Weather Afternoon: 9°c Sunny spells Tonight: 5°c Partly Cloudy Night

Sport

Tough choices facing council ahead of Renault decision

17 Sep 2009


The World Motor Sport Council now face an agonising decision over what sanction they should impose against Renault.

The Anglo-French manufacturer will hope to have drawn the sting out of any penalty after deciding not to dispute the recent allegations made by the FIA concerning the 2008 Singapore Grand Prix.

The fact Flavio Briatore and Pat Symonds have left their positions as team principal and executive director of engineering should also carry some weight when the WMSC meet in Paris on Monday.

There is now little for the 26 Council members to debate because in offering no defence, Renault have effectively admitted a charge of conspiring with former driver Nelson Piquet Jnr to cause a crash.

It resulted in the deployment of the safety car to the advantage of Fernando Alonso who went on to win his first race for two years, at a time when Renault were considering quitting the sport.

It is the gravity of what Piquet was asked to do that is likely to weigh heavy on the minds of FIA president Max Mosley, Formula One supremo Bernie Ecclestone and the remainder of the Council.

Piquet may have feared for his future but he not only put his own life at risk, he also jeopardised the safety of fellow drivers, marshals and spectators.

Speaking last Friday, Mosley noted this incident in his eyes was worse than the McLaren 'spygate' saga when they were found to be in possession of Ferrari technical secrets.

"As for any penalty, if you look at any other sport, if somebody fixes the result then it's usually taken seriously," said Mosley.

"Fixing is one degree worse than cheating, like if you're a cyclist and you take dope, that's cheating.

"If you bribe the other cyclists, or you get somebody to have a crash in the peloton so the yellow jersey guy crashes, that's more serious.

"Then if it puts human life at risk, whether it's the spectators, the marshals or the drivers, then it's more serious again."

Although Renault are not disputing the allegations, and Briatore and Symonds are no longer with the team, it is imperative the WMSC are seen to act.

As for precedents, McLaren were fined a sporting record £50million and stripped of all constructors' points for 2007 over 'spygate', although the fact they were found to be lying worked against them.

Earlier this year, McLaren were handed a three-race suspension in the wake of the 'liegate' saga surrounding Lewis Hamilton and his attempt to deceive the stewards at the Australian Grand Prix.

In mitigation, Hamilton had apologised profusely beforehand, whilst the team also dismissed team manager Dave Ryan as he was complicit in the affair.

Renault will most likely plead for clemency from the WMSC, hoping the actions of two men will not adversely affect the employment of nearly 700 other staff within the team.

Renault's future is a concern for Mosley as he last week remarked: "That's the difficult bit."

One possibility is the Anglo-French manufacturer would have their points deducted for this season, in turn resulting in a financial penalty as they would collect minimal prize money.

As for Renault's long-term future beyond this season, that now lies in the hands of the manufacturer's president and CEO, Carlos Ghosn.

Reader views (1)

 Add your view

Have we all forgotten the 1994 Australian Grand Prix when Michael Schumacher collided with Damon Hill? He had already run off the track hitting the wall with the right-hand side of his Benetton and damaged his car.

Coming into the sixth corner Damon Hill moved to pass Schumacher's damaged Benetton and Schumacher moved to block him and the two collided, breaking the Hill's front left suspension wishbone, and forcing both drivers' retirement from the race.

As Schumacher was already leading the driver`s championship by a single point, he took the title.

Most observers thought that Schumacher had deliberately caused the collision, which could have led to serious injury. But was he punished?... No he became Formula 1 World Champion.

Why are we still surprised when these guys cheat?

- Alan Combe, London, 17/09/2009 12:52
Report abuse


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • Andre Villas-Boas: Roman Abramovich's still backing me even if players aren't Andre Villas-Boas Andre Villas-Boas is confident he still has the support of Chelsea owner Roman Abramovich and insists he is not worried if the players back...
  • There's no way back as bemused Arsene Wenger wrestles with Euro crisis Zlatan Ibrahimovic Manager's unswerving faith in his stumbling players is designed to foster team spirit but it seemed complacency was the only consequence...
  • Ryan Giggs could learn the job at Jose Mourinho's side Ryan Giggs Patrick Barclay: The argument for Giggs as Mourinho's Old Trafford assistant is attractive. Jose often has a link with the...
  • Harry Redknapp drops England hint but agonises over Spurs Harry Redknapp Harry Redknapp has suggested it would be possible to combine the role of Premier League manager and England boss until after Euro 2012 but...
  • Chelsea want Petr Cech and Daniel Sturridge to stay at Stamford Bridge Daniel Sturridge Chelsea insist Petr Cech and Daniel Sturridge are part of their long-term plans and will not be leaving Stamford Bridge
  • Money is only thing that finally brought barking Carlos Tevez to heel Carlos Tevez Dan Jones: Carlos Tevez's absurd reaction to that night in Munich last September has been to undertake a one-man strike...
  • Hammers blow it as Chelsea kids win through West Ham threw away the chance to eliminate favourites Chelsea from the FA Youth Cup when they lost concentration in the dying seconds of injury time
  • Gunners bring out the devil in a lazy mime artist Zlatan Ibrahimovic Dan Jones: The man wielding the cane on Arsenal at the San Siro was football's most enigmatic, quicksilver galoot: Zlatan...
  • The battle for Warren Farm Tony Fernandes QPR have targeteda site for new £6m training ground but could lose out to non-League Southall
  • Sir Alex Ferguson will play his stars in Europa League Sir Alex Ferguson Sir Alex Ferguson has conceded he got it wrong in the Champions League this season as Manchester United prepare to make their debut in the...
  •