Weather Tonight: 5°c Partly Cloudy Night Morning: 9°c Cloudy

News

BA apologises for First Class corpse

Last updated at 11:52am on 19.03.07

 Add your view

 

British Airways has apologised after First Class passengers on a flight from Delhi awoke to find crew had placed a corpse in their cabin.

Businessman Paul Trinder, 54, had dozed off in his £3000 First Class seat on the flight from Delhi to Heathrow, but awoke to a "commotion" in the darkened cabin.

He told how crew were moving what he later established was a person "like a sack of potatoes", positioning her in a seat on the other side of the cabin and seatbelting her in.

He then discovered it was the body of an Indian woman in her 70s who had died in economy class and been taken to the front of the plane where there was more room.

Mr Trinder said that the procedure was so farcical he thought he was the victim of a practical joke, explaining how the turbulence was causing the lifeless body to "rock and roll all over the place".

His concerns that she could have died of an infectious disease prompted no action and he spent the next five hours of the flight last month with the body across the aisle from him.

He later spoke to British Airways to question their procedure of handling deaths in flights - and was told to "get over it if you haven't got any better ideas", he said.

A spokesman for BA said that the body was moved to First Class as there was more space, allowing the grieving family as much privacy as possible.

He said: "It is always distressing when there is a death on board a flight.

"Fortunately such events are rare - in the region of ten deaths on board per annum from some 36 million passengers carried per annum.

"On this occasion, the flight was very busy, although there was space in the First Class cabin which allowed the family members travelling with the deceased some level of privacy in their grief.

"We apologise to passengers in the First cabin who were distressed by the situation - our cabin crew were working in difficult circumstances and chose the option that they believed would cause the least disruption.

"Procedures in the event of a death on board are dependent on the specific circumstances.

"However, all actions are governed primarily by issues of safety, for example, the deceased must not be placed in the galley or blocking aisles or exits, and there should be clear space around the deceased.

"The wishes of family or friends travelling with the deceased will always be considered, and account taken of the reactions of other passengers."

Describing the situation, Mr Trinder, from Brackley, Northamptonshire, said: "I woke up to find that all the window shutters were down. It was fairly dark and there was some commotion going in in the second isle away from me. The crew were moving an object which could have been a sack of potatoes for all I knew.

"It seemed an odd thing to be doing in the middle of the flight. The next thing we knew they were positioning what I had worked out was a person into a seat and putting a seat belt and blanket around her.

"It was quite a turbulent flight and every time there was a vibration in the plane she was rocking and rolling all over the place.

"They put a wall of pillows around her to keep her upright and stop her slipping out. I wondered if it was a practical joke because it was so badly done. I thought: 'This can't be the World's Favourite airline - is this really the procedure they have worked out?'

"I thought: 'What are the family's feelings in all of this - their mother being carried 50 rows like a sack of potatoes?'

"At first I didn't know she was dead. I went to the galley and I said, 'She doesn't look too well'. They said 'we did put out a call to the doctor but it was too late and she has expired'.

"I said, 'We have got five hours to go at room temperature'. I asked if they knew what she had died of, if it was an infectious disease. It could have been an airborne disease.

"You could tell they had never thought of it. They looked at each other open-mouthed but they didn't do anything about it.

"There could have been a risk of potential disease when the cause of death is not known. We didn't know if she had died from something like bird flu, for example, and then you get five hours of somebody in the early stages of death sharing your air.

"Other passengers had shocked expressions. The woman's family were clearly very upset.

"We finally got to Heathrow and nobody was allowed to leave to plane. The police and the coroner were sent on. There were police stopping people getting off.

"I thought: 'I have had enough, I want to go home'. I eventually got off an hour later."

Mr Trinder, chief executive of building manufacturers Capital Safety, said he later contacted BA to question their handling of the issue. The businessman, a BA gold card holder who travels 200,000 miles a year with the airline, said he was offered no compensation and told to "get over it".

"The ticket cost more than £3000. I wrote to BA later and said that this procedure can't be right, you have to do something better than this. Other airlines, for example, leave the deceased in place and move other people away from it.

"I then phoned them up and I was told the crew had done the right thing. I was told: 'You just have to get over it'.

"Before this flight I had had to change four flights because of the strike, and they just told me: 'Get over it, if you haven't got any better ideas we will stick with ours.

