News

HEADLINES:
Joan Ryan: The Enfield North MP claimed £173,691
Joan Ryan: The Enfield North MP claimed £173,691

The guilty and greedy must be brought to book

Andrew Gilligan
29.10.07

Forget Coco Chanel or even Dame Shirley Porter. At £173,691 for her parliamentary expenses last year, Joan Ryan, Labour MP for Enfield North, is London's most expensive woman. Like all expensive women, she is irresistible. Indeed, since she is funded by taxes, it is illegal to resist her.

As well as the MPs' expenses, we learned last week that Sir Ian Blair, the Met Commissioner, considered claiming a £25,000 bonus - because, said friends, the Met has cut crime. The outcry focused on the fact that Sir Ian's force is currently on trial for killing someone. But to me, the real problem was different. Reducing crime is what Sir Ian is already paid for. He shouldn't expect bonuses just for doing his job.

Then there was Andrew Lezala, catastrophic chief executive of Metronet, who got a £500,000 pay-off on top of the billions his company has already cost us. And then John Yates, the policeman in charge of the cash-for-honours investigation, told MPs how Downing Street had frustrated his enquiries, and how his detailed findings must unfortunately remain confidential.

There's a common thread in all this: the arrogance of power. This isn't, as some claim, a country where the powerful enjoy "impunity." But we do seem to have ended up with the worst of both worlds.

We have enough accountability to uncover bad behaviour - the sale of honours - but not enough to punish or discourage it. We have enough accountability to cast general suspicion - but not enough to discover what specifically happened. The result is that all politicians and senior public servants, even the good ones, are tarred by the activities of the worst. It would actually be in their interest - not just in ours - for the system to single out the guilty and the greedy, so voters understand there's a difference between them and the rest.

The crisis in our democracy will not be solved by allowing demonstrators back into Parliament Square, welcome as that is, or by anything else Gordon Brown suggested last week. It's a crisis of accountability.

The reason why corruption or shamelessness goes so often unpunished, the reason why the undeserving are so often rewarded, is that power in Britain is too often unaccountable. Too often, the bodies scrutinising the Government are themselves appointed by the Government.

We need select committees without a governing-party bias. We need democratic approval of senior appointments and salaries. We need a way of finding independent investigators in whom all can have confidence. We need electoral reform to bring all voters, and not just a few million in marginals, into the political process. We need to make sure that the greedy and the grasping in public life fear the real prospect of retribution, not just criticism.

These are fundamental changes to our over-centralised politics. But as a first step, let us release Mr Yates from his confidentiality obligations, and bring the whole cash-forhonours scandal into the daylight zone.

Link to: Digg Reddit Delicious Facebook

Reader views (0)

 Add your view

No comments have so far been submitted.


Add your comment

 

Your email address will not be published

Terms and conditions make text area bigger You have  characters left.


 


Rate cut brings limited relief

It is a decision that will result in real savings for many mortgage payers, but it may cause wider problems

Future of BBC D-G in doubt after scandals

There is growing speculation that Mark Thompson's reign as Director General of the BBC may come to an end sooner rather than later

All stories


Don't miss...

  • Teenager in Dagenham

    Climate of fear

    Teenagers talk for the first time about shocking new levels of sexual violence in London as a charity chief says post-code gangs are now using multiple rape as a weapon to enforce their will
  • Shaggy coat

    Shaggy chic

    Fend off the cold in true fashionista style and become an abominable show-woman
  • Jonathan Miller

    The Miller’s tale revisited

    For a decade the director has complained that no one wanted him in London. Now Jonathan Miller is back at ENO — with a radical new production of La Bohème inspired by Brassaï
  • Florence Welsh

    Influentials 2009

    From finance to fashion and politics to property, the past 12 months have seen dramatic changes in who wields influence in the capital. So who are the up-and-coming power players in London this year?

On This is London today

Pick of the blogs

Richard Godwin
Richard Godwin - A London Life
A sound thrashing has cleared my head

City Briefing

The latest top City stories and Market report emailed to you twice a day.

Read the latest bulletin

Mickey Clark

podcasts

on the City Markets


Linkudo - the lateral thinking word linking game