Weather Afternoon: 9°c Sunny spells Tonight: 5°c Partly Cloudy Night

Business

Punch's Giles Thorley
Disappointed: Punch's Giles Thorley called the inquiry a 'distraction to the industry'

New blow for pubs as MPs roll out a probe

Simon English, Evening Standard
26 Jun 2008


Pub companies battered by the credit crunch, the smoking ban and the worst trading conditions for a decade woke up to another headache today - a fresh Government investigation into the industry.

Following pressure from landlord group Fair Pint, the Business and Enterprise Committee said it is launching a follow-up to the 2004 Trade and Industry report.

Committee chairman Peter Luff MP wants to see whether the pub companies are treating leaseholders fairly.

Landlords complain that the big pub companies raise rents whenever it suits them and overcharge for beer that they could better buy elsewhere. Luff is considering whether tougher regulation should be imposed - a potential disaster for the industry.

Four pubs close every day in the UK, something the pubcos blame on trading conditions. Critics say the business model of the big players is not viable.

The share prices have been devastated of late. Punch Taverns shares have halved in the last six weeks.

Giles Thorley, chief executive of Punch, said of the inquiry: "It is disappointing that this has come when we are putting significant effort into supporting our licensees following the effect of the smoking ban and the challenging trading climate. This will be a distraction for the industry." A move to break the tie that sees the owners of the properties also supply most of the beer sold in the pub would be especially worrisome.

Mark Brumby at Blue Oar Securities said: "Breaking the tie would obviously threaten the business model of Punch and Enterprise in its current form. The tone can only be said to be (potentially) very anti-pubco. The politicians have the chance to help (or to look as though they're helping) the little man ahead of an election. The pubcos need this like they need a hole in the head."

The British Beer and Pub Association welcomed the inquiry 'as a chance to lay to rest the misconceptions that have grown up around pub companies'.

The investigation will publish its conclusions later this year.

Reader views (1)

 Add your view

Pub companies aren't the ones being battered by the current market conditions. They've been milking it dry for a decade now. No, the people who are suffering are the tenants, people who have invested everything into their pubs only to see nothing come back. Around them their communities suffer as their local meeting places disappear, people lose their jobs, suppliers lose their customers.

Meanwhile the pubcos continue to squeeze every last drop of life out of their estates whilst moaning about how hard done by they are. Totally ignoring the people who been paying their wages as they are left homeless and penniless through greed.

An investigation should be welcomed with open arms, it's time that the pubcos powers were curbed, in fact some repatriation should be in order for the innocents who have suffered at their hands.

- Robert Barrow, Dolwyddelan North Wales, 01/07/2008 12:29
Report abuse


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • Moody's threat to Europe's banks sparks fury in City Euro problem graph Moody's has sent shockwaves through the global banking system and sparked fury in the City, as the ratings agency threatened to slash the...
  • Bank's China bond call Peter Sands One of London's most senior bankers is calling on the government to issue a renminbi-denominated bond as part of a charm offensive to boost...
  • Seven Olympus bosses held over £1bn fraud Olympus "After going to hell and back this is a day to remember," said fired Olympus boss and whistle-blower Michael Woodford after seven executives...
  • Spain pays for rating cut Struggling Spain has managed to prise another €4 billion (£3.3 billion) from jittery bond markets today but was forced to pay more for the privilege
  • Kingfisher bonus time as targets are smashed B&Q Ian Cheshire, B&Q owner Kingfisher's chief executive, and his top team are set for bumper payouts after smashing its bonus scheme's targets
  • Greek impasse hits euro Greek protesters European stock markets were jittery and the euro has dropped to its lowest level in four weeks as the brinksmanship between Greece and its...
  • PPR thrives as luxury brands remain strong Handbag Add £1000 python skin Gucci handbags to the list of things that remain popular despite the economic gloom
  • BAE set to axe more jobs as profits go into retreat BAE BAE Systems has raised the prospect of further job cuts as Britain's biggest manufacturer announced a disappointing set of results for 2011...
  • Reed Elsevier sees growth despite tough economy Anglo-Dutch publishing and events group Reed Elsevier reported a rise in full year profit and said it expected to generate more revenue and profit growth in 2012
  • Frothy profits at Heineken Beer The economy might be in dire straits but Brits still love a pint down the pub
  •  
    Market Roundup
    THURSDAY UPDATE

    Unilever urged to go for a break-up after food disappoints

    Is it time for Unilever to consider breaking up?

    More