Weather Tonight: 9°c Light showers Morning: 14°c Overcast

Critics' Choice

Film

Andrew O'Hagan

quoteNew Moon is nothing if not an international advertisement for the hungry virtues of virginity and young people can’t get enough of itquote

Andrew O'Hagan The Twilight Saga: New Moon Theatre

Henry Hitchings

quoteA smart, prickly and rewarding view of sexual and emotional confusionquote

Henry Hitchings Cock Restaurants

David Sexton

quoteKitchen W8 is a bargain for this area, if such sophistication is what you crave quote

David Sexton Kitchen W8

Reader reviews

Film

Adam, Harrow

quoteToo long and drawn out but very entertaining with excellent special effectsquote

2012 Theatre

Rob, London

quoteThis is a peculiar play and does not work for me. Some of it is very funny but there are real flawsquote

The Habit Of Art Music

Bernard, London

quoteAlex has a strong powerful voice and was faultless, she is far better now than she was on the X-Factorquote

Alexandra Burke

Family's fury as girl, 12, allowed to have sex-change operation without against father's wishes

Last updated at 15:47pm on 25.05.08

 Add your view

 



schoolgirls

Row: A judge has decided a 12-year-old girl can have a sex change against her father's wishes (picture posed by models)

A huge ethical row has erupted over a judge's decision to allow a 12- year-old girl to have a sex change that will turn her into a teenage boy.

The child's father, who is separated from her mother, is outraged at the prospect but despite his objections the taxpayer-funded sex swap has already got under way.

His daughter, who cannot be named because of her age, is already having hormone treatment in Australia in what is one of the first such cases involving a child so young.

The girl has also been given permission to apply for a new birth certificate, passport and medical card in a boy's name.

Last night, a relative of the child claimed the girl had been 'vindictively brainwashed' by her mother into making the decision to have the change.

A cousin who stayed with the girl's family for two and a half years said yesterday that after a bitter break-up the mother had used the child to 'get back' at the father.

'She's been brainwashed from an early age,' said the cousin, who has to remain anonymous to protect the Victorian girl's identity.

'The mother drilled into the girl from an early age that she would have preferred a boy.'

Now the father, who considers his daughter is far too young to make a decision on her gender, is appealing to Melbourne's legal fraternity for help in fighting the case after he ran out of money to afford representation in opposing the sex swap request.

The Victorian Family Court was told that the girl had always considered herself a boy and was at risk of self harm if she continued to develop into a woman.

Hormones now being implanted under the 12-year-old's skin every three months will stop her from developing from a child into a woman, including preventing her hips and breasts from growing.

A further court application must be lodged in coming years for testosterone treatment to deepen the girl's voice and promote growth of facial hair and muscles.

Surgery to remove her womb or ovaries or build an artificial male sex organ must wait until she is at least 18.

The court was told that the hormone therapy was reversible and would give the family 'breathing time' with progressive sex change treatments and operations requiring further court orders.

'I question how reversible the treatment is,' said the cousin. 'There will be psychological consequences that are not reversible.

'I don't think the side effects have been adequately considered. How people treat her will have an effect.

'She will never have this time in her life again.'

News of the judge's decision to grant the sex-change treatment has sparked furious debate.

Medical ethicist Dr Nicholas Tonti-Filippini described the ruling as 'astounding'.

He added: 'I fail to see how it can be in the interests of a young girl to undergo treatment that will change her for the rest of her life.



Bookmark and Share
 
 

Reader views (4)

 Add your view

What a disgusting thing to do to a child! that selfish mother. She's making her daughter feel bad because she isn't a boy. I'm serious what kind of SICK world do we live in!

- Penguin, F-USA

I know what this young girl is going through as I went through it as well. Since the age of 4 (that I can remember), I knew I should have a female body -- to coincide with my female mind. I wish I knew then what I know now, and that the resources available to her were available to me before puberty. I wish him well and hope all works out for him.

- Tami, Marysville, USA

Please someone tell me that I just didn't read what I thought I read.What a hard decision she will probably regret what she had done. I feel so sorry for her dad.

- Amar, Thomastown, Australia

This is outrageous and wrong. How can it transpire?

The father should have veto rights and secondly, what makes the little girl think that she'll have a better life as a man after seeing what little rights men and fathers have nowadays?

This act will haunt the girl as she matures, and her opinions on things in life change. She will wish someone like her father stopped it from happening. What a serious decision at 12?

At the least, she'll never be happy with the plumbing and the way it turned out.

- A, USA


Add your comment

 

Your email address will not be published

Terms and conditions make text area bigger You have  characters left.


 
 


 
 
London's Weather
Tonight
Light showers
9°c
Morning
Overcast
14°c
5 day forecast
 
 

Daily Mail Mail on Sunday Travel Mail This is Money Metro

Loot | Jobsite | Homes & property | London jobs | FindaProperty.com | Primelocation.com | Educate London | Holiday Villas