Decca’s last dance
Norman Lebrecht23 Jun 2010
The great British label that launched the Rolling Stones has another number one hit this week — sadly, it will be the record company's swansong...
It's not often a record label scores a number one hit and shuts down in the same week, so keep an eye on Decca. Barring a last-minute change of heart, the Chiswick-based music icon is going to be wiped off the map before Valentine's Day.
The number one Decca hit is Julia Fischer's debut, a performance of the Bach violin concertos with the Academy of St Martin in the Fields, which can be heard on stage at Cadogan Hall this coming weekend. Fischer, 25, is a straight-talking Munich artist with a clear sense of priorities. “Bach has always been a part of my life,” she announces on a promotional video. “It was a must for me to record the violin concertos.” Rather than having to defer to a conductor, she directs the orchestra herself.
Her disc, top of the Billboard classical charts from the day of issue, came out in Britain this week and is moving, they say, very nicely. But the classical music business no longer follows shooting stars and the logic of the market. It's far too busy playing corporate games. Fischer's success is almost certain to be Decca's last.
Decca is a British brand, a piece of bedrock heritage that our forefathers took into the First World War trenches and danced to in the Depression years when Bing Crosby, Stéphane Grappelli and Louis Armstrong were its stalwarts. Vera Lynn sang the nation through the Second World War on Decca, after which a demobbed crew of submarine warriors applied their radar skills to producing the clearest sound anyone had ever heard on record. Decca introduced stereo, the LP and digital recording. It blazed a trail through an industry run by lazy lunchers and stuffed shirts. It may have turned down the Beatles, but it launched the Rolling Stones.
Classical was always its main business. Decca was a singers' label, with Kathleen Ferrier, Joan Sutherland and Luciano Pavarotti. It was an outlet for living composers, with Benjamin Britten and Michael Tippett. It produced the first Ring cycle on record and the first complete survey of Haydn symphonies. Extraordinarily, in a fickle milieu, it commanded lifelong loyalty from most of its artists. One soloist named each of her successive dogs Decca.
The label lost its way and its hold on the pop charts and in the Eighties was sold to a European group that owned its classical rivals Deutsche Grammophon (DG) and Philips. That formation, known as PolyGram, was absorbed into a multinational combine, Universal, operating out of Hollywood and New York. Decca thrived, with the 1990 Three Tenors concert turning into the top-selling classical album of all time. But its stars were ageing and, once Georg Solti and Pavarotti were gone, the Universal desk-jockeys began playing paperclip games with its future. Universal's head of classics and jazz, Christopher Roberts, is a man who believes that neither form can ever make enough money to justify his bonus. Roberts, from the mid-1990s, became a convert to crossover — a catch-all genre that involves getting old rockers like Sting to sing classical, baroque divas like Anne-Sofie von Otter to sing Abba and middle-roaders like Katharine Jenkins and Hayley Westenra to pretend that they are opera stars when they have never sung an opera in their short-breathed lives. The Universal dream of heaven is Bryn Terfel duetting with Ronan Keating. Nothing was too low for its taste. At one point Decca signed a sex-change Paddington street-walker, plucked off a BBC reality show where she was seen playing the piano.
Three years ago, Roberts appointed the subservient Bogdan Roscic as head of Decca and gave the label a predominantly crossover role, while keeping DG for a classical elite. But if crossover was to convince the grannies that it was a cultural product, it needed a DG imprimature. Once Ronan Keating had joined Elvis Costello and Sting on the supposedly highbrow imprint, followed by barrel-scrapings from television talent shows, Decca was left shivering in recessional snow.
Roscic had little to show for his three years other than a failed venture in live concert streaming and the signature three months ago of Julia Fischer, a promising violinist on a small Dutch outlet. When Roscic heard Roberts was planning to scrap Decca, he jumped ship last week to long-dormant Sony Classical, where he has been given a grand title but not much of a budget.
The handful of staff who remain in Decca's Chiswick offices are waiting for the chop. They expect to be told before the week is out that Decca is history, thanks for the memory.
In times like these when household names are vanishing daily, the loss of a record label hardly qualifies for national mourning. But the abolition of Decca is more than just another colophon going to the wall. Decca represented something to artists and record buyers. Once it was the label that scorned star power, sending tyrants like Herbert von Karajan into shock when producers and engineers refused to obey his orders. Decca was also a sound to remember, an uncluttered clarity: home-made, high-tech and unfailingly discreet, a sound that never played ping-pong with your ears.
These qualities have long been laid to rest, as the new Fischer disc all too grimly demonstrates: her sound is poorly balanced and over-bright. Any subtlety she may have tried to convey is blown out of all proportion by all-purpose engineering from a freelance team that has no history with Decca. Nor is there much sign of a producer's intervention. Fischer plays with steely athleticism but not much forethought or refinement. Comparison with the young Anne-Sophie Mutter, equally metallic but infinitely more controlled, puts Fischer firmly in the lower leagues. Decca in its heyday would not have passed this product.
Still, no point in waxing nostalgic. Lots of firms are going to the wall, taking their traditions to oblivion. Decca joins a long queue at the morgue. The regret is that what dies with Decca is more than just a label — it is the very concept of label as a mark of character, a name that united artists and listeners in the search for a particular quality. The idea of label defined the record industry. It is the strategic antithesis of sterile agglomerates like Universal.
