US anger over 'torture file' ruling - News in brief - Evening Standard
       

US anger over 'torture file' ruling

The future of intelligence sharing between Britain and the US is under threat after judges ruled secret evidence relating to the treatment of a former Guantanamo detainee should be released.

US government officials said they were "not pleased" at a decision to reveal information surrounding the treatment of UK citizen Binyam Mohamed by the CIA.

Foreign Secretary David Miliband said the Government was "deeply disappointed" by the High Court judgment and immediately announced an appeal.

Speaking at a press briefing in Washington DC, US State Department spokesman Ian Kelly said a "confidential channel" should remain if intelligence sharing was to continue "to the fullest extent possible".

In their ruling in London, Lord Justice Thomas and Mr Justice Lloyd Jones said there was "overwhelming" public interest in disclosing the seven paragraphs of material redacted from their original judgment on the Mohamed case last year.

"As the risk to national security, judged objectively on the evidence, is not a serious one, we should restore the redacted paragraphs to our first judgment," they said.

The judges added: "It cannot be suggested that information as to how officials of the US government admitted treating Binyam Mohamed during his interrogation is information that can in any democratic society governed by the rule of law be characterised as secret or as intelligence."

Mr Mohamed, 31, was still being held at Guantanamo Bay awaiting trial at the time of the court's original judgment in August last year, but has since been released and has returned to the UK.

He is fighting to prove he was tortured and that the British authorities facilitated his detention and knew about the wrongdoing to which he was being subjected.

The judges have held it was clear - from the fact that the UK intelligence services sought to interview Mr Mohamed during his detention and supplied information and questions for his interviews by others - "that the relationship of the UK Government to the US authorities in connection with Binyam Mohamed was far beyond that of a bystander or witness to the alleged wrongdoing".

News in brief in Pictures

Don't Miss
Rock star: Erin Wasson

Rock star

Erin Wasson is the ultimate anti-supermodel
Maybe it’s because she’s a Londoner … Happy anniversary, Ma’am

Happy anniversary

The monarchy has become stronger and more respected in the past 60 years
Victoria Coren: My obsession with children, five proposals a week and why David and I are no power couple

Victoria Coren

David Mitchell and I are no power couple
The Royal Academy of Arts Summer Exhibition preview party

Summer party

Stars at the The Royal Academy of Arts
London gets ready for the Diamond Jubilee - in pictures

Diamond Jubilee

London gets ready - in pictures
The Glamour Awards - stars turn on the style

Glamour Awards

Stars turn on the style
Duchess of Cambridge is pretty in pink at her first Buckingham Palace garden party

Garden party

Duchess of Cambridge is pretty in pink
FIRST review of Ridley Scott's latest sci-fi blockbuster Prometheus

First review

Is Ridley Scott's Prometheus any good?
Fair-weather goths

Fair-weather goths

The sultry shades of summer darks are coming out of the shadows
Dog save the Queen: Corgis surge in popularity

Dog save the Queen

Corgis surge in popularity