Weather Tonight: 4°c Partly Cloudy Night Morning: 8°c Cloudy

Critics' Choice

Restaurants

Fay Maschler

quoteWith a single dessert and just two glasses of wine our bill was kept in check - but the effort of doing so was not much funquote

Fay Maschler Babbo Film

Andrew O'Hagan

quoteThis is a film with beautiful performances and a visual style that urges you towards reflectionquote

Andrew O'Hagan Bright Star Theatre

Henry Hitchings

quoteAlthough the first half of Kwei-Armah’s production is pacy, funny and intelligent, the energy level then drops offquote

Henry Hitchings Seize The Day

Reader reviews

Film

Squiz, Islington

quoteI loved this film from start to finish. Take the girlfriend, tell your mum - I'd see it again tomorrow and will buy the dvd.quote

An Education Theatre

Joe, London

quoteI saw this last night and can't remember the last time I was so moved in the theatre.quote

This Much Is True Restaurants

Hiroshi Sugiyama

quoteI have been to many of London's so-called best Japanese restaurants and none have been as good as the food that I've had at Aqua Kyotoquote

Aqua Kyoto

Mother awarded £800,000 after 'six pints of water a day detox diet' left her brain damaged

Last updated at 14:05pm on 25.07.08

 Add your view

 


A dieter suffered permanent brain damage after being advised to drink six pints of water a day and cut salt intake to lose weight.

Dawn Page, 52, has been awarded £810,000 in damages from her nutritionist, although the practitioner denies fault.

Mother of two Mrs Page, who weighed 12st, became ill within days of taking up the Amazing Hydration Diet.

Dawn Page

Brain damaged: Dawn Page became ill within days of taking up the Amazing Hydration Diet

She had been told by the nutritionist to drink four extra pints of water a day and drastically reduce her salt intake.

The first stage of the regime left her suffering from severe vomiting and stomach cramps, but she was told these were just part of the detoxification process.

She was then told by her nutritionist to increase the amount of water to six pints and consume still less salt.

Days later she suffered a massive epileptic fit and brain damage caused by severe sodium deficiency.

Barbara Nash

Settlement: Nutritional therapist Barbara Nash

It has left her with 'cognitive deficit' which affects her memory, concentration and speech and she suffers frequent mood swings.

She has been forced to give up her job as a conference organiser and has relied on her husband Geoff, 54, for help since going on the diet in 2001.

Practitioner Barbara Nash, who refers to herself as a 'nutritional therapist and life coach', continues to deny any fault following the payout from her insurance company, which was made without mention of liability. 

The award was ratified by High Court in London at a hearing on Friday.

Yesterday Mr Page warned others of the dangers of 'fad' diets.

Speaking from the family home in Faringdon, Oxfordshire, he said: 'She was not obese or even mildly obese, but like a lot of women, Dawn liked to look after her weight.

'She had tried Weight Watchers and calorie control diets.

This was just another potential route for her to lose weight. Her life has been seriously affected, perhaps ruined, by this fad-type way of losing weight, which I can only say is a
dangerous method of weight loss.'

Mrs Page had paid £50 for a consultation with Mrs Nash. But less than seven days later she was struck down with stomach cramps and sickness.

She contacted the nutritionist about the side effects, but was assured that vomiting was a normal part of the detox programme.

In October 2001, Mrs Page collapsed at home with a serious epileptic fit and was rushed to hospital in Swindon where doctors diagnosed a shortage of plasma sodium levels.

The salt-rich plasma acts as a protective layer around the brain, but because Mrs Page's contained such low levels of the mineral, water had entered the brain, causing permanent damage.

Page

Dependent: Dawn Page has relied on husband Geoff since her severe epileptic fit in 2001

Since the fit, she has had to rely on written notes to remember basic instructions, and finds it hard to recall simple information.

Mr Page, a project manager for a packaging company, said: 'Everything's so difficult for her now. She can't comprehend what's being said or relate to what's going on around her.

'She can't drive, can't work, and takes medication every day and will for the rest of her life.'

Mr Page, who launched the six and a half year legal action, added: 'It's important that people understand how dangerous diets like these are, and not to enter into them without knowing all the dangers.'

Mrs Nash, who is based in Wheatley, Oxfordshire, has a diploma of natural nutrition gained from the College of Natural Nutrition, based in Tiverton, Devon. She was unavailable to comment last night.

Plexus Law, the firm which represented her in court, released a statement after the hearing, which read: 'We wish to make it clear that all allegations of substandard practice made on behalf of Mrs Page in the litigation have always been and continue to remain firmly denied.

'In our view as a recognition of this, the settlement amount agreed to be paid was less than half of the total amount claimed and the compromise which was offered and accepted was on the basis of no admission of liability.'

Warning on 'Hydration'

Hydration diets are sometimes prescribed to those suffering from fluid retention, which can cause weight gain in the fingers, ankles and legs.

