Weather Tonight: 3°c Partly Cloudy Night Morning: 6°c Cloudy

Showbiz

Selina Scott to sue Channel 5 after she was 'ditched for being too old'

Updated 18:37pm on 1 Sep 2008




Selina Scott is suing Channel Five for ageism after accusing the broadcaster of backing out of a presenting deal because she is too old.

The 57-year-old had been approached to fill in for 35-year-old newsreader Natasha Kaplinsky, who is on maternity leave.

It has been claimed that the offer, reported to be worth up to £200,000, was cancelled when a new head of programmes arrived at the network and wanted a younger face to front its flagship bulletins.

Selina Scott

Ditched: Selina Scott is taking Channel Five to an employment tribunal and claiming age discrimination

Although there had been initial discussion, Miss Scott was then not offered a final contract and Five opted instead to use Isla Traquair, 28, and Matt Barbet, 32.

The pair, who were already correspondents for Five's news programmes, took over the main presenting roles for the 5pm and 7pm weekday bulletins on August 22 after Miss Kaplinsky went on maternity leave. 

Miss Kaplinksy, whose baby is due this month, was pictured out and about in Lewes, East Sussex, at the weekend.

Miss Scott, who became a household name fronting News At Ten at the age of 29 in 1980, is taking Channel Five to an employment tribunal, claiming ageism.

 Channel 5 Newsreaders Isla Traquair and Matt Barbe

Isla Traquair, 28, and Matt Barbet, 32, are now presenting Five's flagship daily news programmes

If she wins, legal experts say she could receive in excess of £500,000 in compensation for injury to her feelings, loss of earnings and loss of earnings that she might have received through her raised profile.

However, insiders at Channel Five are adamant that only an initial approach had been made and that a number of people were in the frame to cover Miss Kaplinsky's role.

Selina Scott

Years of experience: Scott found fame on News at Ten

They said that in the end the decision was taken to promote internally in order to ensure there was continuity and to build up Five's own talent.

Natasha Kaplinsky on Saturday

Natasha Kaplinsky on Saturday

It is understood that the decision was made by Five's director of programmes Ben Gale, who started in April.

Mr Gale and Channel Five are named as defendants in the case, which is listed at the London Employment Tribunal.

Although Miss Scott was never offered a contract, leading employment lawyers say she still has a case if she can prove that the reason for her failure to get one was ageism.

James Knight, managing partner at Keystone Law, said: 'If somebody is not selected for the role, or even an interview, and can show they were discriminated over because of their age then there is a case to answer.'

Channel Five said it did not accept the claim and would be 'vigorously defending' it.

Miss Scott has been vociferous in her criticism of broadcasters' attitudes to women in their late forties and fifties. She publicly attacked the BBC this year after it dropped veteran newsreader Moira Stuart.

And more recently she said: 'Since October, new agediscrimination laws have been in place. How long will it take for television to wise up and ask itself why older women are strictly off-limits on our screens?'

Miss Scott and her agent were unavailable for comment last night.

Reader views (3)

 Add your view

EVERY one of its news and weather presenters has been chosen purely on the basis of their youthfulness and attractiveness. They are all young and beautiful men and women, as are nearly all of the presenters of the quiz shows, current affairs programmes, etc., etc. Unfortunately, a lot of them seem to be very self-absorbed, and lacking in the kind of charisma and personality that Selina Scott has. What a superficial lot they are. You're better off out of it Selina - they would all bore you rigid! One thing that Channel 5 does right is showing lots of good movies, including some of the all-time classics, and at least when they're on we don't have to watch these plastic presenters!

- Ed, London, U.K., 02/09/2008 02:24
Report abuse

Selina is stunning, a woman of class, and an excellent presenter and news reader, big mistake CH 5, big mistake !

- Brian, Wiltshire, 01/09/2008 17:10
Report abuse

What a shame! It would have been great to see a talented and attractive professional like Selina Scott back on the TV.

- Clare, London, 01/09/2008 10:23
Report abuse


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • Lady Gaga reveals battle with bulimia Lady Gaga Lady Gaga used to make herself sick after eating family meals because she wanted to lose her "voluptuous" curves
  • Amy Childs tipped for return to TOWIE Amy Childs Amy Childs is set to make a shock return to The Only Way Is Essex
  • Holly Willoughby to host Surprise, Surprise Holly Willoughby Holly Willoughby is st to host a new series of Surprise, Surprise
  • Kris Humphries doesn't want money from Kim Kim Kardashian and Chris Humphries Kris Humphries doesn't want any of Kim Kardashian's fortune
  • My mum will be the judge, David Walliams tells Britain's Got Talent hopeful David Walliams and his mother Kathleen There was an addition to the Britain's Got Talent panel when judge David Walliams asked his mother's opinion on an act as she sat in the...
  • Simon Cowell wanted to keep Paula Abdul on US X Factor Simon Cowell and Paula Abdul Music mogul insists it wasn't his choice to have his former 'American Idol' co-judge removed from the panel
  • Final episode of Call The Midwife moved to avoid Coronation Street clash Call The Midwife Hit show has been shifted from its usual 8pm slot after ITV1 dropped an episode of Corrie into its Sunday night programming later this month
  • I've fallen for English sense of humour, says Birdsong heroine Clémence Poésy French actress Clémence Poésy - star of Birdsong - says she wants to work more in Britain after being seduced by the English sense of humour
  • Alesha Dixon stands up to Simon Cowell on Britain's Got Talent Alesha Dixon Judge Alesha Dixon shows she was not scared of show supremo Simon Cowell after branding one of his favourite performers a "pub" act
  • Christina Aguilera ready to reconcile with dad Christina Aguilera Christina Aguilera thinks it is "time" to meet with her estranged father
  •