One that got away - England denied win as Bucknor turns down Monty 'lbw' - Sport - Evening Standard
       

One that got away - England denied win as Bucknor turns down Monty 'lbw'

England were robbed of victory over India yesterday when a Test featuring a record 14 lbw dismissals concluded with the most convincing appeal of the lot being rejected.

In the mid-afternoon gloom at Lord's, Michael Vaughan's men were circling for the kill, having reduced the tourists to 277 for nine.

Scroll down to read more:

Frustration: Vaughan misses out on victory

When a delivery from Monty Panesar to last man Sri Sreesanth pitched on middle stump and struck the batsman's front pad low down, it appeared the game was up.

But West Indian umpire Steve Bucknor, who had given a number of more marginal decisions in the bowlers' favour, shook his head.

Replays showed the ball would have hit the top of middle and off but moments later the Indian batsmen Sreesanth and Mahendra Singh Dhoni accepted the offer of bad light and persistent rain ruined any chance of a resumption.

India captain Rahul Dravid admitted his team had "got out of jail" but Vaughan took the sting out of the controversial finale by refusing to blame Bucknor.

"You get these decisions," said the England skipper. "We got a couple of lbws that might have been missing so we don't have any complaints."

Scroll down for more:

Not out: the key delivery

Vaughan also praised Bucknor and his Australian colleague Simon Taufel over their handling of the deteriorating light.

He said: "The umpires were very good at communicating with us. When we took the new ball the light was going and they said they would let us know if it was getting too bad for the seamers to bowl, so we could put the spinners on.

"It was dark and starting to rain, so I have no problem with the decision to go off. I'm just disappointed we didn't get the last wicket."

India resumed on 137 for three, needing another 243 runs for an unlikely victory, before England captured two wickets in the first half-hour to take charge.

But an uncharacteristically measured innings of 76 not out from wicketkeeper Dhoni ultimately kept the hosts at bay.

Scroll down for more:

Out: how Hawk-Eye saw Monty's appeal

In the circumstances, Vaughan was delighted with the efforts of his team, reserving special praise for his rookie attack.

"Our young bowlers bowled really well, putting India's experienced batting line-up under pressure," he said.

"Chris Tremlett did so well to bowl like he did on debut. James Anderson showed great skill, control and pace and Ryan Sidebottom continued where he left off against the West Indies.

"We all know Monty Panesar is a good bowler, so we can be proud of the four of them."

Dravid said: "We got out of jail. It was a good effort but we were saved by the weather here. England had us on the run right through this game but we fought hard to stay in touch."

England have retained the same XI for the second Test at Trent Bridge, starting on Friday, after Matthew Hoggard was given more time to recover from his back injury.

Stuart Broad has been included in a 12-man squad but Vaughan admitted that it was hard to envisage any changes "at this stage".

Comments

Don't Miss
Victoria Coren: My obsession with children, five proposals a week and why David and I are no power couple

Victoria Coren

David Mitchell and I are no power couple
The Royal Academy of Arts Summer Exhibition preview party

Summer party

Stars at the The Royal Academy of Arts
London gets ready for the Diamond Jubilee - in pictures

Diamond Jubilee

London gets ready - in pictures
The Glamour Awards - stars turn on the style

Glamour Awards

Stars turn on the style
Duchess of Cambridge is pretty in pink at her first Buckingham Palace garden party

Garden party

Duchess of Cambridge is pretty in pink
FIRST review of Ridley Scott's latest sci-fi blockbuster Prometheus

First review

Is Ridley Scott's Prometheus any good?
Fair-weather goths

Fair-weather goths

The sultry shades of summer darks are coming out of the shadows
Dog save the Queen: Corgis surge in popularity

Dog save the Queen

Corgis surge in popularity
'He’s a better ex than he was a husband', says Boris Johnson's ex wife

A better ex than husband

We talk to Boris Johnson's ex wife
TV Baftas - in pictures

Best of the Baftas

Stars on the red, white and blue carpet