Weather Morning: 9°c Sunny spells Afternoon: 10°c Sunny spells

Showbiz

Elton John adoption bid 'sending out wrong message'

Updated 09:03am on 14 Sep 2009


Elton John's plan to adopt a child from Ukraine could result in more youngsters being abandoned, a children's charity warned.

EveryChild, an international children's charity, said it was concerned by the singer's announcement on Saturday that he and partner David Furnish, 46, wanted to adopt a 14-month-old boy called Lev.

David Furnish and  Sir Elton John
Adoption plans: David Furnish and Sir Elton John

The organisation said that while it praised John's help in raising awareness of the plight of children affected by HIV in Ukraine, it said the answer to the country's deepening HIV and Aids crisis does not lie in international adoption, arguing that more children may be abandoned in children's homes as a result of another high-profile celebrity adoption.

If John, 62, were successful he would follow in the footsteps of actress Angelina Jolie, who has three adopted children from Cambodia, Vietnam and Ethiopia, and Madonna, who adopted a little girl from Malawi earlier this year.

EveryChild argues that 95% of the children in Ukraine's institutions are not orphans and children born to HIV-positive mothers face particular discrimination. They are separated from their mothers and often end up in children's homes and institutions segregated from children not affected by HIV, it said.

Anna Feuchtwang, chief executive of EveryChild, said: "High-profile adoption stories involving celebrities send out the wrong message.

"Research conducted in Ukraine by Liverpool University found that vulnerable mothers were encouraged by news of wealthy foreigners adopting from children's homes to place their own children in care in the hope that they would get a better life.

"Most children placed in children's homes are not adopted internationally; the majority face a bleak future.

"Children who grow up in a children's home are much more likely to end up in prison, involved with drugs and prostitution and go on to abandon their own children.

"The actions of celebrities like Madonna, and now possibly Elton John, could be actually increasing the number of children in children's homes in countries like Ukraine."

The Ukraine government has recently introduced new legislation that requires authorities to explore all possible options such as extended family and domestic adoption before a child is placed in a children's home, EveryChild said.

Speaking at a press conference on Saturday, John said Lev had "stolen his heart" and added: "I don't know what the procedure is to adopt a boy from the Ukraine. I don't think that I can because England has a treaty with the Ukraine but David is Canadian so we might be able to work through something like that."

Reader views (10)

 Add your view

Phew, sense prevails, the Ukrainians are sticking to their guns.... the lad needs a mum and dad... simple.

- Smellyone, london, 14/09/2009 21:44
Report abuse

Life with people who care about you is better than life in an institution. I hope the adoption succeeds.

- Mary, London, UK, 14/09/2009 14:55
Report abuse

Am i the only one that thinks this child will be terribly spoilt? He's going to be horrible. Have you seen Elton have a tantrum...and now he's going to have a child. He'll think he's a prince and will beleive he's a cut above. Hopefully he'll teach the kid the value of things....oh silly me what am I thinking didn't Elton spend thousands on flowers?

- Tammy, Twickenham, 14/09/2009 13:37
Report abuse

Is he releasing a 'best of' soon??

- Alestare, London, 14/09/2009 13:34
Report abuse

Good luck to Elton and David. The child will want for nothing and life with the guys must be better than in an institution. I also agree with the previous comment that there are plenty of children here who need good homes and who are denied them through over tight procedures.

- John, Kent, 14/09/2009 11:54
Report abuse

Sorry, the child is not an EU citizen, no entry allowed, end off . . . .

Elton, if you want to adopt a child go an live in that childs country
!

- Don, London, 14/09/2009 11:03
Report abuse

I'm not sure he'd be able to cope with the spoilt brat's temper tantrums ..... the child that is!

- Paul, London, 14/09/2009 10:30
Report abuse

He would be better off following in the same footsteps as Duncan Bannatyne, invest in an orphanage and save many more children, rather than spoiling only one. He should use his money and fame to support charity organisations like EveryChild and raise funds for them.

- Frank, Copenhagen, Denmark, 14/09/2009 09:56
Report abuse

Meanwhile, in the UK thousands of lonely children remain in institutions - where they are most likely to be abused - because the rules whereby some loving person can adopt them are so stringent that it's nigh impossible to pass them. But so long as everyone has followed 'procedure' that's alright . . .

- Roz, France, 14/09/2009 09:21
Report abuse

Come off it, Elton. A national treasure you may be, but doting dad material you certainly are not.

- Ken, Bexleyheath, 14/09/2009 08:53
Report abuse


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • Cheryl Cole wants new home in Malibu Cheryl Cole Cheryl Cole keen to relocate to California on a permanent basis in a bid to crack the States
  • Russell Brand moves on with mystery woman Katy Perry and Russell Brand Russell Brand has moved on from Katy Perry with a mystery woman
  • Stones would love to play at the Games, says Ronnie Wood Ronnie Wood Guitarist revealed that Rolling Stones had been in discussions about playing during the Games and in other concerts
  • Mother's grief at Whitney Houston's final journey Whitney hearse Whitney Houston's mother Cissy looked distraught today as she brought her daughter's body back to a funeral parlour in her home town
  • Dermot O'Leary is top TV choice for Valentine's Day Dermot O'Leary Dermot O'Leary proved he has the X factor after he topped a poll of the nation's women asking them to name their top TV Valentine
  • Rosie Huntington-Whiteley named top style icon at Elle Awards Rosie Huntington-Whiteley Rosie Huntington-Whiteley has been named the year's top style icon at the Elle Style Awards
  • Al Pacino honoured at White House ceremony Al Pacino Al Pacino was among a host of honourees awarded the 2011 National Medal of Arts at a ceremony in Washington
  • Whitney Houston was dead before she went under the water Whitney o2 Singer Whitney Houston died from a mix of drugs and alcohol - and did not drown in her hotel bath, according to reports
  • Rhys Ifans accused of assault Rhys Ifans Rhys Ifans alleged to have slapped a guest in a late-night argument in a suite at London's five-star St Pancras Renaissance hotel
  • Triumph for Adele as she finds her voice on tragic night at the Grammys adele Adele made a triumphant return after vocal cord surgery to win a record six Grammy Awards
  •