Weather Tonight: 5°c Partly Cloudy Night Morning: 9°c Cloudy

Sport

Luka Modric
Foreign invasion: Spurs' big summer signing Luka Modric takes on Chelsea's Juliano Belletti and Michael Essien

Foreign threat to English game

Simon Johnson and Tom Collomosse, Evening Standard
4 Sep 2008


England begin their World Cup qualifying campaign on Saturday against Andorra with the game at a crossroads in this country.

Under-21 boss Stuart Pearce told Manchester City's new Arab owners in Standard Sport yesterday that they have to protect the fabric of English football.

He fears that trillionaires intent on bringing instant success no matter what the cost for foreign stars like £32.5million Robinho will damage the chances of young English players like Joe Hart, Micah Richards and Michael Johnson.

England failed to qualify for Euro 2008 this summer. They cannot fail to qualify for the World Cup in South Africa in 2010 or more damage will be done to our national game.

The situation is becoming so bad that one manager, Neil Warnock of Crystal Palace, said: "There should be a limit to the amount of foreign players in our league. There are too many in our game at the moment.

"People need to make the choice. Do we want a great Premier League or a great national team. If they want the former then just keep going as it is but if want a successful national side, we have to restrict the amount of foreigners in each team.

"I hardly ever watch the England team anymore, I don't enjoy watching the team play. It is just so poor."

Our research shows that the number of English players in the top flight has now dropped to alarming levels.

Of the 72 who were on duty [each team has 11 starters and seven substitutes] for the big four of Arsenal, Chelsea, Manchester United and Liverpool in their last match, only 13 were from this country.

We asked five leading English figures from every facet of the game for their opinions. All are worried by the foreign invasion.

THE MANAGER - Steve Bruce, Wigan

Q1. Should there be a quota system to limit the number of foreign players in a team?

No. I don't think that idea would work. The Premier League is the best in the world because we have most of the best players over here and they have raised the standards incredibly.

Q2. How important is the presence of home-grown players in English teams?

It's important but we have 40-odd football academies up and down the country and they don't seem to be producing the players to get into first teams in the numbers that everyone would like. Maybe the systems which the kids are in are not quite set up right.

Q3. Are you worried about the future of the England national team?

I think we are all worried - the English managers for certain. We see our top players perform superbly every week for their clubs and we build them up to be some of the best in the world but we did not even manage to qualify for the Euro 2008 tournament.

THE PLAYER - Sean Davis, Portsmouth

1. It's a difficult one to answer because a lot of foreign players have come over here and improved our League. But there are also a lot of young English players not getting their chance. At the moment we have a number of players in the England squad who also play in the Champions League but if that number falls, then we have to do something about it.

2. It is good to have English boys around but at Portsmouth there is a mix of nationalities and we all get on really well. We need a healthy balance of English and foreign players.

3. I don't understand why it's going wrong because we have outstanding players. But if more young talent doesn't come through, maybe it will affect things further down the line.

THE CHAIRMAN - Barry Hearn, Leyton Orient

1. I don't think we can ever restrict it because of the European labour laws. We have to look to support our own national game. The Premier League should give more money to the lower leagues to help fund youth development. At the moment it is a fraction of what clubs spend on foreign players and they should be encouraged to help the grass roots.

2. It's vital. I can understand the attraction of the superstars but there are a lot of foreign players who wouldn't be here if we had enough of our own. The Premier League clubs are also signing too many from overseas for their academies.

3. It's a natural progression. If there are less players playing at the highest level, then it is inevitable the standard of the national team will decline. That worries me because when the national team are doing well it's a shot in the arm for all of us.

THE AGENT - Jon Smith, First Artist agency

1. It is a fantastic thing to have the biggest players in the world being involved in our game and I would fight against having a quota on overseas players.

2. I do believe there should be a reserve for English players in all Premier League clubs. Maybe three or four players would have to be English in each team.

3. I am worried. The problem is that the Premier League is an industry and a business. The England football team are a totally separate entity, yet they have to co-exist. What the answer to the problem is I don't know.

THE FANS - Jon Keen, the deputy chairman of Football Supporters' Federation

1. Yes, there should be a quota system - but a guarded yes. Six plus five has been mooted as the figure but I'm not sure that should be the case. Setting a definitive figure is very difficult.

2. From the Premier League's point of view in terms of global branding, it's important to have as many foreign players as possible playing in the League. But the more foreign players who come in, the more it takes clubs away from their traditional communities and supporter bases.

3. Yes, I am worried about the state of our national team. It's clear that the people who are running the English game must decide whether they want to have the most lucrative league in the world or the most successful national team in the world.

Reader views (1)

 Add your view

English youths are brought up with little footballing tradition,a lot of foreign players wouldn't come to trade their skills in England if there are enough of skillful players on hand. Soccer is a big business, business oriented FA should do enough to encourage grass roots player, families should encourage their children to play soccer if they are to mine the gold made available in soccer playing. Soccer is a business, premiership is business, quota system will ruin the game.

- Olorunsogbon Gbenga, IL,USA, 05/09/2008 04:53
Report abuse


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • Andre Villas-Boas has an impossible job at Chelsea, says Porto president Andre Villas-Boas Andre Villas-Boas' efforts to turn around Chelsea are being damaged by Jose Mourinho's regular contact with the players, it is claimed
  • Chris Powell: racist abuse between players was accepted in my day Chris Powell Exclusive: After high-profile allegations this season, Charlton's manager Chris Powell is pleased the issue is now being...
  • FA long game will only make muddle worse Alf Ramsey Patrick Barclay: According to Graham Taylor, it can take a manager 18 months to adjust from club football to the different...
  • PFA urged John Terry to quit England captaincy for European Championships John Terry Exclusive: John Terry refused a plea from the Professional Footballers' Association to step down as England captain until...
  • Has Arsene Wenger really found a new batch of San Siro heroes? Cesc Fabregas The Champions League clash between Arsenal and AC Milan will determine whether critics are right to question the strength and ability of...
  • Carlos Tevez targets Manchester City return in two weeks Carlos Tevez Carlos Tevez was due to arrive in England this morning determined to win back his place in the Manchester City team and prepared to...
  • Rangers appoint administrators  Craig Whyte Rangers have today appointed administrators Duff and Phelps after a court battle with Her Majesty's Revenue & Customs
  • Nicky Maynard itching to make his West Ham debut against Southampton Nicky Maynard Nicky Maynard is confident that he will be able to score if called upon to make his West Ham debut in the club's top-of-the-table showdown...
  • Ravi Bopara and Steven Finn turn tide to stop tour sliding into a complete disaster Ravi Bopara England have won a match and for their next trick they plan to win a series. Anything is possible now after their victory in the opening...
  • Portsmouth prepare for 10-point penalty Fratton Park Portsmouth are set to go into administration for the second time in two years leaving the club facing a 10-point penalty
  •