"People may dream of getting on a flight and waking up next to Tom Cruise for example, but the reality is you may not.

"I got really, really miffed with their whole procedure.

"I just think it could have been better done and I feel very sorry for the woman's family, who were under enormous stress and this wasn't the most brilliant performance of support.

"I just hope they improve their procedure, both for the sake of people directly concerned and other passengers."


Bookmark and Share
 
 

Reader views (11)

 Add your view

Quote: The wishes of family or friends travelling with the deceased will always be considered, and account taken of the reactions of other passengers.

I think this is what Mr. Trinder's concerns are related to - the fact that his reactions were not taken into account. Explaining the situation to other passengers, and possibly offering to move them to a place that would be more comfortable and less distressing might have been appropriate.

I don't see that the BA flight staff had much choice in how they dealt with the deceased woman, but how it affected other passengers seems to have only been paid lip service.

- Jason, Cork, 20/03/2007 17:45
Report abuse

Every time I watch films set on jets, there always seem to be big baggage compartments below the passenger compartments. Couldn't a body be moved down there? Or couldn't they move groups of economy passengers into 1st class? If I paid £3000 for a flight, I'd be mortified if a corpse was moved deliberately closer to me.

- Andrew, Mallorca, Spain, 19/03/2007 16:21
Report abuse

Agree with Jane completely. This man needs to get his head straight. Of course it wasn't pleasant for him but first class passengers are in the same tin box as the rest of them. The 'infectious disaease' point is ridiculous: if she had a disease she could communicate it living as much as dead. Sounds as if he has a problem getting too close to the rest of humanity. There may be plenty of reasons to avoid flying in general and BA in particular, but this episode doesn't change anything for me, except maybe to provide a further reason not to go first class - might run into someone like Mr T up there.

- Ben, Brussels, Belgium, 19/03/2007 14:19
Report abuse

I hold no brief for BA but Mr Trinder sounds like a complete whinger. There is clearly no perfect solution to the problem that the cabin staff encountered and their action, to place the body as far away as possible from as many passengers as possible, seems reasonable to me. The infectious disease question is irrelevant since the body has to be kept in the cabin somewhere, so everyone on the flight shares any risk of infection.

- Alan, London, 19/03/2007 14:13
Report abuse

I too had a terrible flight with BA once.

"I ain't getting on no 'plane/eating no goldfish crackers, you damn fool" etc.

Couldn't get any sleep whatsoever.

- David, London, England, 19/03/2007 14:07
Report abuse

I guess after reading this article I shouldn't be disappointed anymore when I don't get seated on the plane next to the blond I was starring at while waiting at the gate! Certainly, this article makes my plight seem pale in comparison to sitting next to a 'corpse'!

- Rob Lion, USA, 19/03/2007 14:04
Report abuse

Wonder if BA charged the family for the upgrade?

- Nighan, Anytown USA, 19/03/2007 13:47
Report abuse

How anyone can still fly with this horrendous airline is totally beyond me. Still, I suppose it's not the airline but rather the people who are the idiots. Well done BA. Again.

- Jay, London, 19/03/2007 13:44
Report abuse

What a selfish man this Trinder is. A passenger died on a flight leaving relatives in deep shock and grieving. The body had to be put somewhere. What exactly does he suggest? Lock it in a toilet compartment? Would he be happy to see his mother treated as such?
I doubt it.
The cabin crew did their very best in a difficult situation. Treating the berieved family with as much respect as possible. Mr Trinder and the rest of the first class cabin should have been removed to either business or economy and a refund in ticket price made after the flight. I am sure they would have been offered an alternate seat. My sister was a stewardess for many years and said it is standard procedure with all airlines to move the body to the first or business section of the plane and reseat the passengers elsewhere. Perhaps airlines should integrate a sub-floor coffin so as not to upset passengers in the event of a death. It is part of life - deal with it.

- Jane, London, 19/03/2007 13:29
Report abuse

When it comes to dealing with deceased Indian ladies, "Sari" seems to be the hardest word for BA.

- Keith, Farringdon, 19/03/2007 13:28
Report abuse

Not surprised at all by this. BA Business Class is appalling, expensive and service that wouldn't pass for Economy in most other airlines, so imagine First isn't much better.

- Emma, London, 19/03/2007 13:00
Report abuse


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.