Potty! A judge's verdict on neighbours who blew £300,000 EACH in court row over rhododendron bushes - News - Evening Standard
       

Potty! A judge's verdict on neighbours who blew £300,000 EACH in court row over rhododendron bushes

Two wealthy landowners who have spent three years and £300,000 each in a war over a small piece of garden were described as "potty" by a judge yesterday.

Lord Justice Ward urged Robert Beton and Colin Streets to abandon their "hideous litigation" over a "stupid piece of land", telling them: "Go away and sort it out."

The judge's astonishing outburst came after he heard about the long-running dispute between the two businessmen over a quarter of an acre of land on the exclusive St George's Hill estate in Weybridge, Surrey.

The estate is one of Britain's ten most expensive addresses.

Scroll down for more ...

Bush warfare: The neighbouring properties on the 'golden postcode' St George's Hill estate

Past and present residents include Sir Cliff Richard, Sir Tom Jones, Sir Elton John, John Lennon, Chelsea footballer Didier Drogba and the Manchester City owner, former Thai Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra.

The Appeal Court in London heard that the case centred on a chain link fence which was originally hidden by a clump of rhododendrons.

When the bushes died in 2005, Mr Beton spotted the fence for the first time.

He noticed that it sliced off two small triangles of land which he believed belonged to his garden.

The total area amounted to about a quarter of an acre - a tiny fraction of the house's huge garden.

But land on St George's Hill can change hands for up to £3.5million an acre.

Not amused: Lord Justice Ward

The area is known as a "golden postcode", where property prices are virtually unaffected by downturns or credit crunches.

Mr Beton took legal action over the disputed land, but last year a judge at Kingston County Court ruled that his neighbour Mr Streets, 61, had squatters' rights over the land, as the fence had gone unnoticed for years.

The matter could have ended there, but 48-year-old Mr Beton, who lives in a sprawling two-storey house with his wife of 16 years, Carolyn Valdata-Beton, and their two teenage daughters, took the case to the Appeal Court.

Yesterday his lawyer Clive Freedman QC argued that the county court decision was wrong because the position of the fence did not tally with the boundary plans of the two properties.

Lord Justice Ward granted leave to appeal, but then rounded on both sides and launched a stinging attack against the entire legal action.

He said: "This is another of that hideous form of litigation called the boundary dispute, a form of litigation which is best not pursued.

Unlikely catalyst: Battle lines were drawn after a huge rhododendron bush died

"Just how much is this stupid piece of land worth? What you are arguing over is a few rhododendron bushes. If you live in St George's Hill you've got money to throw away, presumably.

"But why throw it away like this? You're all potty.

Disputes of this kind are a most hateful form of litigation. Go away and sort it out."

If the neighbours cannot settle their differences, the case will go on to be heard by three judges in a day-long Court of Appeal hearing, which would see the legal bill soar even higher.

Mr Beton, who was in court to hear the judge's comments, did not return calls to his lawyer's office.

Mr Streets, a company director with a string of successful office equipment firms based in Croydon, was not in court and was unavailable for comment.

Comments

Don't Miss
Dog save the Queen: Corgis surge in popularity

Dog save the Queen

Corgis surge in popularity
London gets ready for the Diamond Jubilee - in pictures

Diamond Jubilee

London gets ready - in pictures
'He’s a better ex than he was a husband', says Boris Johnson's ex wife

A better ex than husband

We talk to Boris Johnson's ex wife
TV Baftas - in pictures

Best of the Baftas

Stars on the red, white and blue carpet
You big softie: Has Giles Coren put down his poison pen?

You big softie

Has Giles Coren put down his poison pen?
Pop star Paloma Faith, former Labour minister and Tory blogger back gay marriage video

Gay marriage

Pop star, former Labour minister and Tory blogger back gay marriage video
Promethipedia: the lowdown on Ridley Scott's new blockbuster Prometheus

Promethipedia

The lowdown on Ridley Scott's new blockbuster Prometheus
Prints charming: patterned trousers for summer

Prints charming

Patterned trousers for summer
Bob Geldof on grandchildren, activism and the state of music

Grandpa Bob

Bob Geldof on grandchildren, activism and the state of music
The Middletan: Kate Middleton has the most requested tan in London

The Middletan

Kate Middleton has the most requested tan in London