Weather Tonight: 11°c Clear Night Morning: 20°c Mostly cloudy

Critics' Choice

Film

Andrew O'Hagan

quoteJohnny Depp has become, in his young middle age, like a star of the movies’ golden periodquote

Andrew O'Hagan Public Enemies Music

André Paine

quotethis was a triumph of eye-popping production and exhausting choreographyquote

André Paine Madonna Theatre

Fiona Mountford

quoteIf his smug stage persona is tricky to warm to, his skill, and the snappiness of Andy Nyman’s direction, are spot-onquote

Fiona Mountford Derren Brown

Reader reviews

Film

Russell. Hertfordshire

quoteIf you are feeling totally fed up with your lot at the moment with the economic squeeze - go see this filmquote

Sunshine Cleaning Theatre

Heather, London

quoteI thought this was an excellent, powerful production. The staging and acting were superb, it is well worth going to seequote

Observe The Sons Of Ulster Marching Towards The Somme Music

Debbie & Bill Holmes

quoteAbsolutely AMAZING show that went like a train for three hours solid and didn't waiver once!quote

Bruce Springsteen And The E Street Band

Olympic singer row: 'Ugly' youngster may get a spot at closing ceremony

Last updated at 13:18pm on 13.08.08

 Add your view

 


The little Chinese girl who was stopped from appearing at the Olympic opening ceremony because she was too ugly could be given a role at the closing celebrations after a public outcry, it has been revealed.

News of the last-minute switch that put Lin Miaoke centre stage at what was likely one of the most watched performances in history is the latest embarrassment for games organizers who have gone to extraordinary lengths to ensure the event goes off flawlessly.

In a sparkling red dress, Miaoke soared on wires above 91,000 people attending the ceremony and mouthed the words to "Ode to the Motherland."

Enlarge Olympics

Faker: Lin Miaoke, right, who lip-synched at the opening ceremony at the Bejing Olympics over the voice of Yang Peiyi

But the voice heard by the crowd and by a worldwide television audience estimated to be in the billions was that of 7-year-old Yang Peiyi, who was pulled from the performance after the final dress rehearsal because she did not have the right look, a senior official said.

"Yang Peiyi's looks are OK," Lin Hui, the father of Miaoke, told reporters. "In my opinion, she's not ugly. She looks cute."

Photos of Peiyi on a blog by her tutor show a typically pretty girl in a white dress with a pink clip in her hair. She appears to be losing her milk teeth, and her two front teeth are only partially grown, at slightly awkward angles.

Olympic officials faced a barrage of questions on Wednesday about the switch, and the families and other representatives of both girls said the two would not be available to speak to news media.

Olympics

Fly-past: Lin Miaoke performs during the opening ceremony

The issue was being widely debated on the Internet in China and on the streets of Beijing, where many people felt the two separate roles should not have been kept secret and that Peiyi should be included in the glitzy closing ceremony scheduled for August 24.

"I don't agree with the decision because they are kids and it may scar them for life," said Li Lin, 41, a marketing worker in Beijing.

"I think the girl with the voice should have a chance to perform at the closing ceremonies. It would be a great chance for her to redeem herself to the world."

More ire was directed at the organizers for not going public with the decision, rather than at Miaoke, whose performance was highly praised immediately after the opening ceremony.

The secret was revealed by Chen Qigang, the opening ceremony's chief musical director, in an interview on Sunday with state-owned Beijing Radio, in which he said a senior Politburo member said Miaoke's voice was not good enough for the ceremony but that Peiyi did not look right.

By using both girls, "We combined the perfect voice and the perfect performance," Chen said.

Chen, a French national, later said he felt compelled to "to come out with the truth." Peiyi was "a magnificent singer" who "doesn't deserve to be hidden," he said, before declining further comment.

Chen's original interview was posted on Beijing Radio's Web site on Sunday night. By Tuesday, after it began to be picked up by other media, the link was shut down.

The Chinese government routinely blocks sites that are politically sensitive or that could cause embarrassment to the country's communist rulers.

Lin declined to answer when asked if Peiyi should be included in the closing ceremony, except to say that he was not the director.

He said his daughter was not doing any rehearsals and that he presumed she would not be involved in the closing ceremony.


Bookmark and Share
 
 

Reader views (5)

 Add your view

Here's a sample of the latest views published.

So its fake...who cares. Olympic games, where everyone pretends for two weeks to care for their fellow man and not have international hate. Its sports, a business like any other.
The winners will have a better financial future and desire crushing their opponents.
No one is there for the so called love of the game. That's a foolish unrealistic notion, like the Easter bunny. They switched girls, they faked fireworks, surprise surprise, it is entertainment.
EVERY government creates propaganda for its foolish citizens to believe. No one is the bad guy ever, no govt ever "wants" to go to war, every government cares for its people. No country has crime, no country has homeless or poor, right? Grow up people, This fantasy utopia doesn't exist...never did.

- Dty, New York, NY.

Can someone please politely request to Chen Qigang, the musical director, that any time he is in public he wears a paper bag over his head so people don't have to see him. Not that he's ugly, it's just that he's not outstandingly good-looking.

- Graham Banks, Haltwhistle, UK

Please, lets not be so naive - all ceremonies are pre-recorded for quality of sound for the broadcast. Likewise check out the footage of all other past Olympic Ceremonies - Atlanta, Sydney, Athens - can you spot an ugly person!

For example the girls, and it is always girls who carry the national placards for the teams are always the prettiest ones - its a well known fact that every Olympic producer always makes sure that anyone who is going to be on camera looks good.

Its sweet that we expect everything to be open - but the whole performance is about illusion!

Can't wait to see what London does in its bit of the ceremony

- Jc, E14

I think she is beautiful. She should definitely be the STAR in the closing ceremony. What a disgusting word "ugly" to use when you are talking about a very young child. Lets hope that she never gets to see or hear any of this coverage, it can be so damaging. Give her this big moment she so deserves.

- Tricia Davies, South Wales. U.K.

Yeah, poor little one. She isn't ugly. Bring her on for the closing ceremony.

- Maurits Van Eijck, Billericay, UK


Add your comment

 

Your email address will not be published

Terms and conditions make text area bigger You have  characters left.


 
 


 
Promotions
 
London's Weather
Tonight
Clear Night
11°c
Morning
Mostly cloudy
20°c
5 day forecast
 
 

Daily Mail Mail on Sunday Travel Mail This is Money Metro

Loot | Jobsite | Homes & property | London jobs | FindaProperty.com | Primelocation.com | Educate London | Holiday Villas