News

HEADLINES:

Comment: The Golden Rule is tarnished

Evening Standard
18.07.08

The Treasury has condemned as speculative a report in today's Financial Times that the Prime Minister may be preparing to ditch two of the rules that once underpinned his reputation for economic prudence. The first, or Golden Rule, is that over the economic cycle, the Chancellor can only use borrowing to fund investment in long term projects like schools and roads, not for day-to-day spending. The second is that public borrowing may not exceed 40 per cent of national income, or GDP. It seems likely that the Treasury will simply declare that the present economic cycle has drawn to a close and new rules will apply. The likeliest time for such an announcement is when the pre-Budget report is delivered in September, on the basis of economic figures from the Office of National Statistics.

The upshot is, the Government will feel more free than ever to borrow itself out of its difficulties. And the pressures making for greater borrowing are very real. Public-sector borrowing was 50 per cent higher than last year for the first two months of the tax year. The Government is faced with the worst possible vicious cycle, whereby lower employment produces higher social security spending and lower income tax. Meanwhile, pressure from higher prices on spending means less VAT, while fewer house sales produce less stamp duty. The downturn also has an effect on capital gains tax and corporation tax. Not all of this unlovely scenario is the fault of the Government but its inability to respond to the situation except by rewriting its own rules is. The extent of government spending - some of it kept off the balance sheets by Private Finance Initiatives - is squarely Gordon Brown's responsibility. He spent in the fat years; he has no room to manoeuvre in the lean ones.

Mr Brown's image on economic competence was massively tarnished in his transition from Chancellor to Prime Minister but scrapping the Golden Rule may well put paid to it. That was his real claim to his present job. Rewriting the rules may give him short-term breathing space but the damage is to his reputation.

Link to: Digg Reddit Delicious Facebook

Reader views (0)

 Add your view

No comments have so far been submitted.


Add your comment

 

Your email address will not be published

Terms and conditions make text area bigger You have  characters left.


 


The fallout from the bank rescue

JUST as the markets appear to be stabilising in response to the banking bail-outs, there comes a rude reminder that out in the real economy, the situation is worsening

Will Brown try a new election-that-never-was?

Gordon Brown's problems may have started when he failed to call a snap election - is he planning to solve them once and for all by going ahead with it 12 months on?

All stories


On This is London today

Don't miss...

  • The Queen K in Venice

    Mandelson, the billionaire and a growing mystery

    As the controversial politician is ennobled and returns to government, we reveal new evidence that calls into question his links with Oleg Deripaska
  • Peter Mandelson

    Can a man truly lord it in fur?

    Mandelson in ermine reminds us that it's inadvisable to go full pelt when you're a bloke
  • Sonia Purnell and her son Laurie

    Choices? What choices?

    When a Sutton grammar school called in the police last week to control the crush of parents on entrance exam day, it was the latest sign that Government policy on admissions is in tatters. Here, two mothers tell of the trials they face trying to find the best education for their boys
  • Angelina Jolie

    Competitive thrift – it’s the new spending

    Today it’s all about being seen to buy less, says Helen Kirwan-Taylor

Pick of the blogs

Jonathan Prynn
Jonathan Prynn - Consumer affairs
London can take this latest crash

City Briefing

The latest top City stories and Market report emailed to you twice a day.

Read the latest bulletin

Rosamund

Urwin Podcasts

on the City Markets