Morning:
20°c
Johnny Depp has become, in his young middle age, like a star of the movies’ golden period
Secret deal hatched by News of the World to hush up details of phone-tapping was sealed in a tiny room at the Royal Courts of Justice
More...
You're being dishonest about the EU, ex-minister tells Brown
Last updated at 23:52pm on 15.10.07
Under pressure: Gordon Brown is being urged to set out his 'vision'
One of the architects of the EU constitution yesterday denounced Gordon Brown's stance on the new treaty as 'patently dishonest'.
Gisela Stuart, a former Labour minister, spoke out as it became clear the Government was ready to accept the treaty as it stands without offering a referendum on the issue.
Labour rebels are canvassing possible support for a public vote on the treaty as the debate moves to Parliament.
Four former ministers - Miss Stuart, Frank Field, Kate Hoey and Graham Stringer - and 40 other Labour MPs are ready to defy Mr Brown, according to party sources.
The Prime Minister heads to Lisbon on Thursday to finalise the contents of the document with other EU leaders.
After private talks with Foreign Secretary David Miliband in Luxembourg yesterday,
Gisela Stuart: Red herrings
Manuel Lobo Antunes said: "The UK is happy with this text. They made an important intervention in favour of the treaty so I don't see any major problems."
The developments prompted Miss Stuart to warn the Prime Minister his refusal to offer a referendum was dangerously 'out of touch' with what the majority of voters wanted.
Her intervention is particularly surprising as she was the Government's-representative on the EU committee which drew up the original blueprint.
She dismissed the Government's much-vaunted 'red lines' - giving it a series of exemptions from the treaty - as 'red herrings'.
She said they had all been in the previous version of the constitution, on which Labour promised a referendum in 2005.
And she warned Mr Brown against creating a 'contrived row' over the red lines in an attempt to suggest he had scored a victory over other EU leaders.
Miss Stuart, the MP for Edgbaston, took colleagues aback with the strength of yesterday's attack.
Writing for the Daily Mail's sister paper, the London Evening Standard, she insisted: "It's a matter of trust and integrity.
A referendum was promised. It should be delivered. If Labour can't trust the people, why should the people trust Labour?"
Miss Stuart told Mr Brown he was already 'in a hole' and should 'stop digging' rather than 'digging another one on Europe'.
She added: "When he entered Number 10, Gordon Brown sought to present himself as a national leader focused on serious issues, offering a new style of politics - engaging and listening to people and involving them in important decisions.
"Recent events have shown some rather old-style politics, with the Prime Minister looking indecisive and lacking veracity.
"To pretend that Labour was not gearing up for an election or that opinion polls played no part in the decision to postpone it was silly and gave David Cameron some of his most damaging ammunition."
Miss Stuart said Mr Brown could not hope to restore his 'dented authority' unless he honoured Labour's promise to hold a referendum on the EU treaty.
She said she believed the Prime Minister's 'Praetorian Guard' of close advisers would argue that strong leadership meant 'hunkering down'.
She also predicted that they were committed to 'ramming' the treaty through Parliament using the Government's substantial majority.
But she added: "Sticking to your guns in defence of a patently dishonest position is not leadership, but the soft option, and a cop-out from a specific promise made to voters."
She dismissed Mr Brown's argument that a referendum was not needed on the new treaty as it was different from the now abandoned constitution.
She said the new document had '90-95 per cent' of the same content as the old one.
The treaty would create the first long-term president of the EU from 2009, as well as an all-powerful EU foreign policy chief.
It would also abolish Britain's right to veto EU proposals in 50 policy areas.
Is this why Falconer is gunning for Brown?
Lord Falconer is squaring up to Gordon Brown over his failure to secure a six-figure pension.
After the former Lord Chancellor wrote an article pointedly urging the Prime Minister to set out his vision for Britain, it emerged he was arguing with Downing Street over the size of his pension.
Lord Falconer is angry with the pension that Gordon Brown secured for him
He held heated discussions with the Prime Minister at Downing Street to try to convince him he deserved a more generous retirement pot.
Sources in Westminster have warned that he could take legal action if Mr Brown continues to block a deal.
As Lord Chancellor he was entitled to an annual salary and a pension higher than that of any other minister, including the Prime Minister.
But when he accepted the role in a reshuffle in June 2003 he opted for a standard Cabinet salary – worth £104,386 last year – rather than the £232,900 to which he was entitled. Consequently, he lost a chunk of his pension which he is now trying to reclaim.
Lord Falconer is understood to be unhappy that the Cabinet Office has ruled he is entitled only £52,193 a year.
One friend of the peer said: "Unlike some of his contemporaries, he did not spend years earning a fortune at the bar."
Reader views (14)
Here's a sample of the latest views published.
I'm curious, this is about Britain being part of the EU? Presumably the Scotttish parliament can call their own referendum on this issue? In which case why exactly are we letting a Scotsman sell us down the river?
- Trevor Roll, London
If by "thoughtful" Sam, you mean he thought he should and then he thought he should not hold an election based on Polls and not what was best for his country, and that he thought the people of the United Kingdom should not have a vote on destroying 400 years of Parliamentary sovereignty, then I would prefer someone less "thoughtful" thanks very much.
- Stephen Rothbart, Prague, Czech Republic
This traitor won't be happy until all of Britain is ruled from Brussels.
We have to get rid of him even if it involves rioting in the streets.
- Dave, London
Blair said he did not have a reverse gear, but here's hoping Brown does or the only election we will see in the immediate future is another one for the leadership of Nu-Labour. The public are not going to take no for an answer over the Referendum on the EU Treaty(Constitution).
Just remember it was only France and Holland who saved Tony's bacon over the original EU Constitution, or his leadership would have gone chipolatas much before it did.
- Robert, Kirk Ella, East Yorks.,
I find Falconers demands for a huge pension highly offensive, it is clear that he has enjoyed the "champagne socialist" lifestyle- his reduced pension will clearly mean more money that can go to our essential key worker frontline services and will most certainly NOT be used to pay MPs more in expenses.
- John Graham, London, UK
Surely nobody in their right mind honestly expects a politician to tell the truth.
- Lezl, London UK
He's been rumbled...
- Ian, London
Gordon is finding it a bit harder being in the tent rather than on the outside looking in!
- Paul, London
Can we please stop this endless analysis of polls. The results have no true meaning and the analysis is worse than spin. Brown should be left to get on with it until at least next summer so all the parties can come up with some joined up thinking. Or have we got dumbed down politicans to go with the dumbed down 'A' levels and degrees?
- Michael, London
Poor Lord Falconer. I can imagine an uprising amongst OAPs desperately worried that he won't be able to get by on a mere £52,193 a year. Can someone remind me what the standard state pension is?
- Warren Alexander, London, UK
Both inside as outside of his Nu Labor party is the man disliked profoundly. He has been by far the worst leader this country has had.
- Stephen, London
Getting with the job is all he ever seems to say. When is he actually going to do the job? Otherwise, please make way for a fresher and more able Team Cameron!
- Tom, St. Albans
It is not difficult to snipe at Gordon Brown: everything he does seems to be bungled. I have never seen such a poor PM. Raising taxes was easy hey Brown? Everything else he has to do like lead government he is obviously not good at.
- Georgie, Islington, London
The dour and somewhat more thoughtful Brown is far preferable than those superficial imbeciles devoted to Blair. Hopefully, the Blarites will be consigned to the political dustbin where they belong.
- Sam, London