Fluid retention can be caused by the kidneys not working properly and it is thought some nutritionists claim additional water can ‘kick start’ the kidneys.

But registered dietician Nigel Denby said: ‘If hydration ever leads to weight loss, it is simply because the extra water makes you less inclined to eat because you feel full.

Hydration diets do not work. I have no idea what the reduction of sodium is supposed to achieve, but no qualified professional would recommend this sort of diet.’

A serious loss of sodium can lead to weakness, dizziness, memory loss and nausea.

If the deficiency becomes severe, the circulatory system can collapse and the body can go into shock, causing fatigue, muscle twitching and fits.


Bookmark and Share
 
 

Reader views (13)

 Add your view

This registered guy is saying 'hydration diets don't work' and that 'no qualified professional would recommend this sort of diet.' I m super hydrating at the moment drinking around 4 litres a day. Difference is i m also taking mineral salts such as sodium along with the water making it alkaline water. I also add to this water a green drink so I m getting all the nutrition I need so I m not deficient. The aim of the detox diet is too cleanse the body of acids, not drag fluid from the body by lowering salt to lose water and therefore weight. I have been doing this for 6 days and have not eaten anything. I feel amazing and am full of energy. Its just a cleanse that lasts about a week to give your liver a break and cleanse your colon. I'll let you in on a secret. Our bodies run on salt water (sodium), not sugar, caffeine, carbs, protein etc.

- Ken, Scotland

This is exactly why people should be wary of so called "Nutritionist" especially in the fitness industry. Most personal trainers or fitness gurus do half day or at most 2 days nutrition module and are advised not to give specific nutrition advice to clients, but because it's such a competitive business, they all sell themselves as nutrition experts. Please ask what qualifications they have before doing any specific diets they recommend. One such diets that is very common in gyms is the metabolic typing diet, which has no scientific basis.

- Veronica, London

I don't understand why on earth people think that faddy diets are safe? Why not just eat properly (including all 5 essential nutrients your body needs) instead of consulting women's mags and chomping back diet pills? Oh because you won't lose a stone in a week and because some effort and will power is involved. Come on people, use your brains! The lengths people will go to for the sake of vanity these days is unbelievable.

- Kitty, London

If you are desperate about your weight you are more likely to lose perspective and try anything and believe people who tell you that the nonsense you are doing to yourself will make you lose weight. Beware the charlatans who will pray on such people.

- Charlotte, london

Why did she not just go to Weight Watchers! Doesn't take a genius to tell yourself to stop something if you are being sick. People need to take responsibility for their own actions!

- Charlie, London

"Detoxing" as a diet is a complete fad. You have a liver and kidneys for a reason - they remove toxins from your body - you don't store them. Duh.

- Sb, London

Well looks like the diet didn't work?

- Brandon Thomas, London UK

Common-sense should always prevail in anything new you undertake-she should have stopped as soon as she realised something was wrong-sudden change can be hard for the body to adjust to-the body always tells you what it needs. There is water in everything you eat

- A Matharu, hayes, uk

There's a difference between drinking a recommended amount of 2 litres a day and keeping your salt down and drinking 4 litres plus and cutting out salt from your diet. The more water you drink, the less sodium in your body and your heart needs sodium to function. Its a balance, but the whole thing about detox is that its unnecessary, the body detoxes normally anyway. This woman should have just done weight watchers or something similar. We are all obsessed with quick fixes these days.

- Louise, Essex

Ca Metcalfe, by being even slightly overweight you are putting pressure on your body. This may not necessarily have been an obsession to be thin, more an obsession to be healthy. This should be encouraged, but in healthy ways. If only people would try incorporating a bit of exercise into their daily lives there would be no need for fad diets.

This lady was apparently 12 stone and as far as can be told from the picture is not abnormally tall. So I guess you could say that she was overweight and was obviously not happy about it.

- Bb, S.E London

I find this story so bizzare.
We are always being told to cut down on salt and drink plenty of water.

- Mark Vincent, London

Her poor family.
This obsession with thinness is to be deplored and discouraged.

- Ca Metcalfe, UK

If you start throwing up, your body is telling you something. Someone recently died from excess water - drinking 8 litres a day and throwing up then forcing more water down his neck. Why do people do this kind of thing? Why don't they just add fruit and veg to their diet and let nature do the rest?

- Neil, london uk, Airstrip ONE .


Add your comment

 

Your email address will not be published

Terms and conditions make text area bigger You have  characters left.


 
 


 
 
London's Weather
Tonight
Partly Cloudy Night
4°c
Morning
Cloudy
8°c
5 day forecast
 
 

Daily Mail Mail on Sunday Travel Mail This is Money Metro

Loot | Jobsite | Homes & property | London jobs | FindaProperty.com | Primelocation.com | Educate London | Holiday Villas