.
In a separate statement, the Metropolitan Black Police Association said it was "extremely disappointed" that Mr Dizaei had not been selected by a four-strong police authority promotion board, which was advised by Sir Ian.
"We suspect the decision of the Metropolitan Police Authority was not free from bias and could not have been reached on the basis of objective and fair criteria," it said.
Three white officers were selected for the rank of commander, equivalent to the rank of assistant chief constable, instead of Mr Dizaei.
Mr Dizaei - head of policing in Hounslow, west London - has angered scores of colleagues by writing a controversial book about his time at Scotland Yard, which was serialised in a national newspaper last week.
The timing of his book serialisation prompted claims that he was trying to put pressure on the police authority promotion board - a suggestion denied by Mr Dizaei.
In the book, entitled Not One Of Us, Mr Dizaei, writes scathingly about the four-year, multimillion-pound corruption investigation launched against him in 1999.
He was accused of drug abuse, using prostitutes, spying for Iran and making a series of 'deeply unpleasant' threatening phonecalls to a girlfriend.
It finally ended when he was cleared of perverting the course of justice and fiddling his expenses at the Old Bailey in 2003.
In addition to the criminal charges, Mr Dizaei was accused of nine police disciplinary offences, including claims he accepted backhanders and interfered in investigations on behalf of friends.
No action was taken after the Met - under pressure from the then Home Secretary David Blunkett - came to a controversial deal with Mr Dizaei, which was brokered by Sir Ian.
In return for him dropping a race discrimination claim, he was told all outstanding counts against him would be scrapped and that he would also receive £60,000 in compensation.
He was also handed a place on a prestigious chief officers' promotion course at Bramshill police college.
But three years after finishing the course, he is yet to be given a higher rank.
Keith Jarrett, president of the NBPA, said he would be seeking an urgent meeting with Sir Ian Blair in the wake of the MPA's decision not to promote Mr Dizaei.
He said he wanted "answers" from the Commissioner about why Mr Dizaei had been denied promotion when he led one of the best performing boroughs in London and had been graded as "exceptional" in his personal performance assessment.
If these answers were not satisfactory, Mr Jarrett said the NBPA would take the matter "further" - possibly to an employment tribunal.
Mr Dizaei had completed his senior command course three years ago - achieving the highest marks - and yet had still not been promoted, he said.
All nine other officers on the course had since been promoted to more senior roles, Mr Jarrett added.
He also said that in the last five years, there had been no promotions of senior black or Asian officers within the Met.
Mr Jarrett added: "I do not want to start levelling accusations of racism, but it worries me it could be a personal vendetta against Ali.
"I need to satisfy myself that is not the case."
Asked whether Mr Dizaei's book could have affected his chances, Mr Jarrett said: "I am hoping that the Met would not be so vindictive as to say because he has written this book we will not promote him.
"These are the questions I am hoping that we, along with the Metropolitan Black Police Association, will be asking the Commissioner."
In a statement, Sir Ian: "I am confident that the candidates who have been selected will lead by example and promote confidence in the MPS and within our communities.
"The position of commander within the Met is tough and demanding and requires real dedication and commitment. The selection process was full and thorough and tested each candidate's ability at various stages."
Len Duvall, chairman of the MPA, insisted Mr Dizaei had been treated fairly at the promotion board.
"We categorically deny the Metropolitan Black Police Association's unwarranted attack on the integrity of our promotion process," he said.
"Their allegation of bias amounts to a charge of discrimination.
"That is wholly unsubstantiated and completely untrue. Our decisions on appointments were based, rationally and fairly, on merit."
Reader views (16)
Here's a sample of the latest views published.
Oh dear what a whimp! The traditional way of overcoming disappointment at being 'dipped' by a promotion board was to meet with your fellow losers in the pub, have a laugh and a drink, congratulate the 'winners' and say to fellow losers. "See you next year". Why does this nincompoop believe he is the one the board are fortunate to have before them? So far, he has had a good run and the odd setback might make him a better - and more humble - individual.
- Roy, Solihull, West Midlands
I wonder how many of the people contributing their comment against Mr Dizaei are current or previous serving police officers.
