Weather Tonight: 4°c Partly Cloudy Night Morning: 8°c Cloudy

Sport

Phil Vickery and Steve Borthwick
Frustrating: England captain Steve Borthwick remonstrates with the referee after he showed Phil Vickery a yellow card against Ireland

The deadly sin-bins that cost England

Ben Bailey
3 Mar 2009


It can't be easy being Martin Johnson. The England head coach had to watch on Saturday as his side had two men sent off for the third match in a row. Here we look at the six guilty offenders, and how England were punished for their mistakes...



Ireland 14-13 England

Phil Vickery (55th minute)

What happened: You can understand Martin Johnson's frustration. All of Croke Park watched as referee Craig Joubert called Steve Borthwick over and told the England captain that any more penalties would result in a sin-binning. Barely minutes later, former England skipper Phil Vickery was penalised for killing the ball. True to his word Joubert reached for his yellow card and Vickery was sent to the stands.

Result: At the time the visitors were pinned back on their own line, and it only took Ireland two minutes to make their advantage count, as Brian O'Driscoll powered over the line.

Danny Care (69th minute)

What happened: Replacement scrum-half Danny Care only managed 11 minutes on the field before he was dismissed. The number nine received his marching orders after shoulder charging Marcus Horan. Martin Johnson reacted furiously as he watched the substitute trudge off.

Result: At that stage Ireland were leading 11-6 going into the last 10 minutes. England had to play the rest of the game with 14 men as Ronan O'Gara converted the penalty taking the hosts to 14-6, and out of sight.


Wales 23-15 England

Mike Tindall (16th minute)

What happened: Only minutes into the match, Steve Borthwick had already been given his now routine berating from the referee for his side's indiscipline. Borthwick went back and warned his players, but Mike Tindall, seemingly convinced that the rules didn't apply to him, continued to use his hands in the ruck. It may have been Tindall's first offence, but Jonathan Kaplan made an example of the England centre, dismissing him only 16 minutes into the game.

Result: Stephen Jones converted the penalty to give Wales a 6-0 lead.

Andy Goode (42nd minute)

What happened: At half-time England were a point behind Wales and in the match. Then they went out for the second half and almost immediately the game changed. Having made a try-saving tackle, stopping Jamie Roberts down the right wing, Goode successfully slowed the game down by killing the ball. Goode was sin-binned for his actions but never rejoined the action, and was substituted for Toby Flood.

Result: Stephen Jones kicked the penalty, again, putting the home side four points ahead. Wales then made the extra man count as Leigh Halfpenny scored in the corner, as the home side exploited the holes in the England back line.


England 36-11 Italy

James Haskell (34th minute)

What happened: In a game mired by basic errors, James Haskell was sent off for one of England's more petulant fouls. Haskell had no excuse after he left a trailing leg out and tripped Gonzalo Canale off the ball after the Italian had chipped it over Haskell and was giving chase.

Result: Italy had two penalties while the Wasps man was warming the bench, scoring three points. In the second half they came out an invigorated side putting the 14 men of England under pressure.

Shane Geraghty (63rd minute)

What happened: Geraghty came on as a sub for Riki Flutey on the hour mark. The over-eager young centre hadn't even touched the ball, when he was sent off for tackling Luke McLean in the air after less than four minutes. Martin Johnson could only bury his head in his hands.

Result: Italy were the better team in the second-half, moving the ball across the pitch with great fluidity and purpose. Substitute Luke McLean went on a wonderful run through the England midfield and, after the ball was recycled, Italy's Mirco Bergamasco went over for a try.

Reader views (1)

 Add your view

I am already looking forward to the next sin bins. Maybe with a little flutter on the side to make it interesting?
Watching Martin Johnsons face turn angry is more rewarding than his teams play.

- Dave Davies, Basingstoke, Hants, 04/03/2009 14:37
Report abuse


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • Chris Robshaw to captain England for rest of Six Nations Chris Robshaw Chris Robshaw will lead England for the rest of the Six Nations after winning his two games as captain
  • Thierry Henry set for final game for Arsenal against AC Milan Thierry Henry Thierry Henry will play his final game for Arsenal at the San Siro with manager Arsene Wenger wishing he could stay for longer
  • I've played at Wembley, thanks to the JLS boys Phillips Idowu Phillips Idowu exclusive: JLS are a cool bunch of guys, I've got all their albums and I've followed them closely since The...
  • Chelsea stars say 'get Guus ­Hiddink in now' Guus ­Hiddink Senior Chelsea players want Guus ­Hiddink to return to Stamford Bridge as manager and save the club's season
  • Robin Van Persie has score to settle on his return to big stage Arsenal players Arsenal striker was harshly sent off this time last year but a brilliant run of form since has put him in a perfect position to put his...
  • England's luck is in as Charlie Hodgson leads the charge Charlie Hodgson Fly-half never gave up on Test career and that spirit is serving the team well
  • Shed tears for taxpayers not Rangers fans Rangers Ibrox Patrick Barclay: Administration is no fun for any club but it is still a relatively easy way out for the owners and...
  • Sean Dyche delighted with Valentine's Day victory for hard-working Watford Craig Forsyth Watford boss Sean Dyche hailed the Hornets' team spirit as they made it 10 points from 12 to continue their upward movement in the...
  • Alan Curbishley is No1 choice for Wolves Alan Curbishley Alan Curbishley is due to be interviewed for the job of Wolves manager
  • Javier Hernandez ready to embrace Europa League Javier Hernandez It might be a Thursday night on Channel Five - but Manchester United's clash with Ajax does sound like a Champions League game
  •