Weather Tonight: 4°c Partly Cloudy Night Morning: 8°c Cloudy

Business

Williams
Staying put: the watchdog insists there is no chance that Williams will be asked to resign

Morrisons wins OFT 'price-fix' apology

Simon English, Evening Standard
23 Apr 2008


The Office of Fair Trading was forced into a humiliating climbdown today, apologising to supermarkets giant Wm Morrison for incorrectly accusing it of colluding to fix prices on dairy products.

It is paying Morrisons £100,000 plus its legal costs - an unprecedented move for a regulator that has recently taken a get-tough approach to big business.

The decision is a major embarrassment for OFT chief executive John Fingleton, who imposed £237 million of fines last year, leaving major industries claiming he was a publicity seeker who was unfairly targeting large companies.

Click here for the full OFT statement

The OFT issued a "provisional decision" against the supermarkets last September, saying they fixed prices on milk, butter and cheese in 2002 and 2003, costing consumers £270 million.

A group of supermarkets and dairy firms agreed to pay fines of £116 million to settle the case, but made clear they thought the finding unfair. The investigation stunned the industry, which argues it had increased the fees paid to farmers for goods after coming under intense pressure from the Government to raise prices to help agriculture.

Sainsbury's paid £26 million but said it was "disappointed to have been penalised for actions that were intended to help British farmers". Tesco and Morrisons vowed to fight the allegations, claiming they had been found guilty before evidence had been heard.

In the original statement, OFT executive director Sean Williams said the case was "very serious" and "this kind of collusion on price is a very serious breach of the law".

Today it said the quotes from Williams "were not intended to suggest that the OFT had concluded that Morrisons was guilty of price-fixing". Tesco boss Sir Terry Leahy earlier lambasted the OFT for the way it handled the investigation, saying: "I think it would be good if it did the press releases and interviews at the end of the inquiry rather than the beginning."

Rival supermarkets were delighted that Morrisons had won a victory. One retailer said: "Good on them. There are an awful of investigations into supermarkets - it is the most regulated industry there is. It is encouraging that the OFT has had the courage to say it was wrong."

The OFT insists there is no chance Williams will be asked to resign but said it could not elaborate on the case for legal reasons. It says its probe into the price-fixing allegations will continue.

It is not yet known if a similar apology for Tesco is on the way. The Competition Commission is due to publish its latest report into the grocery sector later this month.

Reader views (1)

 Add your view

What a sad day for John Fingleton and us customers once again!
The OFT should remove ALL meat products from supermarket shelves,force ALL supermarkets to provide a separate government licenced and operated 'Butchers Shop' adjacent to their store where all meat products could be purchased - not just the products that sold the best - the price charged to be calculated on a fair price to the Farmer/Smallholder plus abattoir/transport charges.
If you get the impression I think all supermarkets are profiteering, shortchanging, money grubbing. You're right

- Mike Matthews, sutton, london, uk, 23/04/2008 13:46
Report abuse


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • Relief for Sir Mervyn as inflation takes a tumble Osb and mervyn Bank of England Governor Sir Mervyn King has gained a major victory in his battle to bring down the spiralling cost of living as inflation...
  • Yell dives as print blow outstrips digital leap Yell Beleaguered Yellow Pages directories publisher Yell has seen its shares plunge as much as a quarter after a worse-than-expected slump in...
  • BHP and Rio bet on copper with mine expansion Rio Tinto The future is looking copper-coloured for BHP Billiton and Rio Tinto after the mining giants announced plans to invest $4.5 billion (£2.9...
  • Why saving may start to make sense again - just Piggy bank savings Long-suffering savers at last had some good news today when inflation fell below 4%, meaning there are now seven standard savings accounts...
  • City says timing wrong in Moody's UK rating threat Euro City economists have raised doubts over the timing of the threat by rating agency Moody's to slash the UK's AAA sovereign credit score,...
  • Hotel giant goes for Olympic gold as profits wow the City Intercontinental Hotels Hotelier InterContinental Hotels is looking to emerging markets and especially China to drive future growth
  • Bloomsbury takes a new passage to India Fashion book Publisher Bloomsbury is to set up a new business in India to take advantage of rapidly growing demand from the country's English-speaking...
  • Thai disaster floods Lloyd's with a bill for £1.4 billion Lloyd's of London Thailand's worst flooding in 50 years last October will cost the Lloyd's of London insurance market $2.2 billion (£1.4 billion), it has...
  • Bank of Japan increases stimulus to boost growth Japan Bank of Japan has added 10 trillion yen (£83 billion) to its 20 trillion yen pool of funds set aside for asset purchases in a surprise move
  • Brammer sees profits jump Box of tricks: DIY tools can be expensive to buy Industrial services group Brammer has posted a 41% jump in full-year pretax profit on strong demand
  •  
    Market Roundup
    TUESDAY UPDATE

    Valentine's massacre as City dumps Hampson

    No one likes getting rejected on Valentine's Day

    More