News

HEADLINES:
Cloned picture of car
Fraud: the clone pictured on a penalty notice

The cloned car running up £1,000 in unpaid fines

Danny Brierley, Evening Standard
04.07.08

A businessman who has never driven in London faced £1,000 in congestion charge and parking fines after fraudsters cloned his Range Rover.

Barry Ellis was harassed by bailiffs at his Cheshire home and almost ended up in court during a two-year campaign over the unpaid charges.

Criminals had copied his number plates and put them on an almost identical £35,000 4x4, meaning penalty charge notices started arriving for Mr Ellis, 45, soon after he bought the car in October 2006.

The first, an offence in Great Dover Street in Borough, was followed by violations in Redcliffe Gardens in Fulham, Baker Street, King's Road and on the A1.

Mr Ellis returned the tickets explaining he had only ever been to London on a coach but the fines were returned with stern letters demanding he pay the ever increasing amount.

Eventually, the money from five congestion charge fines and one Westminster council parking ticket snowballed to almost £1,000.

Mr Ellis, who runs a minibus service, finally convinced police he was a fraud victim and they let him change his registration.

But TfL still refused to back down and sent in bailiffs who issued more than 20 letters, charging more money for every one.

TfL agreed to cancel the fines after being contacted by the Evening Standard and apologised to Mr Ellis. The businessman said: "You can tell from the CCTV pics they sent me that it's not my car. It's the same colour and the same registration but the badge on the back is different.

"The bailiffs said they would give me a week to sort it out but I haven't been able to get TfL to see reason. It's so obvious that it's not me, you can see the bloke getting into the other Range Rover in one of the CCTV pictures and it is clearly not me."

Police said that last year 40,000 sets of number plates were stolen in the UK, up 25 per cent on the previous 12 months.

TfL said: "We have cancelled all congestion charge PCNs relating to Mr Ellis's vehicle and would like to apologise for the delay and any distress this may have caused."

Mr Ellis added: "I'm over the moon they've seen sense at last, I just wonder why it took two years and so much aggravation to get them to see what anyone could work out in two minutes." Westminster said fines could also be challenged with the Parking Appeals Service.

Link to: Digg Reddit Delicious Facebook

Reader views (2)

 Add your view

Here's a sample of the latest views published. You can click view all to read all views that readers have sent in.

This man should be compensated for his time in defending himself. This looks like demanding money with menaces to me.

- Steve Drew, Tamworth. UK.

Guilty until proven innocent where the traffic fascists are involved I'm afraid.

Perhaps Mr. Ellis should consider suing TFL and Westminster council for the time he has had to waste trying to clear his name, say at the rate of £50 per hour.

- Jimbob, Kensington


Add your comment

 

Your email address will not be published

Terms and conditions make text area bigger You have  characters left.


 

Confidence lost on Black Friday

As uncertainty continues in the US over how far the Treasury there will follow the UK in offering equity to recapitalise major banks, it has become clear that the $700 billion Paulson plan and Federal Reserve support in money markets have not succeeded in restoring investor confidence

Turbulence for Cameron as he flies Air Freud

David Cameron's latest entry in the Register of Members' Interests shows that he has a generous new pal - Rupert Murdoch's son-in-law Matthew Freud

All stories


On This is London today

Don't miss...

  • Angel Flowers

    Hard times on the high street

    The Government has begun a massive rescue operation to prop up the crumbling pillars of the City but big institutions are not the only victims of the credit crunch. Ellen Widdup heads to Islington to see how ordinary businesses are coping
  • Bangers and mash

    Upside of the downturn

    Never mind all the gloom and doom — there are still lots of things to smile about
  • Michael Spencer

    The beginning of the end says the City’s top player

    After yesterday’s £500 billion bail out to the banks, Michael Spencer, the richest self-made man in the Square Mile talks exclusively to the Standard about who’s to blame
  • Boris Johnson

    The Influentials: London's top fifty

    Our annual survey of London’s 1000 most influential people is free with today’s Evening Standard - here we reveal the chart-toppers

City Briefing

The latest top City stories and Market report emailed to you twice a day.

Read the latest bulletin

Rosamund

Urwin Podcasts

on the City Markets



Pick of the blogs

Waugh
Paul Waugh - politics
Gordon Brown's sofa shuffle
Godwin
Richard Godwin - A London Life
The ideal day for a night out