Brown warned to tone down his language in clash with Cameron over Scottish elections fiasco - News - Evening Standard
       

Brown warned to tone down his language in clash with Cameron over Scottish elections fiasco

Gordon Brown had to be warned by Commons Speaker Michael Martin to use 'temperate language' yesterday in a furious clash with David Cameron.

It came after the Prime Minister accused the Tory leader of 'misleading people' about the conclusions of a devastating report into a poll fiasco in Scotland earlier this year.

Scroll down for more...

Gordon Brown: Told to use 'temperate language'

That prompted uproar, since it is considered a breach of Commons rules to accuse an opponent of deliberately misleading Parliament.

Proceedings were dramatically brought to a halt as Mr Martin held hushed consultations with the clerks of the House.

As furious Conservative MPs demanded the Prime Minister withdraw the allegation, the Speaker warned Mr Brown: "I call for temperate language."

Mr Cameron called for Labour's election supremo and Mr Brown's close ally, Douglas Alexander, to resign over the independent report into May's elections to the Scottish Parliament and local councils which descended into a shambles that saw more than 140,000 people disenfranchised.

Scroll down for more...

Michael Martin: The speaker had to calm down Gordon Brown

The report, by Canadian elections expert Ron Gould, concluded that voters had been treated as an 'afterthought'.

Most damagingly, it said ministers were frequently focused on 'partisan political interests' when making arrangements for the elections.

At Prime Minister's Questions, Mr Brown insisted all main parties had to accept responsibility because they all agreed the system that had been adopted.

After he accused Mr Cameron of 'misleading people', a visibly angry Tory leader replied that he did not know how the Prime Minister had the 'gall' to make such a claim.

He quoted the report's conclusion that there was a 'notable level of party self-interest evident in ministerial decision-making'.

Scroll down for more...

Douglas Alexander: Apologised for his role in the problems

Mr Cameron insisted that Mr Alexander, who was Scottish Secretary at the time and is now International Development Secretary, should 'explain himself to the House of Commons' and be 'stripped of his responsibility for elections'.

"How can he possibly go round the world lecturing other countries about probity in their elections?" Mr Cameron demanded.

The Prime Minister conceded that the Gould report had said 'there were decisions made about the elections that could have been better made'.

Scroll down for more...

David Cameron: Accused of 'misleading' by the PM

But he insisted: "These decisions were supported by the Conservative Party. What the Gould report does not do is put the blame on any individual or any institution."

The May polls saw a new ballot paper design and a new voting system-for council seats.

Mr Gould found strong evidence that combining both regional and constituency ballot papers on one sheet was to blame for the confusion that meant 146,099 votes having to be rejected because the papers were not filled in properly.

Critics say it was a deliberate attempt to sideline smaller parties such as the Greens and the Scottish Socialist Party.

Voters had traditionally seen the second, separate regional vote as a 'second choice' and a chance to take a risk on a smaller party after their 'main' vote.

Mr Alexander issued a statement apologising for his role in the fiasco.

Comments

Don't Miss
TV Baftas - in pictures

Best of the Baftas

Stars on the red, white and blue carpet
What makes Chelsea and Arsenal target Eden Hazard tick?

Hazard warning

What makes Chelsea and Arsenal target Eden Hazard tick?
You big softie: Has Giles Coren put down his poison pen?

You big softie

Has Giles Coren put down his poison pen?
Pop star Paloma Faith, former Labour minister and Tory blogger back gay marriage video

Gay marriage

Pop star, former Labour minister and Tory blogger back gay marriage video
Promethipedia: the lowdown on Ridley Scott's new blockbuster Prometheus

Promethipedia

The lowdown on Ridley Scott's new blockbuster Prometheus
Prints charming: patterned trousers for summer

Prints charming

Patterned trousers for summer
Bob Geldof on grandchildren, activism and the state of music

Grandpa Bob

Bob Geldof on grandchildren, activism and the state of music
The Middletan: Kate Middleton has the most requested tan in London

The Middletan

Kate Middleton has the most requested tan in London
Amy Childs bares all like Britney

Dare to bare

Amy Childs vajazzles like Britney
Trip the bright fantastic - in vertiginous neon

Fashion

Trip the bright fantastic - in vertiginous neon