Morning:
18°c
The full story of the rescue operation was told as it emerged that plastic windows fitted at the block two years ago melted in the intense heat, effectively acting as fuel for the blaze
More...
Official: housing crash on the way
Joe Murphy, Political Editor13.05.08
An Assessment that house prices will fall by up to 10 per cent this year was laid bare today by a blunder.
The secret official verdict was unwittingly disclosed when Housing Minister Caroline Flint strolled into this morning's weekly Cabinet meeting carrying an armful of documents.
Clearly visible on top of her bundle of papers was a printed briefing paper on the state of the property market which said that "at best" prices will tumble this year by five to 10 per cent. It came as inflation jumped to three per cent, way above forecasts.
Ms Flint's careless disclosure at a stroke undermined government attempts to talk up the economy and may even damage confidence in housing further. It also over-shadowed a major announcement by Alistair Darling this afternoon of compensation for people who lost out from the 10p tax band abolition, fuelling the impression that Gordon Brown's government is beset by bad luck.
Headed "Caroline Flint - speaking notes" the briefing contained a summary of what the minister told Mr Brown, Mr Darling and other Cabinet colleagues during an hour-long discussion on the economy at No 10.
A sticker on the document said "Papers for Cabinet meeting 13 May 2008". It said leading house price indicators were predicting reductions for the first time in recent years and warned starkly: "We can't know how bad it will get. Given present trends, they will clearly show sizeable falls in prices later this year - at best down five per cent to 10 per cent year on year." There was also worry that the collapse would torpedo government promises to get three million new homes built by 2020. "Housebuilding is stalling," warned the notes. "New starts are already down 10 per cent compared with a year ago. House-builders are predicting further falls."
The notes highlighted the rise in mortgage defaults, after figures last week showed that threats of repossession had hit their highest level since the early Nineties. They continued: "Underlying demand for housing remains high and the fundamentals of the economy are sound. But the market is being affected by the global credit crunch, which is making it difficult for many who would like to buy to do so.
"We can't know how bad it will get. But we need to plan now to put in place effective measures against the risk that it does get worse and to prepare for the upturn."
Ms Flint accepted she had been "caught out" but insisted her briefing note only contained information that was already public.
"These things happen, I'm not the first person to have been caught out in this way and probably won't be the last," she said.
"But the fact is this note simply reflects what external analysts have said publicly - they are not Government predictions.
"This Government is on the side of homeowners and will ensure we provide them with the maximum support we can. We have already taken action and put a comprehensive strategy in place but will continue to monitor the situation and take appropriate action where necessary.
"UK house prices are 45.5% higher than five years ago. As the note makes clear, the fundamentals of the economy are sound with high employment and low inflation but, as everyone knows, the market is being affected by the global credit crunch."
Downing Street refused to comment on the contents of the "leaked" document. Sources close to the Prime Minister played down Ms Flint's error, saying that the findings were in line with the public comments of ministers and the Prime Minister. "This is why we are so concerned and why the Government is putting so much effort into helping home-owners," said an official.
But Labour MPs were aghast at what seemed to be a major own goal that could have grave repercussions if the forecast becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Shadow housing minister Grant Shapps said: "Rather than closed door briefings to Cabinet, Caroline Flint must come out in public and make a full statement about what she thinks the future might be for hard-pressed homeowners.
"Instead of dithering and complacency Brown could act today to free up the housing market by scrapping Home Information Packs and abolishing stamp duty for most first-time buyers."
There was more bad news from the housing industry today with figures showing a dramatic reduction in new home loans. New mortgage numbers almost halved in March compared with a year ago, reported the Council of Mortgage Lenders, down to 46,500 compared with 89,000 in March last year.
Reader views (11)
Here's a sample of the latest views published.
The the question that needs asking is not "how has the Government and the banks allowed a housing crash to happen?", but "Why did the Government and banks allow hyper-inflation take a hold in the housing market, pushing up prices to ridiculous heights, making a crash a certainty sooner or later?"
