Weather Tonight: 8°c Mostly cloudy Morning: 10°c Cloudy

Sport

Michael Vaughan, Peter Moores and Geoff Miller
Where it all went wrong: from left to right Michael Vaughan, Peter Moores and Geoff Miller discuss team tactics at Headingley

Miller clears the air with Vaughan

David Lloyd, Cricket Correspondent
24 Jul 2008


Geoff Miller insists there is no friction between himself and Michael Vaughan over the captain's comments following England's Headingley hammering.

Miller and fellow selectors Peter Moores, James Whitaker and Ashley Giles met in the wake of South Africa's 10-wicket victory in the Second Test, then the head of the panel went alone to see Vaughan.

Vaughan's post-match remarks suggesting his team lacked unity at Leeds, and that the controversial choice of Darren Pattinson to replace back injury victim Ryan Sidebottom caused confusion, clearly concerned Miller as well as claims that no-one in England's hierarchy wanted to be held responsible.

But national selector Miller insists there has been no falling out.

"I fully understand what Michael was saying and, as people will appreciate, things can be taken out of context," said Miller. "But it's all cleared up and we move on, which we've got to do.

"The selectors sat down to analyse the last Test - and there were a lot of things to analyse - and to discuss what we are going to try to do at Edgbaston next week. Michael was not involved in that meeting [because he's not a selector] so I wanted to have a chat with him, on my own, to clarify everything.

"There's no friction at all between Michael and the selectors."

Picking the almost unknown Anglo-Aussie Pattinson ahead of Matthew Hoggard or Steve Harmison led to England being widely criticised.

But Miller continues to defend both Pattinson and the thinking that earned him a Test debut.

He said: "We are held responsible, and I am held responsible, for the decisions [to first put Pattinson on stand-by for injury doubt Jimmy Anderson and then play him ahead of Chris Tremlett when Sidebottom failed his fitness test]. And they were made with the right intentions."

Miller also reiterated his belief that Pattinson was the 'form horse' among swing bowlers outside the original squad and did not let anyone down at Headingley when judged against the performances of England's other bowlers.

"Now we've got to go again and pick a squad for Edgbaston," said Miller. "You can't dwell on Headingley. It's gone, and we have to move on and sort something out for the next Test."

Despite the debate over Pattinson's inclusion at Headingley, it was England's first innings batting which put South Africa on the road to victory.

Vaughan's men were not helped by the conditions, and had a couple of important decisions go against them, but being bowled out for 203 last Friday did the real damage.

That collective failure should be enough to dissuade England from repeating their decision to play only five front-line batsmen next Wednesday. But if it isn't, then either Andrew Flintoff must bat at No6 or the selectors will need to replace Tim Ambrose with his wicketkeeping predecessor, Matt Prior.

Much more likely is the reintroduction of Paul Collingwood at No6 with Warwickshire's Ambrose dropping down two places to a more comfortable No8 on his home ground.

Reader views (0)

 Add your view

No comments have so far been submitted.


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • Andre Villas-Boas: Roman Abramovich's still backing me even if players aren't Andre Villas-Boas Andre Villas-Boas is confident he still has the support of Chelsea owner Roman Abramovich and insists he is not worried if the players back...
  • There's no way back as bemused Arsene Wenger wrestles with Euro crisis Zlatan Ibrahimovic Manager's unswerving faith in his stumbling players is designed to foster team spirit but it seemed complacency was the only consequence...
  • Ryan Giggs could learn the job at Jose Mourinho's side Ryan Giggs Patrick Barclay: The argument for Giggs as Mourinho's Old Trafford assistant is attractive. Jose often has a link with the...
  • Harry Redknapp drops England hint but agonises over Spurs Harry Redknapp Harry Redknapp has suggested it would be possible to combine the role of Premier League manager and England boss until after Euro 2012 but...
  • Chelsea want Petr Cech and Daniel Sturridge to stay at Stamford Bridge Daniel Sturridge Chelsea insist Petr Cech and Daniel Sturridge are part of their long-term plans and will not be leaving Stamford Bridge
  • Money is only thing that finally brought barking Carlos Tevez to heel Carlos Tevez Dan Jones: Carlos Tevez's absurd reaction to that night in Munich last September has been to undertake a one-man strike...
  • Andrei Arshavin and Tomas Rosicky must leave Arsenal, says Emmanuel Petit Andrei Arshavin Former Arsenal midfielder Emmanuel Petit has warned the club need to get rid of a host of their big names and sign six established players...
  • Gunners bring out the devil in a lazy mime artist Zlatan Ibrahimovic Dan Jones: The man wielding the cane on Arsenal at the San Siro was football's most enigmatic, quicksilver galoot: Zlatan...
  • The battle for Warren Farm Tony Fernandes QPR have targeted a site for new £6m training ground but could lose out to non-League Southall
  • Sir Alex Ferguson will play his stars in Europa League Sir Alex Ferguson Sir Alex Ferguson has conceded he got it wrong in the Champions League this season as Manchester United prepare to make their debut in the...
  •