Tonight:
4°c
A rioter who terrorised diners with an axe at McDonald's has been jailed for five years and three months - one of the toughest sentences for last summer's disturbances
More...
Mother invented 17 children to collect £30,000 in benefits
Last updated at 09:52am on 23.07.07
Charlene Ostle claimed that by the age of 26 she had given birth to three sets of twins and two sets of triplets
A mother who conned £30,000 in benefits by inventing 17 children has been spared jail as she suffers from post-natal depression and is pregnant with her third child.
Charlene Ostle claimed that by the age of 26 she had given birth to three sets of twins and two sets of triplets. At one point Ostle became so confused she told officials she had given birth to five children in three months.
At Carlisle Crown Court the barmaid, of Dearham, Cumbria, admitted nine charges of fraudulent activity between December 2003 and September 2006.
Recorder Arthur Noble said he was sparing her prison as an act of mercy and imposed a nine month jail term, suspended for two years.
The court heard that between April 2005 and December last year Ostle illegally claimed £18,893 in child tax credits. She must repay another £11,500 which had also been fraudulently claimed.
Giles Bridge, prosecuting for HM Revenue & Customs, told how Ostle made more than 400 calls to the tax credit helpline to amend the size of her fictitious family. In December 2003, while living in Cockermouth, she worked at a nursing home and submitted a genuine claim for child tax credit.
But within weeks she told officials that all of the children she was caring for were suffering from disabilities relating to diabetes. This allowed her to claim a higher level of tax credits, boosting her income.
During 2005 she said that six of the children she was caring for were her sisters. She was also, she claimed, looking after three of her own children, including her real daughter, now four.
Mr Bridge said: 'At that stage she was claiming tax credit for nine children. If she had maintained her claim for the whole year, she would have been entitled to £51,000, which would have been £760 per week.'
The highest number of children Ostle claimed for at any one time was ten.
Alison Whalley, defending, said her client endured a lack of support from her partner and that, combined with pride, left her unable to ask for help.
Revenue and Customs spokesman Joanne Pennington said: 'Those who think they can beat the system will be caught and brought to justice.'
Reader views (10)
Condescending male judges treating women as weak child-like creatures. Come on feminists where are the cries for equal treatment.
- Bernie, New Malden, 23/07/2007 22:36
Report abuse
Didn't anyone at these agencies realise that it is highly unlikely for someone to have so many children in such a short space of time? What's the chance of this money ever being recovered? The whole system is a sham. Yet another example of the incompetancy of the Labour government.
- Rebecca, London, 23/07/2007 18:41
Report abuse
I find it astonishing that nobody at the DHS picked up on this sooner! And does she have to pay this money back, or is she spared that punishment as well as prison?
- David Clancy, London, England, 23/07/2007 15:53
Report abuse
How can you suffer from post-natal depression, complain of a lack of support from a partner and then fall pregnant? I don't suppose there will be much of the overpayment paid back either.
- Jc, Billericay, Essex, 23/07/2007 14:11
Report abuse
Revenue and Customs spokesman Joanne Pennington said: 'Those who think they can beat the system will be caught and brought to justice.'
Hmmm well obviously not... this girl should have her children taken away, benefits withdrawn forever, locked up and ordered to repay what she took. This makes me sick! So I have to work hard and get what this scum gets for free in a year. Well done England - makes you proud!
- David Scott, London, 23/07/2007 13:38
Report abuse
She knew exactly what she was up to trying to con money from the taxpayer and hoping that no one would notice. I say jail her and show no mercy. Again, here you have someone conning their way out of any punishment by pulling the wool over soppy judges eyes who have no brain cells at all.
- Stephen D., London, England, 23/07/2007 11:49
Report abuse
That's a big deterrent then.
- Paul, London, 23/07/2007 10:00
Report abuse
Can't she be treated for post-natal depression in jail?
- Andy, London, 23/07/2007 09:43
Report abuse
Revenue and Customs spokesman Joanne Pennington said: 'Those who think they can beat the system will be caught and brought to justice.'
And a 2 year suspended sentence for 9 counts of fraud is what they consider justice I presume? The criminal justice system in this country is a joke.
- Trevor Roll, London, 23/07/2007 09:33
Report abuse
Long live new labour. Sometimes you really have to fight NOT to get the benefits paid to you!
- Jacqueline, Hampstead, London, 23/07/2007 07:51
Report abuse
