Critics' Choice

Film

Derek Malcolm

quoteIt beats most of this summer's blockbuster entertainments into pulpquote

Derek Malcolm Hellboy II: The Golden Army Restaurants

Fay Maschler

quoteYou know that fusion works when you eat something and you think why has this not been done before?quote

Fay Maschler The Modern Pantry Music

John Aizlewood

quoteJames Yorkston is the quietly rising future of folk-tinged British songwritersquote

John Aizlewood James Yorkston

Reader reviews

Film

Ben S, London

quoteThis new animated Star Wars movie is much better than final Star Wars prequel quote

Star Wars: The Clone Wars Restaurants

Chris, London

quoteThe service is awful, much worse than somewhere like Wagamamasquote

Cha Cha Moon Music

Derrick, London

quote'Tuku' was excellent. The show was above expectations ... hope you come back againquote

Oliver Mtukudzi

Painter given £30 fine for smoking 'at work'...in his own van

Last updated at 00:28am on 25.07.08

 Add your view

 


For painter and decorator Gordon Williams, his van is simply a means of getting from A to B.

But council officials chose to give the vehicle a more lofty status.

When they spotted him behind the wheel with a cigarette, they handed him an on-the-spot fine of £30 - for smoking in his place of work.

Gordon Williams

Fined: Gordon Williams, 58, was given a penalty for smoking in his van when council officials declared he was 'at work'

Mr Williams, 58 and self-employed, had finished work for the day and was driving to the shops to buy some teabags when the council official pulled him over.

'I was told that because my van is my place of work I had broken the smoking laws.

'I was dumbfounded - the van is only insured for private use and to get me to and from work.

'It's not my place of work - I decorate houses not vans.'

Mr Williams, who lives with his wife Sue near Aberystwyth in Wales, was driving on the A487 near his home in his unmarked blue Suzuki Carry when he was stopped by council officials.

He was travelling with a 16-year-old family friend who had been helping him at work and was also smoking a cigarette.

'They were pulling in vans and commercial vehicles,' said Mr Williams.

'I'm not sure what sort of offences they were looking for but when they saw me with a fag in my hand, that was it.

'The council official was not a very nice man. There was no warning or reminder of the new laws - I was handed a fixed penalty notice and that was it.'

He believes it could be the first ticket of its kind handed out by Ceredigion Council since the smoking regulations came in last year - the fixed penalty notice was number 0001.

Simon Clark, director of smoking rights group Forest, said: 'This smacks of some jobsworth council official interpreting the law to the most extreme level.

'This surely is not what the change in the law was intended for - it was not meant to harass and persecute people going about their ordinary lives.

'It is ridiculous that someone should be fined for smoking in their own private vehicle away from any workplace.'

Mr Williams is now planning to appeal, even though his wife has already paid the fine.

She explained: 'If it wasn't paid on a certain time it doubled so I went to the council offices and gave them the £30.'

Mr Williams, who has not smoked in his van since the fine, added: 'I respect anyone who chooses not to smoke but I would also ask for the same respect to have the freedom to smoke in my own private vehicle.'

Ceredigion Council yesterday said they could not comment on individual cases but a spokesman said: 'There are very few exemptions to the smoking ban.

'It affects most public premises, including work vehicles.'

A spokesman for the Welsh Assembly explained the rules which led to Mr Williams's fine.

He said: 'The regulations state that a vehicle shall be smoke-free if it is used for work by more than one person - regardless of whether they are in the vehicle at the same time.'


 

Reader views (11)

 Add your view | Show all

Here's a sample of the latest views published. You can click view all to read all views that readers have sent in.

And this is supposed to be a free country?

If the van is privately owned and insured then you should have the right to smoke as many cigarettes as you like whilst inside it.
If that was me, I would not have paid the fine. Its a pity our council officials have nothing better to do than harass citizens over nothing at all.

- Adam, Wisbech

Are the Beagles in the cigarette factory still allowed to smoke at work?

- Arthur Pantry, London, England

There are many laws that apply on or in people's personal property. This is just another chance for smelly addicts to whinge. I for one am sick of the smell of their smoke.

- Philip, London, England


Add your comment

Show all

 

Your email address will not be published

Terms and conditions make text area bigger You have  characters left.


 


 
 

Mickey Clark podcasts on today's City markets - download now

London's Weather
Afternoon
Cloudy
23°c
Tonight
Mostly cloudy
16°c
5 day forecast
 
 

Daily Mail Mail on Sunday Travel Mail This is Money Metro

Loot | Jobsite | Homes & property | London jobs | FindaProperty.com | Primelocation.com | Educate London | Holiday Villas