Weather Morning: 14°c Cloudy Afternoon: 15°c Cloudy

Business

Former Moody’s chief attacks inflated ratings

23 Sep 2009


The role of ratings agencies was back in the spotlight today after a recently departed Moody's analyst said that inflated ratings are still being issued.

Eric Kolchinsky claimed Moody's Investors Service gave a high rating to a complicated debt security in January 2009 knowing it was planning to downgrade the assets that backed it.

Within months, the newly rated security was put under review for a potential downgrade.

“Moody's issued an opinion which was known to be wrong,” said Kolchinsky in a letter to the firm's chief compliance officer seen by the Wall Street Journal.

The major credit rating agencies were lambasted in the financial crisis for their overly rosy ratings of complex securities which turned out to be duds and triggered billions of pounds of losses.

Kolchinsky, a managing director at Moody's before he resigned, is due to testify to US lawmakers on ratings firm reform tomorrow.

He said he felt “some moral responsibility for the poor... ratings” issued under his watch.

“I was part of the process that did this damage and I feel I should try to do something now to make sure it doesn't happen again,” he said.

Reader views (1)

 Add your view

Who pays the rating agents their fees? Its only the people they are rating, lawyer would be struck off for this. Also, I fear the rating agencies do not understand the complex products they are being asked to rate and like the global regulators do not have the money to hire the best people. Mr Kolchinsky is confirming our fears.

- Andrew, London, 23/09/2009 22:26
Report abuse


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • RBS posts £2bn loss for 2011 RBS Taxpayer-backed Royal Bank of Scotland remained at the heart of the row over bankers' pay today as it unveiled total losses of £2 billion...
  • Clegg reveals £1bn jobs fund boost Nick Clegg An extra £1 billion is being made available to businesses seeking support to create new jobs, the Government has announced
  • British American Tobacco in £1.25bn buyback as earnings rise Cigarettes British American Tobacco, the world's second-biggest cigarette maker, increased its share buyback to £1.25 billion after it raised prices...
  • January mortgage approvals rise to two-year high First-time buyers UK mortgage approvals rose in January to the highest in two years as buyers tried to complete purchases before a property tax suspension...
  • British Gas owner profits up 1% gas ring Centrica has reported a small increase in full-year profit as higher commodity prices and mild weather offset gains in its upstream oil and...
  • Kier Group profit rises Building construction site Construction group Kier has reported a higher full-year underlying pretax profit citing a strong performance at its property division
  • Redrow's family focus pays off with H1 profit jump Construction Housebuilder Redrow has reported a jump in first half profit, driven by a focus on family houses
  • Court victory puts Tchenguiz brothers closer to huge damages win over SFO Tchenguiz The Serious Fraud Office has been dealt a major blow when the High Court ruled that the colourful Tchenguiz brothers can go ahead with a...
  • MPC doves spark Bank split with call for yet more QE David Miles A fierce debate over the health of the recovery split the Bank of England this month, as two rate-setters called for an even bigger boost to...
  • Banks in record payout for insurance mis-selling scandal UK banks paid out £1.9 billion in compensation to thousands of people last year over the massive mis-selling payment protection insurance scandal
  •  
    Market Roundup
    WEDNESDAY UPDATE

    CWW and Vodafone cool as Square Mile starts to doubt tie-up

    They may have started flirting but it appears that the City is rather sceptical about whether Cable & Wireless Worldwide and Vodafone will actually make it down the aisle

    More