Weather Morning: 8°c Mostly cloudy Afternoon: 9°c Sunny spells

Sport

Noel O’Brien and Phil Smith
Weighty issues: handicappers Noel O’Brien and Phil Smith in discussion

Wind and lots of hot air on agenda at National lunch

Paul Fielder
11 Feb 2009


The announcement of the John Smith's Grand National weights has given racing plenty to talk about in the build up to the big race on 4 April.

The weights were revealed at a special lunch in London hosted by the BBC's Clare Balding at the Park Lane Sheraton Hotel.

She was in top form and, for starters, lavished praise on Tony McCoy's achievement of reaching 3,000 winners.

Balding then invited National winning jockey Mick Fitzgerald to give his views on the big race and introduced the former jockey as the "new At The Races, BBC, Channel 4 presenter, well, anyone that will pay him".

Fitzgerald saw the funny side and was soon revealing that he thought the Evan Williams-trained State Of Play looked attractively weighted on 10st 8lb.

Next up was BHA handicapper Phil Smith who had to hastily reframe the weights following the last minute withdrawal of ante-post favourite Denman.

He admitted that Willie Mullins's Snowy Morning caused him the most trouble when framing the weights. Mullins, who failed to reveal his No1 Cheltenham Bumper contender when asked, was far from complimentary about the handicapper when questioned by the BBC's Rishi Persad shortly afterwards.

Radio Five Live's Cornelius Lysaght then asked Jackdaws Castle trainer Jonjo O'Neill about the merits of Butler's Cabin, who has got in off an attractive weight of 10st 5lb.

Soon after, trainer Charlie Mann was under the Lysaght interrogation. But it was soon apparent that no one knew why. Mann has two contenders for the Aintree showpiece but, from the start, continually told the BBC man that Air Force One was 12 months away from going for the race and that his second string Nadover had little chance of getting into the final field of 40.

Lysaght thanked Mann for being interviewed and looked forward to him being invited back in a year's time "even if it was just to have lunch".

Stars of the show were Charles Egerton who revealed that two of his three entries - Hobbs Hill and Darkness - had had wind operations and that he was thinking of having one himself and the comedy duo that is Nigel Twiston-Davies and Philip Hobbs. Twiston-Davies was accused of knocking his rival over and dislocating his shoulder on the ski slopes recently while Hobbs revealed that NTD doesn't hold back in telling him that he has two National winners to his none - including when What's Up Boys was run out of it by Bindaree in 2002.

Persad, who tried all he knew in an attempt to chat up trainer Venetia Williams, was soon asking Irish trainer Tom Mullins what he would do if he was stuck in a lavatory with Smith and Irish handicapper Noel O'Brien after being less than impressed with Chelsea Harbour's weight of 11 stone. Mullins quite simply said: "I can't imagine being in that situation."

But what were the clues to be garnered? David Pipe quite fancies Comply Or Die for a repeat victory once he puts the blinkers back on despite the fact that the horse was the only one he didn't mention at this stage 12 months ago; Willie Mullins would be keen on Irish Invader if she got a run and Rishi's still trying with Venetia as far as we know.

Reader views (0)

 Add your view

No comments have so far been submitted.


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • Arsene Wenger urges Arsenal to rally for Sunderland clash after 'shocking' defeat to AC Milan Kevin-Prince Boateng Arsene Wenger urged Arsenal to regroup for their FA Cup fifth-round tie at Sunderland after a "shocking" 4-0 defeat to AC Milan shattered...
  • Money is only thing that finally brought barking Carlos Tevez to heel Carlos Tevez Dan Jones: Carlos Tevez's absurd reaction to that night in Munich last September has been to undertake a one-man strike...
  • Drome from home: Australia's cyclists set for London test Velodrome Australia's in-form cyclists arrive in London for event which will give them a potentially vital feel for the Olympic velodrome
  • Where was Roger Federer on my horrible Valentine's Day? Roger Federer Lizzie Armitstead: Okay, I know Roger Federer is married and he's a bit old for me but I love the suits that he wears at...
  • Manu Tuilagi ready to make fresh start in England colours Manu Tuilagi Manu Tuilagi has done a lot of growing up in the last six months and now feels ready to make a fresh start with England after overcoming a...
  • Sir Alex Ferguson accepts European failings this season Sir Alex Ferguson Manchester United boss Sir Alex Ferguson has conceded he got it wrong in Europe this season
  • Roberto Mancini will not be distracted by Carlos Tevez saga Carlos Tevez Manchester City boss Roberto Mancini is determined not to let the continuing Carlos Tevez saga derail his side's title push
  • Chris Robshaw to captain England for rest of Six Nations Chris Robshaw Chris Robshaw will lead England for the rest of the Six Nations after winning his two games as captain
  • Sir Alex Ferguson: Manchester United and Liverpool need each other Luis Suarez Sir Alex Ferguson has admitted his Manchester United side need a healthy rivalry with Liverpool
  • Javier Hernandez ready to embrace Europa League Javier Hernandez It might be a Thursday night on Channel Five - but Manchester United's clash with Ajax does sound like a Champions League game
  •