Without labels, artists spin off to Starbucks, listeners lose interest and the remnants of the record business go rummaging in dumpbins. Even a number-one classical hit barely shifts 500 copies a week, not enough to support an executive's pension fund. It's the end of the line for Decca, the last waltz in a bare-walled studio of dreams.
Reader views (11)
you so right..the bigger record companies have a tendecy
to look at artists only and forget about the people behind these recordings a good procucer and recording engineers together they make the label everybody favourites and appreciated on the same level as the artist my special favourites are enigineers who worked for decca people like kenneth wilkinson and tony faulkner
those boys from polyhymnia holland record classic music
like a pop concert to close no ambiance from the hall
dry and hars and upfront and the solo artist constantly move in the stereo image listen to pentatone and now decca is the best way to create listening fatigue yes the old days of recording are passed and gone
- Fritz De With, amersfoort holland, 25/04/2009 09:10
Report abuse
'Julia Fischer, a promising violinist...' - Please, Mr Lebrecht! A comment like that could qualify you as the undisputed winner of the Gramophone award for understatement (and, if no such award exists, then it should do, after a remark of that nature) I'd suggest that your comment would be comparable to a sports commentator stating that Manchester United's Cristiano Ronaldo shows potential!!
NB - in the absense of an award for understatement, I'm sure there must be some kind of a gong, for pomposity, that we could present you with?
- John Dyson, UK, 25/02/2009 15:38
Report abuse
It is of course sad news. I expect the Philips label will disappear with Decca.
But the label started to fade years ago already as there are only a few new issues a year. The rest is/was reissueing older stuff that was not always up to date (Pavarotti, etc.) which is commercially not selling that much I think.
As a quite young person I never saw the real highlights of this label.
For me Decca is the label with some great opera recordings, concerting soloïsts (Ashkenazy, Lupu, Chung, Schiff ...) which happened some time ago and which are still OK. And recently I listened some interesting products (e.g. Freire, Chailly). Not that much, I see, as I'm writing this down.
Apparently no. 1 sellers like C. Bartoli, Janine Janssen, Gergiev, Fleming can't save this label.
One reason of course is the diverged landscape of classical music companies which is for us listeners very interesting, but it makes concurrence growing on.
Happily there now a lot of newer more inventive labels like Hyperion, Channel Cl, Bis, Cpo, Chandos, PentaTone, Zigzag and of course there is HMundi, that still growing company in France.
- Bas, belgium, 09/02/2009 14:54
Report abuse
No it did not have to happen and it should not happen. Music guys were replaced by beancounters. A concept for disaster. Granted, all major companies sat on their laurels while technology changed the business. The perceived value of music was brought down and the labels countered by selling for peanuts. Particularly in the UK. However, Mr. Roberts will find soon that he worked on his own swansong. Classical music sells over time and is not interesting for the day traders running this business. The good news: Music is not dead. It is very much alive. If given value for money, people will still pay for it. However, as long as the idea prevails amongst some that the buying public is between 16 and 25 years old and that one can disregard the rest, I see this business model going further down the drain.
- Dr. Heinig, Los Angeles, USA, 05/02/2009 14:23
Report abuse
Is there no respect for the fact people that if this was true, which is isn't, then people would lose their jobs? Yes, management may have got it wrong in the past but there are many, many fantastic staff at the label still working on interesting projects. Should Decca close, might I add this hasn't even been announced yet, then it will mean that instead of the UK classical music introducing new talented artists like Julia Fischer and Janine Jansen it will instead amount to faux classical singers like Katherine Jenkins and Faryl Smith. So perhaps Mr Lebrecht be careful what you wish for!
- Audrey, London, 05/02/2009 14:23
Report abuse
Laminated with "Clarifoil" made by British Celanese. The end of an era. Universal can keep its seemingly overloud, overcompressed and over noise-reduced CDs. I've gone back to vinyl.
- Oxenholme, Kendal, England, 05/02/2009 12:16
Report abuse
Well, it had to happen. Classical music becomes more and more a niche market. Labels like Bis and Hyperion know more about the future classical music lover then Universal...
Rolf
- Rolf Den Otter, Delft Netherlands, 05/02/2009 11:41
Report abuse
Incisive essay by Lebrecht. A postscript postmortem to his last book. Sad to hear the news.
- Eddie Williamson, Los Angeles, Calif. USA, 05/02/2009 04:47
Report abuse
A real shame. Decca made some of the greatest recordings of classical masterpieces. The aforementioned Solti Ring Cycle, Bohm's superb Bruckner 4 in the early 70's and Ashkenazy's sublime digital Sibelius cycle to name but a few. I will cherish my Decca collection all the more after reading this sad news.
- Jeremy O'Connor, London, UK, 04/02/2009 18:17
Report abuse
This is the most depressing news of the year ; Decca has showned the best artistic sense in record history since decades ! major artists , technicians and competences - a true patrimony of England victim of today's world ... a progress ? a better world ? where ????
- G D., Paris,, 04/02/2009 16:53
Report abuse
Great shame I was head creative for Decca for a number of years and I have a great fondness for the label, I have a lot of great memories and stories and meet a lot of wonderful talented people and artists. Very very sad especially for my friends who still work there.
- Mark Millington, Axminster, Devon. UK, 04/02/2009 16:41
Report abuse
Morning:
9°c















