Morning:
8°c
With a single dessert and just two glasses of wine our bill was kept in check - but the effort of doing so was not much fun
Latest: Gordon Brown apologises for his poor handwriting and for misspelling the name of a dead soldier in a letter to the young man’s mother
More...
At last, Blair admits he broke pledge on dentists
Last updated at 00:07am on 26.04.07
Tony Blair has admitted that New Labour has failed over its policy on NHS dentists
Tony Blair has finally admitted that Labour has failed in its key pledge to provide access for all to an NHS dentist.
The prime minister promised in 1999 that everyone would have an NHS dentist no matter where they lived within two years.
Eight years later, less than a half of the adult population is registered - a lower figure than when Labour took office.
Yet Mr Blair has never conceded that he had broken its promise to the electorate.
However, he was directly challenged at prime minister's question time by Liberal Democrat MP Mark Cheadle, who asked when he expected the promise to be fulfilled.
He replied: "It is and has been a real problem. I entirely accept that.
"The reason for it is very simple: even though we have increased the number of NHS dentists, we cannot stop dentists going outside the NHS if they wish to do so.
"They are entitled to do that and despite the fact that we are paying far more and hiring far more within the NHS, we have not been able to fulfil that pledge.
"However, the majority of people are actually within their area able to access an NHS dentist if they want to, but that is not 100 per cent - I accept that.
"It will only be dealt with ultimately by increasing still further the number of NHS dentists and that is what we intend to do."
Mr Blair personally promised in September 1999 to deal with the problem of disappearing dentists. He told the Labour conference that "everyone within two years will be able once again to see an NHS dentist, just by phoning NHS".
But the deadline passed without any improvement. In 2004, the extent of the crisis became apparent when more than 300 people in Scarborough famously queued from dawn to register with a newly-opened Dutch dentist.
Last month a survey by Citizens Advice found that around two million people in England who would like access to NHS dentistry are unable to do so.
Two thirds of them simply go without treatment rather than going private if they cannot find an NHS dentist.
Critics say the new dental contract, which came into force last year, has made the situation worse because dentists are leaving the NHS, angry at a new payment scheme they say does not effectively recompense them for work they do.
And two months ago it emerged that many dentists were turning patients away because they performed all the treatments they were contracted to provide too early in the financial year.
Shadow health secretary Andrew Lansley said: "Labour are still in denial at the scale of the problem. It is not just that less than 100 per cent of people can't access NHS dentistry. The reality is that in many places across the country, people can barely access and NHS dentist at all.
"In the last year since the new contract, things have got worse not better. We are heading towards a two-tier dentistry unless policies change."
Liberal Democrat health spokesman Sandra Gidley said: "The prime minister cannot shirk responsibility for the exodus of dentists from NHS work. It is very much his fault.
"It was his ill-thought out and rushed dental reforms which have caused so many dentists to opt out of the NHS and which left many dentists with no money to carry out NHS work just a few months ago.
"Rather than yet more empty promises, we need real action. The government must start listening to dentists' concerns and introduce more flexibility into the system, so that dentists have the resources to focus on prevention and getting treatment to groups currently missing out on dental care."
A spokeswoman for the Health Department said: "We are turning the corner in improving access to dentistry. However, in some cases, we accept that the change may not be happening as quickly as we would like.
"As the new arrangements settle down, there is clear evidence that the reforms are beginning to improve access."
Reader views (5)
If socialized health care is to include dentistry, then they should have NHS dental practices for people who wish to have NHS treatment. Private practices should be private, not a mix of both. It just leads to good people who can't afford quality dental treatment going without. These people have paid their contributions to the NHS like everyone else. Why should they have to lose their teeth or have dodgy ones because they simply can't afford to pay private dentist fees? Can't the government just open a practice for every borough and put the dentists on salary like the doctors at the hospital? Then they could fund the NHS practices from the money they are now paying private practices. Privatization is great for those who can afford it or want specialist treatment or cosmetic dentistry, but good basic dentistry should be available to anyone if this is to be public health care, what the National Health Service is anyway.
- Debbie, SE London
To Keith of London.
Dentists are well paid, and consequently pay a lot in taxes. That is the countries 'return on it's money'.
What bungling politicians choose to spend that revenue on is their business, but it's obvoiously not on funding a decent NHS service.
There is no 'National Service' for any other trade or profession, who are all educated at public expense. To inflict this on dentists would be a breach of human rights.
- Toothsmith, nth Yorks
Dentists are paid very well - they are just greedy. Do not forget they have been trained at great expense - all paid for by taxpayers who I believe are entitled to a return on their money.
- Keith, London
Oooh, this could be fun. Could all the other MPs challenge Tony each week on everything else he's failed to deliver? It might encourage him to leave sooner rather than later and end this ridiculously drawn out farewell tour stunt he's currently pulling.
- Marianne, SW France
"The reason for it is very simple: even though we have increased the number of NHS dentists, we cannot stop dentists going outside the NHS if they wish to do so."
Um, actually Mr Blair, you can, it involves paying dentists a decent wage.
- Trevor Roll, London