- Owen, London
The Bucks property market has always been robust and tends to recover quickly from these self-prophesising slumps. Schools are good, communication links are good, housing stock is varied. House prices needed to slow and probably fall back. 10% per annum price increases are not sustainable
I worked as an estate agent in Gerrards Cross for 7 years,(the second most expensive town in the country, apparently) during that time home-owners have made a lot of money. I recently changed to a different area, hugely different property stock in value and type. Back to the end of the market that is dependant on mortgage lending and first time buyers.
What is clear to every agent and every vendor in both areas is that prices had to come down, they have come down, by approximately 6-8%. A further negotiating margin of 2 or 3% is not out of the question, prior to a sale being agreed.
What we need now is the press to stop jumping on the doom and gloom band wagon. There is a good choice of property on the market, at realistic prices. Good mortgage deals are still available through independent advisors.
By the time all of the clever people come out of their rented houses (waiting for prices to plummet) choice will be minimal, buyers plenty and prices will be recovered and rising again.
Change the record and persecute the oil companies instead.
- Peter Reilly, Flackwell Heath, Buckinghamshire
Can't people remember that the last house crash was under the Tories?
The thing is a country that doesn't produce anything cannot have a healthy economy. How many years will it take to the UK to understand the British Empire is gone and now global economy is something that who is clever will survive. China, India and Brazil the new superpowers? ... Wake up Britain before is too late, stop waiting the government doing for you, do it yourselves!
- Arturo Viola, London, UK
This stupid woman will cause a crash. The government should have used the £50 billion it gave to the banks to set up a fund for mortgages exclusively available to first time buyers. That would have got the market moving. Those who want a crash should be careful what they wish for. House prices may come down, but they may find themselves out of a job.
- Beatirz, London
For years a cooling off of house price growth has been wanted by first time buyers and first time sellers - now it is here, the banks won't lend unless you have huge cash deposits (15-20%) which means the majority of the public now cannot buy (to avoid the risk of the banks going into negative equity they would rather use your cash!)- The lack of finance available is here mainly because the banks did not asses the risks to their cash flows when making investments outside of the local UK economy - the 'crisis' or 'crunch' is global for more than the sub prime debarcle (oil, food shortage, gulf war and the emerging eastern markets competing for oil, food and commodities)however, on a localised level we all want to see an end to this impending doom - and one method would be to scrap the stamp for genuine 1st Time buyers and then imposing an 0.5% stamp on all residential property above £3m to compensate (it could be 0.5% of the difference after £3m) as this would then bring back the threshold for those it was designed to target in the first place... It would also mean the smaller investment landlord would not be able to compete with a genuine first time buyer as they will have access to extra finance due to the saving on the stamp. Even if they are buying at £500k they could avoid the stamp if they have never owned in the u.k. before.
- Richard, London
But Crash Gordon is saying all is fine?!
- Steveo, London
This just shows how foolish, incompetent and incapable this government is. The country was in freefall last March 2007 yet the government continues in self denial.
We are heading for a major housing crash and unfortunately this will rock the whole economy into recession.Wake up and put easy strategies in place.
What other country in the world trades its economy on the state of the housing market?
Bring on the Conservatives asap as the y actually understand business economics.
- Kevin Martin, bromley UK
House prices are already being discounted 5-25%. Just look at estate agent's prices - its obvious that cuts have been made to try shift them. There is a web site that lists the discounts - with links to the discounted property.
Its not surprising given how hard it is to get a mortgage, but 10% looks very optimistic at this point.
- Peter, Battersea
A 10% fall in the housing market is probably a good thing hopefully it will start it moving again. That is as long as the banks and building societies start to lend money responsibly - after all it's because of them we are in this position.
- Sharon Powell, London England
This jaw-dropping stupidity is just typical of the arrogant Labour Government. Bring on the next election...
- Emily Oliver, London
Ha-ha this Government resembles a Monty Python sketch more every day. They have no principles or ideas so they just bend with the fickle wind of public opinion from day to day. Which would be bad enough if they weren't like a large group of incompetent middle managers.
- Mark Curtis, London
