Morning:
22°c
Boris Johnson gives his strong personal backing to Standard's campaign for a huge increase in cycle parking at London's railway stations
More...
Mayor 'forced' £98m buyout of Croydon tram service
Dick Murray, Transport Editor18.03.08
Mayor Ken Livingstone has bought out Croydon Tramlink in a deal costing £98 million.
But the move has triggered accusations that he forced the deal through by deliberately undermining the company.
Tramtrack Croydon Ltd has been engaged in a bitter battle with London's transport chief Peter Hendy over the future of the Tramlink, which carries 25 million passengers a year.
Transport for London said the current contract for the 17.5mile network was not flexible enough and forced TfL to make compensation payments over changes to fares and ticketing.
But Tramtrack claimed that TfL wanted to get rid of it and was motivated by a desire to seize control.
Tramtrack managing director Paul Davison accused the Mayor's authority of putting on extra buses to take away their passengers. "They've tried everything they can think of. They've sent letters trying to undermine us to our banks. They've taken us to court and lost," he said.
His general manager Roger Harding added: "Their way of negotiating is they decide what they will pay and then tell you that's it. They 'consult' you and then do exactly what they want."
TfL denied the allegations. A spokesman said: "All we are interested in is providing the best possible transport services for the public. This deal does that." Ken Livingstone said: "This will mean we can plan how to make the improvements required to cater for increasing numbers of passengers."
A TfL spokeswoman said that last year's compensation payment to Tramtrack was £4 million and the rate is increasing annually. "Taking control of Tramtrack Croydon means TfL will no longer have to make those payments."
TfL, expected to take over in summer, said current fares and ticketing arrangements would not change. Planned improvements include doubling off peak services between Elmers End and Beckenham Junction.
Reader views (5)
Here's a sample of the latest views published.
Don't be so quick to boast about the savings Andy, TfL spent £125m on building Tramlink in 1996, Tramtrack Croydon paid the other £100m. TfL were then paying Tramtrack £4m/year for over 10 years while they operated it. So before the buyout, Tramlink cost the taxpayer £165m. Now add on the £98m and we have spent a whopping total of over £260m on the trams. I make that a waste of £40m of taxpayer money
- Oran Hassan, Thornton Heath, Surrey
Love the maths, put the 98 Million in the bank and get 5-6 million a year in interest, so no it hasn't saved a penny.
- Vince, London, UK
Keep Ken out of Croydon, next we'll be having his bendy buses and roadside fires to deal with. Under him my council tax has rocketed and again, another case of him wanting state ownership of the transport system. Focus on your own in house problems Ken and leave the professionals to get on with it.
- Mark Ager, Croydon
The £98m is great value for money, rather than TfL paying Tramlink £4m per year (plus inflation,) until 2096. Just do the maths, TfL have saved Londoner's £254m (without inflation) at a stroke!
- Andy Barber, Sundridge, Bromley
Since when did the Mayor, London or TfL start owning parts of the transport infrastructure? What a waste of £98m.
- Nobby Clark, Perth, UK
