Weather Tonight: 10°c Heavy rain Morning: 12°c Sunny spells

Critics' Choice

Film

Andrew O'Hagan

quoteNew Moon is nothing if not an international advertisement for the hungry virtues of virginity and young people can’t get enough of itquote

Andrew O'Hagan The Twilight Saga: New Moon Theatre

Henry Hitchings

quoteA smart, prickly and rewarding view of sexual and emotional confusionquote

Henry Hitchings Cock Restaurants

David Sexton

quoteKitchen W8 is a bargain for this area, if such sophistication is what you crave quote

David Sexton Kitchen W8

Reader reviews

Film

Adam, Harrow

quoteToo long and drawn out but very entertaining with excellent special effectsquote

2012 Theatre

Rob, London

quoteThis is a peculiar play and does not work for me. Some of it is very funny but there are real flawsquote

The Habit Of Art Music

Bernard, London

quoteAlex has a strong powerful voice and was faultless, she is far better now than she was on the X-Factorquote

Alexandra Burke

Businessman awarded £22,000 in landmark libel ruling over malicious fake Facebook profile

Last updated at 21:13pm on 24.07.08

 Add your view

 




General pic of someone logging onto Facebook

Matthew Firscht was awarded £22,000 after former friend Grant Raphael created a false Facebook profile

A company boss was awarded £22,000 in damages today over fake entries posted on Facebook. It is thought to be the first successful defamation and privacy law case involving the social networking site in the UK.

A false profile of Matthew Firscht, 38, was created in June last year by Grant Raphael, a cameraman, which wrongly said he was signed up to gay groups and had lied to avoid paying loans.

Mr Firscht's lawyers contacted Facebook and found through the profile's internet address the entries had been made from Mr Raphael's computer at his home in Hampstead, North London.

Awarding Mr Firscht and his company £22,000 in damages, a High Court judge yesterday ruled that the defence had been 'built on lies'.

Judge Richard Parkes QC said that Mr Raphael was liable for the internet entries and had lied about the posts.

The pair had been friends, who went to school in Brighton together, before working in Mr Firscht's joint TV production company Power House.

They fell out in 2000 when Mr Firscht took his friend's advice to resign from the company only to find out Mr Raphael had moved into his offices shortly after his departure.

Mr Firscht believed that his former cameraman had profited from his resignation and they stopped talking to each other.

He later when on to found Applause Store, which finds audience members for radio and television shows.

Of the false Facebook entry, Mr Firscht, said: 'What Mr Raphael did was extremely offensive, embarrassing and may have caused serious damage to the reputation of myself and Applause Store, which I have spent years building into what it is today.

'The case never needed to go this far. Had Mr Raphael owned up at the beginning and apologised, the matter could have been dealt with without the need for a lengthy and distressing legal process. 

'Instead, Mr Raphael stuck his head in the sand and will now have to pay the consequences for having lied to both myself and the court. 

'I hope that this judgment will at least send a warning out to users of Facebook and other social networking websites that they cannot recklessly post defamatory and private material with immunity. 

'Having been vindicated by the court, I now look forward to getting on with my life and putting this episode behind me.'

Mr Firscht learnt of the fake profile in July last year when his brother Simon spotted it 16 days after it had been first posted.

The profile said he was signed up to groups on the site including 'Gay in the Wood.....Borehamwood' and 'Gay Jews in London'.

Another group, 'Has Matthew Firscht lied to you?', claimed he owed large sums of money but regularly made 'pathetic excuses' to avoid payment.

Facebook staff were alerted and deleted the offending profile and groups.

Mr Raphael claimed that the entries had been made by strangers who turned up to an impromptu party at his flat on June 19 and 20.

Judge Parkes said: 'This is an unfortunate dispute between two former friends.

'It seems to be the overwhelming fact that the defendant has lied from the whole beginning about his alibi of production of the Facebook profiles and groups.

'His behaviour does take this case out of the norm. I do take the conduct of the defendant as particularly culpable.'

The ruling is expected to affect the online community who have been more immune to privacy and libel laws in this country compared to newspapers.

Mr Firscht's lawyer, Ashley Hurst, said: 'This decision is likely to send shock waves amongst the social networking community.

'There are many similar instances of libel and breach of privacy which go unchecked every day.

'People need to realise that libel and privacy laws in the UK apply just as much to online media as they do to newspapers. 

'The case also goes to show that with a combination of sophisticated tracing techniques, use of the court process and careful assembly of evidence, anonymous users of the internet can be brought to justice.'

Facebook became a worldwide phenomenon in 2006 and is the seventh most popular site on the internet. In May, it attracted 129.3 million visitors.

MPs raised concerns that the site could fuel bullying by allowing insults to be traded anonymously.

Some members said they received hate mail and death threats. Others reported being sent insults and comments about their weight, looks and sex lives.


Bookmark and Share
 
 

Reader views (4)

 Add your view

I ve known a few people like that. Will do any thing they think they can get away with. Nice to see one get his just desserts.

- Adamrussell, sierra vista, usa

At last a measure of justice.

- Jim Stickann, Schererville, IN, USA

Lesson learned: If you're gonna do something like this, don't do it from your home computer!

- Damian Woodland, London

You lie - you should pay. Lots of nasty things you can say about someone before you cross that line into libel and defamation. And if the truth is not sufficient, maybe neither is your anger.

- Justa Thought, Indiana, USA


Add your comment

 

Your email address will not be published

Terms and conditions make text area bigger You have  characters left.


 
 


 
 
London's Weather
Tonight
Heavy rain
10°c
Morning
Sunny spells
12°c
5 day forecast
 
 

Daily Mail Mail on Sunday Travel Mail This is Money Metro

Loot | Jobsite | Homes & property | London jobs | FindaProperty.com | Primelocation.com | Educate London | Holiday Villas