Weather Morning: 9°c Sunny spells Afternoon: 10°c Sunny spells

Sport

Harry Redknapp
Big challenge: Harry Redknapp's new side face a trip to the biggest rivals tomorrow night

Arsene Wenger's success casts long shadow

Tom Collomosse
28 Oct 2008


It is a sign of the contrasting fortunes of the two north London clubs that tomorrow night Arsene Wenger will lock horns with a ninth Tottenham manager since arriving at Arsenal.

The Frenchman joined the Gunners 12 years ago at a time when Spurs were relatively stable under Gerry Francis but since then the managerial merry-go-round has spun feverishly at White Hart Lane, culminating in Harry Redknapp's appointment on Saturday.

Anyone seeking to explain why Arsenal have held the upper hand over their great rivals in modern times must start with the sitatution in the two dugouts.

The most ardent Spurs fans could argue that their team is closing the gap, winning the Carling Cup this year, while Arsenal have not won a trophy since lifting the FA Cup in 2005.

But overall, in Wenger's 12 seasons at the helm, Arsenal can boast three Premier League titles and four FA Cups, doing the Double in 1998 and 2002, and also reaching the Champions League final in 2006 and the UEFA Cup final six years earlier.

Spurs, by comparison, have won two League Cups, the first under former Arsenal boss George Graham and then Juande Ramos this February, during that period. They have never played in the Champions League.

The Gunners have also been dominant in derby matches, as Wenger has been beaten only twice in 29 matches, 2-1 by Graham's team in November 1999, and 5-1 by Ramos' men in the second leg of last season's Carling Cup semi-final.

Francis, 56, who is now working as a coach for Stoke City, believes that being forced to watch Arsenal's successes from such close proximity has influenced decision-making at Spurs.

He said: "If a club is desperate to win and do well, they do not show so much patience, whereas if you are successful, there are not so many changes.

"The north London derby is important to both clubs, but more so to Tottenham. They have not been able to win things regularly, so they want to put one over on Arsenal.

"It does not help Spurs' situation if Arsenal are winning at home and doing well in Europe, because it creates extra pressure.

"It is similar to the situation in Manchester, with United and City. Ask City fans what it is like. The only chance you get to put one over on your rival is in the derby games."

Francis guided Spurs to seventh in 1995, eighth in 1996, and tenth in 1997, before resigning after a poor start to the 1997/98 season.

On the added pressures now facing former Portsmouth boss Redknapp, he added: "Look at Martin Jol. He finished in fifth place in the Premier League in 2006 and 2007, and if Harry got two fifth-placed finishes in a row, he would be doing very well - but Martin Jol still lost his job.

"At a club like Portsmouth, you can have a hiccup or a bad start, and there is not the same pressure on you, so you can get out of it.

"But at Tottenham, you are always under the cosh. Everything is magnified. It is a great opportunity for Harry, but he will find a huge difference in the expectation levels between Spurs and Portsmouth."

Spurs are also falling behind Arsenal off the pitch, according to football finance expert Professor Tom Cannon, of the University of Liverpool.

Cannon said: "In this market place, Spurs are losing massively against their big rivals Arsenal in north London.

"Not so long ago, Tottenham were considered roughly the same size as Arsenal, but now Arsenal are a club worth about £770million, while Spurs would be worth about £200m."

But George Graham, who managed Arsenal from 1986 until 1995 before taking charge of Spurs from 1998 until 2001, believes Redknapp is the perfect man to drag Spurs back towards the top of the English game.

He added: "Harry is the ideal choice for Spurs. He has proved that, and it is great to see a British manager getting a top job."

Reader views (3)

 Add your view

Is Rob lonely, is he just a Gemini or should he be getting over himself.

He seems to have two stage names, as he is obviously Gooner Rob also !!!!

- Kevin, North London, London, UK, 29/10/2008 00:50
Report abuse

Speaking of top English managers, what is Gerry Francis doing coaching at Stoke? He is one of the few English-born managers around today who truly has the skill to manage a top football club.

- Les, London, 28/10/2008 12:28
Report abuse

Tootenham should have stuck with Martin Jol, an excellent manager, as is being shown in Germany. This nonsense about English managers has reared its ugly nationalistic head again. There are'nt any top English managers, you only have to look at the idiotic selction of Steve MacClaren as England manager. He was, as I predicted, a disaster as England manager. We didnt show enough respect for Sven's achievements, which will be emulated by Cappello. The top premiership managers are Benitez, Scolari, Wenger & Fergerson, none of which are English. Harry Rednapp will only achieve mid-table wih Spurs this season & possibly 5th or 6th place, at best, next season with Spurs. He has proved to be a disloyal manager, walking out on teams whilst under contract. His best achievement has been an F A Cup win & UEFA cup qualification & avoiding relegation. Maybe these are the dreams of Spurs fans?

- Rob Gooner, North London, 28/10/2008 10:16
Report abuse


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • Thierry Henry set for final game for Arsenal against AC Milan Thierry Henry Thierry Henry will play his final game for Arsenal at the San Siro with manager Arsene Wenger wishing he could stay for longer
  • Carlos Tevez back in the fold at Manchester City Carlos Tevez Carlos Tevez is beginning the task of winning back Manchester City's trust after ending his self-imposed exile to return to the club
  • England's luck is in as Charlie Hodgson leads the charge Charlie Hodgson Fly-half never gave up on Test career and that spirit is serving the team well
  • I've played at Wembley, thanks to the JLS boys Phillips Idowu Phillips Idowu exclusive: JLS are a cool bunch of guys, I've got all their albums and I've followed them closely since The...
  • Roman Abramovich must bite the bullet and give Andres Villas-Boas some space Roman Abramovich James Olley: The problem for any manager playing Russian Roulette with Roman Abramovich is the slight rule change at...
  • Arsene Wenger will keep faith in youth for AC Milan clash Arsene Wenger Arsene Wenger has challenged his young Gunners to once again rise to the occasion when Arsenal tackle AC Milan in the first leg of their...
  • Bernie Ecclestone rejects notion that Bahrain Grand Prix will not go ahead Bernie Ecclestone Bernie Ecclestone sees no reason for this season's Bahrain Grand Prix not to go ahead despite violence flaring again on the island kingdom
  • Sean Dyche delighted with Valentine's Day victory for hard-working Watford Craig Forsyth Watford boss Sean Dyche hailed the Hornets' team spirit as they made it 10 points from 12 to continue their upward movement in the...
  • Dougie Freedman satisfied with Crystal Palace's draw at Bristol City Dougie Freedman Dougie Freedman refused to criticise his Crystal Palace players for surrendering a two-goal lead as they left Bristol City with just a point
  • Javier Hernandez ready to embrace Europa League Javier Hernandez It might be a Thursday night on Channel Five - but Manchester United's clash with Ajax does sound like a Champions League game
  •