Weather Morning: 9°c Sunny spells Afternoon: 10°c Sunny spells

Sport

Lewis Hamilton and Jarno Trulli
Road to ruin: Jarno Trulli leads Lewis Hamilton at the Australian Grand Prix and the Italian got one up on the champion again today

Formula One stages another sorry farce

David Smith
2 Apr 2009


It could only happen in Formula One. Just last Sunday, Lewis Hamilton was being lauded for a stupendous drive from 18th on the grid to third place in the Australian Grand Prix. The way in which he carved through the pack, exploiting his exquisite driving skill to make up for the deficiencies of a clearly uncompetitive McLaren, confirmed his world title last season was no fluke.

Today, he has effectively been labelled a liar by stewards investigating the circumstances by which the British star was awarded a podium place in Melbourne at the expense of Italian rival Jarno Trulli.

Hamilton's reputation for being a hard but fair competitor has been called into question. Three weeks after being presented with an MBE by the Queen for his services to sport, his sportsmanship has been left open to question by an official ruling that he and his team provided "deliberately misleading" evidence to an inquiry in Melbourne looking into the Trulli affair.

As a man who takes his responsibilities as a role model extremely seriously, that will hurt. But then the first black driver in Formula One has already been battered and bruised by a litany of run-ins with the authorities in addition with being targeted for racial abuse.

Hamilton's dream, almost from when he was first able to walk, was to become a successful racing driver. But he must now be wondering whether the years of single-minded dedication aimed realising his ambitions were worth it.

For not only has his own reputation been called into question, but the whole credibility of Formula One lies in tatters.

Barely had the sport recovered from the Spygate scandal, in which McLaren were fined £50million for being in possession of technical secrets belonging to Ferrari, and from a sex scandal involving the president of the international governing body, Max Mosley, than the new season has been tainted by new rows and controversy.

Don't forget that we're still not sure who finished first and second in Australia. Television pictures showed Britain's Jenson Button taking the chequered flag ahead of Brazilian team-mate Rubens Barrichello in their Brawn GP cars.

It was a magnificent feel-good story, with a team that had barely existed at the start of last month successfully clearing all kinds of obstacles not only to get their cars onto the starting grid but to beat the world's elite into the bargain. But three members of that elite - Ferrari, Renault and Red Bull - were not happy with team owner Ross Brawn's interpretation of rules regarding diffusers, which aid aerodynamic performance.

A protest was lodged, and the outcome of the opening round of the title chase will now be decided by the FIA at their Paris headquarters on 14 April.

Were Brawn to lose then Trulli, who crossed the finish in third, was kicked down to 12th within an hour and restored to third five days later will be named the winner of the Australian Grand Prix 16 days after everyone had packed up and left Melbourne.

If that proves to be the case, ridicule will pile upon ridicule and the whole pit lane may as well pack up and go and find a fairground where they play dodgem cars to their hearts content.

Because Formula One, for all the millions of pounds spent on it, for all the interest manufacturers take in it, for all that drivers like Hamilton commit to it, will be rendered meaningless.

Reader views (6)

 Add your view

Lewis Hamiltons perceived offence of overtaking under yellow caution conditions (which started this whole stupid affair) was rediculous in the first place.
When the driver he was following went off the track, what was Hamilton & the rest of the field supposed to do? Stop & wait for the off track driver to get out of the sand trap & rejoin the circuit in front of them?
As for the sour grapes of 3 other teams against Braun, the mind boggles.
Get rid of the unrealistic controlers of F1 and lets get some common sense people running the sport.

- Colin Anderson, dunstable, england, 04/04/2009 00:18
Report abuse

why cant the stewards in F 1 leave Lewis Hamilton alone
last year they picked on him now its starting all over again i love watching this sport leave him to do what he loves doing in my opinion its the stewards who need to go and the sooner the better

- N Taylor, london, 03/04/2009 22:27
Report abuse

Drivers risk their lives for this sport and it is such a shame that they have to be penalised for the teams mistakes. Surely the drivers points should not be in jeapordy, but the constructors should take the brunt of any ruling if it is not driver error.

- Deirdre Leighton, Devon, England, 03/04/2009 17:46
Report abuse

The problem is too many nick picking rules,which change every year,for the so called better for f1,its not a sport no more its just a big money making enterprise, for the chosen few, and i think bernie ecklesteinberg, decides who gets it, there should be a big shake up with the FIA, get rid of some of these idiots who run it, i am blowing out FI and switching to touring car racing, much better

- Mr W Meller, whitstable, 03/04/2009 14:08
Report abuse

I think that with regard to lewis hamilton from what I have seen already he has won the last race fair and square.
I think that eveybody should just shut the hell up and let the guy prove his worth,lets not forget a certan michael schumacher who put the sport into disrepute a few seasons ago.
Lewis hamilton is not only a bloody good driver but also one that has decent morals aswell as values to his already good record.

- Mr J. Wilks, kettering,united kingdom, 03/04/2009 12:58
Report abuse

The credibility of F1 should not be clouded with some fundamental principles. Hamilton LIED to get his fellow professional into trouble and take two extra points from him. This is very serious and cannot be overlooked even if the credibility of F1 is further damaged. The problem is the knowledge of his lie puts a question to some of the expalanation he gave last year. e.g. He did not see the red lights at the end of the pit lane and ran into the rear of Raikkonen's stationery car in 2008 Montreal GP. Raikkonen would have gone on to win the race and close the gap in the Championship had Lewis not taken both cars out to protect his lead in the Championship.

- Wwuk1, Essex U.K., 03/04/2009 01:30
Report abuse


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • Carlos Tevez back in the fold at Manchester City Carlos Tevez Carlos Tevez is beginning the task of winning back Manchester City's trust after ending his self-imposed exile to return to the club
  • Arsene Wenger will keep faith in youth for AC Milan clash Arsene Wenger Arsene Wenger has challenged his young Gunners to once again rise to the occasion when Arsenal tackle AC Milan in the first leg of their...
  • Bernie Ecclestone rejects notion that Bahrain Grand Prix will not go ahead Bernie Ecclestone Bernie Ecclestone sees no reason for this season's Bahrain Grand Prix not to go ahead despite violence flaring again on the island kingdom
  • Sean Dyche delighted with Valentine's Day victory for hard-working Watford Craig Forsyth Watford boss Sean Dyche hailed the Hornets' team spirit as they made it 10 points from 12 to continue their upward movement in the...
  • Officials cost West Ham the chance to beat Southampton, claims Sam Allardyce Mark Noble Sam Allardyce felt referee Lee Probert cost West Ham the chance to move four points clear of Southampton at the top of the npower...
  • Javier Hernandez ready to embrace Europa League Javier Hernandez It might be a Thursday night on Channel Five - but Manchester United's clash with Ajax does sound like a Champions League game
  • Dougie Freedman satisfied with Crystal Palace's draw at Bristol City Dougie Freedman Dougie Freedman refused to criticise his Crystal Palace players for surrendering a two-goal lead as they left Bristol City with just a point
  • PFA urged John Terry to quit England captaincy for European Championships John Terry Exclusive: John Terry refused a plea from the Professional Footballers' Association to step down as England captain until...
  • Has Arsene Wenger really found a new batch of San Siro heroes? Cesc Fabregas The Champions League clash between Arsenal and AC Milan will determine whether critics are right to question the strength and ability of...
  • Ravi Bopara and Steven Finn turn tide to stop tour sliding into a complete disaster Ravi Bopara England have won a match and for their next trick they plan to win a series. Anything is possible now after their victory in the opening...
  •