Weather Tonight: 3°c Partly Cloudy Night Morning: 6°c Cloudy

News

How 118,000 violent thugs have been let off with just a caution as convictions for violent crime plummet

Last updated at 01:52am on 25.08.08

 Add your view

 


Cautions have overtaken convictions as punishment for violent crimes for the first time, a report reveals today.

The number of assault cases where police allow offenders to escape punishment has more than trebled in five years to more than 118,000  -  including a near-doubling of the most serious violent attacks.

The rapid expansion of 'instant justice' under Labour has seen a dramatic rise in the use of formal warnings, cautions and on-the-spot fines by police as an alternative to pressing criminal charges.

The detailed study by Professor Rod Morgan, former chairman of the Youth Justice Board, warns the trend could be diverting serious offenders  -  who would previously have been dealt with in court  -  towards lesser punishments.

Thugs

More than 118,000 violent thugs have got off with cautions under Labour's instant justice policy. Posed by models

Prof Morgan's report, published by the Centre for Crime and Justice Studies, King's College London, exposes the full extent of the growth in instant justice.

Police and prosecutors have embraced the policy, partly in response to controversial Whitehall targets which give equal credit for cautioning a child for a trivial disturbance as for catching a murderer.

Cautions handed out for 'more serious violence against the person'  -  assaults where victims are badly hurt  -  rose by 92 per cent to 916 between 2001 and 2006. It means nearly a quarter were given cautions, up from 14 per cent.

For less serious violence, cautions leapt from 19,090 to 56,357.

While convictions also rose, from 32,390 to 38,622, the proportion of offenders charged and sent to court plunged from 63 per cent to just 41 per cent.

The increase was repeated for common assault where cautions more than trebled to 60,938.

But the trend is not restricted to violent crime. In 2000 almost twothirds of those caught shoplifting  -  some 77,000  -  were charged and appeared before magistrates.

But by 2006 that had slumped to 41 per cent, or 58,000 offenders, while 32 per cent were cautioned and 27 per cent given fixed penalty fines of £80.

Penalty Notice Disorder fines were introduced in 2003 to deal with minor disorder, but were extended to cover shoplifting up to a value of £200, and criminal damage up to £500.

The findings follow years of efforts by Labour to 're-balance' the criminal justice system, aiming to deal with more offenders without swamping the courts with less serious cases.

While the total number of offences brought to justice grew from just over a million in 1999 to 1.4million in 2007, virtually all the increase was accounted for by the rise in cautions, fines and formal warnings.

Professor Morgan's report suggests greater use of these powers by police is 'dragging into the criminal justice system offenders and offending behaviour that would not previously have been criminalised'  -  particularly 'marginal' offences by young people.

In the past such cases were dealt with 'possibly quite effectively' by teachers, neighbours and pub landlords rather than the courts.

Shadow Home Secretary Dominic Grieve said: 'Labour's ad hoc and distorted approach has created the worst of both worlds.

'Not only are serious offenders escaping real justice due to the reliance on spot fines but, as this report shows, many people who should be dealt with informally are being criminalised.'

He added: 'The public are sick and tired of this Government pursuing easy targets, instead of going after the real criminals.'

A Department of Justice spokesman said: 'The law-abiding majority want to see crimes dealt with effectively and fixed penalty notices and cautions are part of this process.

'They allow police to deal swiftly with low-level offending, freeing them up to spend more time on frontline duties and more time investigating violent, dangerous and serious offences. They also free up court time for more serious cases.'


Bookmark and Share
 
 

Reader views (2)

 Add your view

- Normal law-abiding people fear going outside their houses
- Everyones in their cars because they're too scared to use Public Transport
- Parents wrapping kids in cotton wool because they want their children to live past their teens
- Police restricted by politicians in case they upset the PC brigade

Bring back the death penalty, build supersize no-frills prisons with longer sentencing, bring in an 8pm curfew on under 18's, abolish welfare benefit for life to anyone convicted of a violent crime.

Thank god I got out of London years ago.

- Richard Mcgarry, Ireland, 25/08/2008 23:16
Report abuse

Oh so that's why violent youth crime is on the increase - they just get a rap on the knuckles....

- Barbara, Sydney, Australia, 25/08/2008 23:08
Report abuse


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.