Weather Tonight: 4°c Partly Cloudy Night Morning: 8°c Cloudy

Showbiz

Row over BBC drama which shows Jesus crucified in a foetal position

Updated 18:16pm on 17 Mar 2008


The BBC is facing accusations of rewriting the Easter story by claiming Christ was nailed to the cross in a foetal position.

The corporation is accused of "misleading" the public by ditching the traditional image of Jesus with arms outstretched, legs straight and hands nailed.

Makers of lavish new drama The Passion, which started last night, say they are challenging this image, because new historical evidence shows he probably did not die this way.

Scroll down for more...

Controversial: The BBC has been accused of rewriting the Easter story after claiming Christ was nailed to the cross in a foetal position

They instead maintain he likely died with his arms above his head, nails through his arms and his knees bent, when killed by the Romans.

But the corporation is being accused of ignoring evidence in the Bible and gratuitously offending Christians who cherish the image.

This comes just weeks after the broadcaster faced claims of exonerating Judas and Pontius Pilate in the same programme, which stars Joseph Mawle as Jesus.

Others have also hit out at the programme's portrayal of Jesus' mother Mary, after the programme suggested she had not known what was happening to her.

Speaking about the crucifixion row, Reverend George Curry, chairman of the Church Society, said: "They are misleading people by distorting the facts.

Scroll down for more...

the passion james nesbitt

James Nesbitt as Pontius pilate in the drama

"That's a serious and dangerous thing to do, but sadly utterly predictable and regrettable. Jesus's nails went through his hands not his forearms.

"We should be true to history and the events that occurred."

Other scholars pointed out that the traditional image was important to Christians in understanding the event.

They also claimed it ignored what the Bible says and the image of Jesus "throwing his arms out in a symbol of love".

In the Book of John, Jesus says to Thomas: "Put your finger here; see my hands."

Scroll down for more...

the passion Joe Mawle

Biblical figure: Joe Mawle as a bloodied Jesus

But production designer, Simon Elliott, defended the crucifixion scene, claiming they were trying to make the show as "historically accurate" as possible.

He said: "The Victorian image of Jesus doesn't tie in with the historical evidence.

"He was probably put on a crude wooden gibbet and made to stand in a loose, foetal position. It was fiendishly designed."

Elliott claimed that the position so well known to Christians was only one of a number of ways the Romans crucified people.

He added: "It is a minefield as everyone has such strong feelings about it."

But the decision to go with the new portrayal was based on "lengthy research", including the discovery of a crucified skeleton found near Jerusalem in 1968.

It is believed that in the foetal type position would have meant that his chest was crushed and he would have died of asphyxiation.

Mark Goodacre, associate professor of religion at Duke University, who advised producers, also defended the scene.

He claimed the Bible did not explain in any detail the type of crucifixion that was used.

Scroll down for more...

christ jesus crucifiction

Crucifixion : The traditional image of Jesus on the cross

The academic added: "The makers wanted something that wasn't the typical image that would surprise the viewers. This is not an attempt to be iconoclastic, but to get people to look again at the events surrounding his death."

The BBC has faced claims of trying to exonerate Judas, Pontius Pilate and High Priest Caiaphas in the programme.

Programme-makers have portrayed them in a sympathetic manner, claiming they have been dealt "a raw deal" by history.

Judas Iscariot is portrayed as torn between his loyalties to two fathers, Caiaphas and Jesus.

Pilate is shown struggling to manage his wife's social aspirations and his career as he tried to "keep a lid" on tensions in Jerusalem.

Stephen Green, national director of Christian Voice, said: "Yet again a revisionist slant has to be put on a story that is transparent.

"It's fine to have an alternative look at the motivation of people such as Caiaphas, Pilate and Judas, but the fact remains that these guys were instrumental in an innocent man meeting his death."

The Passion also stars James Nesbitt as Pilate, Ben Daniels as Caiaphas and ex-EastEnders actor Paul Nicholls as Judas.

The four-part BBC1 drama, which climaxes on Easter Sunday, will also feature Penelope Wilton as an "angrier" Mary.

Reader views (0)

 Add your view

No comments have so far been submitted.


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • Russell Grant stars as he dances into Wizard spell Sophie Evans and Russell Grant When Nancy Dell'Olio was bidding for the public's affection on Strictly Come Dancing, Russell Grant was one of her fiercest rivals
  • Cheryl Cole wants new home in Malibu Cheryl Cole Cheryl Cole keen to relocate to California on a permanent basis in a bid to crack the States
  • Russell Brand moves on with mystery woman Katy Perry and Russell Brand Russell Brand has moved on from Katy Perry with a mystery woman
  • Stones would love to play at the Games, says Ronnie Wood Ronnie Wood Guitarist revealed that Rolling Stones had been in discussions about playing during the Games and in other concerts
  • Mother's grief at Whitney Houston's final journey Whitney hearse Whitney Houston's mother Cissy looked distraught today as she brought her daughter's body back to a funeral parlour in her home town
  • Dermot O'Leary is top TV choice for Valentine's Day Dermot O'Leary Dermot O'Leary proved he has the X factor after he topped a poll of the nation's women asking them to name their top TV Valentine
  • Rosie Huntington-Whiteley named top style icon at Elle Awards Rosie Huntington-Whiteley Rosie Huntington-Whiteley has been named the year's top style icon at the Elle Style Awards
  • Al Pacino honoured at White House ceremony Al Pacino Al Pacino was among a host of honourees awarded the 2011 National Medal of Arts at a ceremony in Washington
  • Whitney Houston was dead before she went under the water Whitney o2 Singer Whitney Houston died from a mix of drugs and alcohol - and did not drown in her hotel bath, according to reports
  • Rhys Ifans accused of assault Rhys Ifans Rhys Ifans alleged to have slapped a guest in a late-night argument in a suite at London's five-star St Pancras Renaissance hotel
  •