Weather Tonight: 3°c Partly Cloudy Night Morning: 6°c Cloudy

Football

Jeff Winter hopes players and referees will learn from red weekend

2 Nov 2009


Former top referee Jeff Winter hopes the weekend's record number of red cards in the Barclays Premier League will not be repeated.

The red mist descended on the top flight this weekend, with eight players sent off on Saturday and Birmingham's Barry Ferguson dismissed on Sunday.

The total of nine was the highest for a decade but Winter hopes lessons will be learned by both referees and players.

"Referees don't want to be sending players off and certainly games can be spoilt if we get red card after red card," said Winter.

"But hopefully this weekend is a one-off.
Referees may learn from it, hopefully players will learn from it and it won't be repeated."
Consistency among referees remains a concern, with two incidents involving Jamie Carragher a prime example of different interpretations of the same offence.

Carragher pulled down Manchester United's Michael Owen last Sunday but only received a yellow card from referee Andre Marriner, who decided Owen was running away from goal.

But referee Lee Mason did show Carragher a red card against Fulham when he was adjudged to have pulled back Bobby Zamora in similar fashion.

"The problem is some managers are incorrectly interpreting the law that the referees are supposed to adhere to," added Winter on Sky Sports News.

"Denial of a goalscoring opportunity has got to be an obvious goalscoring opportunity. The player has got to be running towards his opponents' goal.
"The one with Michael Owen is one where I can see why the referee didn't send him off.

"It is very hard to justify to fans who say there is no consistency but when he (Carragher) got sent off this week and was saying he got the ball, to me he had also had a little pull on the opponent's shirt.

"That player was clean through on goal, in possession, and running towards the goal.

"That is the problem with football, if everything was black and white it would be very easy to be a referee.

"There are a lot of grey areas and those two instances are ones that many fans and players will say were much the same.

"The laws of the game suggest they are not. We have got to have consistency. We have got to have a law that everyone understands, but most of all we have got to have understanding from the authorities that it is difficult for a referee out there.

"In a split second he gives what he sees. There is enough pressure on him without him thinking that if he doesn't send him off, he will be marked down."

Two other games also featured a pair of dismissals.

Everton's Diniyar Bilyaletdinov and Carlos Cuellar of Aston Villa received their marching orders within minutes of each other at the end of their 1-1 draw, with Sunderland's Kenwyne Jones and West Ham's Radoslav Kovac dismissed at the Stadium of Light.

Geovanni's red card added to Hull's woes in their defeat at Burnley but Jlloyd Samuel can have no complaints about his dismissal for tripping Chelsea's Didier Drogba.

Reader views (0)

 Add your view

No comments have so far been submitted.


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • I haven't run away from England job, says Fabio Capello Fabio Capello Fabio Capello has blamed a "misunderstanding" for him quitting the England job
  • Harry Redknapp: England is the ultimate job but I couldn't manage Spurs as well Harry Redknapp Harry Redknapp has described becoming ­England manager as "the ultimate job" but insisted he could not lead both Tottenham and his country
  • I know Harry Redknapp can handle transition to the England job Harry Redknapp Sam Allardyce: The new manager will have to adjust to having the players for only 10 games a year, instead of 40-plus
  • There's no doubt that Harry Redknapp is the best man to take over as England manager, says Sir Alex Ferguson Sir Alex Ferguson Sir Alex Ferguson has hailed Harry Redknapp as "the best man" for the England job
  • Pressure's on Andre Villas-Boas as Roman Abramovich renews contact with Jose Mourinho Andre Villas-Boas The pressure on Andre Villas-Boas is mounting amid the news that Roman Abramovich has been stepping up his communication with former boss...
  • FA reject £1.5million pay-off claims Fabio Capello The Football Association have rejected claims they paid £1.5million in compensation to Fabio Capello following the Italian's resignation as...
  • Peterborough pray fans aren't too posh to sweep Chris Powell Peterborough have appealed for fans to turn up at London Road with their own shovels to save their clash with Championship leaders West Ham
  • Fabio Capello arrived as a winner but we all look like losers now he's gone Fabio Capello James Olley: Capello got plenty wrong. A failure to grasp the language and underestimating the English furore around the...
  • Derby blow for Thierry Henry after Arsene Wenger fails to extend loan Thierry Henry Striker denied the opportunity to face Spurs as Arsenal confirm he will be returning to MLS the day after Milan clash
  • No shortage of options for Fabio Capello Claudio Ranieri and John Terry Fabio Capello's record as a club coach means there should be plenty of chances for him to return to management after quitting as England...
  •