- Karl, London
Those of you who have made comment clearly did not read this story. What keeps this man from being qualified? According to the story, 1) ...he led one of the best performing boroughs in London and had been graded as "exceptional" in his personal performance assessment. 2) ...Mr Dizaei had completed his senior command course three years ago - achieving the highest marks - and yet has still not been promoted. 3) ...All nine other officers on the course have since been promoted to more senior roles. 4) ...In the last five years, there had been no promotions of senior black or Asian officers within the Met. Not to mention Mr. Dizaei was falsely accused of wrongdoing, and exonerated.
It appears that Mr. Dizaei is at least as qualified, if not more, than others who have been promoted, yet he has been continuously passed over? I don't believe it is Mr. Dizaei who has played the race card here.
I am a member of the National Black Police Association here in the States, as well as a law enforcement officer. Mr. Dizaei's story is one repeated over and over for officers all over the world. And your responses are the same ones that we hear when we protest wrongful treatment.
The truth of the matter: People of color are still marginalized and seen as less than, even when the proof indicates otherwise. Let's at least admit that truth, so that we can set up a forward-moving conversation that is inclusive of everyone.
- Sonia Pruitt, Maryland, USA
How dare he complain about being passed over. As others have pointed out, he is shamelessly playing the race card. Appointments should be based on ability - and loyalty for that matter. Colour of skin or ethnic background shouldn't come into it.
Mind you, the Police are very quick at pursuing the ordinary public for the most innocent and harmless references to race etc. I note the Chief Superintendent is legal adviser to the National Black Police Association. If that isn't a racist organisation, what is? Shouldn't the Police be doing something about that? I bet they would be up in arms if someone tried to set up a National White Police Association.
- Petrel, London, England
I may well be that the three men who got the job were the best men for the job.
- Mike Melbourne, Bedford
Promotion should be based on selecting the best candidate for the job and not on any other basis. If Mr Dizaei were a decent individual he would not expect to be selected for promotion on the basis of his race. I know many people who have not been offered jobs or bypassed for promotion when they are the best candidate as they do not tick one of the boxes; be it race/religion/disability etc.
- Michael, London
How much do you reckon this guy is going to receive in compensation?
- Jill, Granada, Spain
I completely agree with the below. It frustrates me greatly that the race card is played to try and force a promotion. What a horrible man. To suggest that such a serious promotion is based on race is ridiculous, this must be awarded on merit, and I applaud the MPA for making the correct decision.
- Gavin, London
Dezai appears to me to be a calculating opportunist, who will use the race card if it suits his purpose.
- Sej, Reading, UK
Thank goodness this good for nothing man got passed over for promotion - surely common sense is not breaking out at last! Well done the board for seeing through this loser.
- Shirley, London
At last. The most appropriate and to the point summary from Sir Ian.
I for one applaud his comments and believe it was right not to allow this self serving bully any further gain. How can the police, the civil service, or any organisation move forward being lead by individuals such as Mr Dezai who's motivation for self promotion is clearly and unashamedly set alongside sensitive agendas? The man's personality has been laid bare by the publication of the book, its timing, its content and his position. His position, in my view is barely tenable.
- Henry, Cambridge
Pathetic excuse for a policeman, just leave the job and do something else.
- Brian, Swindon
His book "Not one of Us" Should have been called "Just one of Me" and thankfully that is the case within the MET. Promotion will not restore public confidence in the police. He is a disgrace and because of pathetic management, the MET are stuck with him. I would be surprised if any other force he tries to transfer to accepts him. If the BPA had any sense they would adopt the Muslim Police Association view and distance themselves from him. I expect the next thing we will hear is how his failed promotion is related to racism.
- Chris, Kent UK
Judging by his own admissions in his ghost-written book that is currently being serialised, this sad self-publicist is deeply flawed and should not even be a Borough commander, let alone a member of the Met's senior management team.
For a change, the people of London have a sensible decision from the Metropolitan Police Authority.
- David, Cambridge, UK
Ali Dizaei more like Ali G.
It is pathetic posers like this PC, PC that kill off any ligering respect I have for the Police. They do little about the rampant drug dealing where I live yet pursue an agenda of political posturing.
- Dee, Newham
Stand by for someone's legal whining about this...
'Is it 'cos I is...'
- Ethan, UK
