Backbenchers demand retreat over charity cap

“Fair share”: Nick Clegg says the move is needed against “very wealthy” people
CAPTION TEXT

George Osborne was hit by a backbench revolt today over plans to cap tax breaks on giving to charity.

Tory MPs demanded a “review and retreat” on the proposal which has sparked fury among leading charities and philanthropists.

Amid warnings that the move to limit reliefs at £50,000, or 25 per cent of income, is already hitting donations, they raised fears it will cause lasting political damage.

However, Nick Clegg became the latest senior coalition minister to defend the proposal, which was unveiled in the Budget, insisting it was needed to ensure the super-rich pay their “fair share” of tax.

That followed anger among philanthropists at being branded tax dodgers after Downing Street said some donors were “exploiting” the system by paying into bogus charities.

But Conor Burns, who is ministerial aide to Northern Ireland Secretary Owen Paterson, said that was a matter for the Charity Commission rather than an argument for closing off “legitimate giving”.

“I think it’s time that we do a very quick review and retreat on this,” the Bournemouth West MP told the Standard.

“Charitable giving is ever-more important and we are all seeing that in our constituencies particularly at a time of frozen or reduced government spending.

“Central to what the Prime Minister has been talking about in terms of the Big Society are voluntary and charitable groups. We should be doing everything we can to encourage more and more giving.”

Mark Pritchard, secretary of the backbench 1922 Committee, added: “This appears to be going in the opposite direction of encouraging philanthropy and major giving to charity.

“It needs to be reviewed as it is already having an impact on charities ranging from fighting cancer to providing fresh water abroad.”

He added: “We need more philanthropy not less philanthropy and this is not the way to do it.”

Another MP privately raised fears the move would bring more political damage than money for the Treasury coffers, saying: “It is the signal it sends.”

Ministers have vowed to work with charities to ensure those that rely on large donations will not suffer.

But Mr Clegg insisted the move was needed to stop “very wealthy” people using the relief and other tax breaks to avoid paying income tax.

Defending the new limit, he said: “I don’t think a quarter of someone’s overall income for people who are in many cases multimillionaires is a terribly sort of restrictive cap — that still allows people to make very significant contributions to charity in a way that is preferential to their tax arrangements.”

 

Comments

Property search

ES Rentals

    Don't Miss
    I was a karate kid and boys used to kick me in the boobs, reveals Suki

    ES Magazine

    Model of the moment Suki Waterhouse
    The Silver Tassie, National's Lyttelton - theatre review

    Theatre review

    The Silver Tassie at the National's Lyttelton
    Espresso yourself: What does your coffee order say about you?

    London Life

    What your coffee order says about you?
    'Buccaneering aristo-rebel': a tribute to Mark Shand, a gent who walked on the wild side

    Mark Shand

    A tribute to the gent who walked on the wild side
    A part of the Establishment says that it’s fine to have coke laid out after dinner: Justine Picardie on 'cocaine Conservatives'

    Interview

    Justine Picardie on 'cocaine Conservatives'
    Jay-Z and Beyonce spend £5.5m on west London home

    Run This Town

    Jay-Z and Beyonce spend £5.5m on west London home
    Dorian Gray, Riverside Studios - theatre review

    Theatre review

    Dorian Gray at Riverside Studios
    The true cost of buying a first-time home in London boroughs

    Homes & Property

    The true cost of first-time buying in London
    Fay Maschler reviews Rotorino

    Fay Maschler

    Dalston gets a taste of Italy
    Pictures: Party people - the stars out in London

    Party people

    The stars out in London