Weather Afternoon: 9°c Sunny spells Tonight: 5°c Partly Cloudy Night

News

A monopoly that should never have existed

Chris Blackhurst
20 Aug 2008


It's been a long time coming - too long, given the chaos passengers have had to endure at Heathrow these past few years - but today's Competition Commission finding at last begins to give proper shape to BAA.

The airports operator should never have been allowed to be privatised as a monopoly owning London's three main airports. An opportunity that was lost in the selloff scramble of the late Eighties is finally being realised.

In recommending that Gatwick and Stansted are effectively to be put into separate ownership, the commission has gone to the other extreme - from no competition at all to an open playing field in one fell swoop. The trouble, however, is that it will by no means be level.

It's all very well hiving off the other airports in the expectation that the washrooms will be cleaner and the conveyor belts will run more smoothly, but that doesn't address the heart of the problem. While Heathrow continues to be so much bigger - and may even be allowed to expand - London's air transport will still be dominated by one airport.

Gatwick and Stansted must be encouraged to match Heathrow in terms of size and usage. Unless that happens, Heathrow will carry on being the centre of choice for the major scheduled airlines and will remain the international hub, while Gatwick and Stansted will still be also-rans - better run and managed but little more than air charter terminals. In effect, Heathrow's preeminence will be assured.

That cannot be the result that the commission envisages. But on its own, the break-up of BAA is not enough. What is required is a wholesale restructuring of London's air services and a recognition that planning laws at Gatwick and Stansted need to be relaxed. That is bound to lead to major disputes and upset the inhabitants of Essex and Sussex.

Without further change, the pro-Heathrow lobby will be able to cling to the argument that the airport is the only one capable of serving the needs of the economy, the UK airport that any airline worth its salt wants to use. That isn't competition - so, welcome as it is, the decision of the commission can only be regarded as a first step.

Reader views (0)

 Add your view

No comments have so far been submitted.


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • Side by side in dock, Chris Huhne and his ex-wife Chris Huhne Vicky Pryce Former minister Chris Huhne and his ex-wife refuse to exchange a glance as they are sent for trial for perverting the course of justice
  • Public 'priced out of best Games seats' Olympic Tickets Ordinary Londoners may have been priced out of buying the best seats at the Olympics, an official report said
  • Whitehall accused of covering up sky-high pay Whitehall departments are accused of using controversial arrangements to cover up the huge pay of top mandarins
  • Boris Johnson pledges to slash council tax every year Boris Johnson Boris Johnson will cut council tax every year if he is re-elected as Mayor, the Standard can reveal
  • Man hit by lorry in first crash on 'shared space' of Exhibition Road New Exhibition Road A man suffered head injuries when he became the first to be knocked down in Exhibition Road since it was turned into a "shared space" for...
  • Family left mourning 'our most beautiful, intelligent, bright girl' Casey-Lyanne-Kearney The parents of a 13-year-old girl stabbed to death in a park pay tribute to "the most beautiful, intelligent and bright young girl"
  • Stay in UK and I'll give you more power, David Cameron tells Scotland Cameron Salmond The Prime Minister has made a major offer to the Scottish people of more devolution if they vote against breaking up the UK in the coming...
  • Ken's friends in the East Livingstone and Lutfur The Mayor of Tower Hamlets defeated Labour to be elected. Livingstone not only backed him but some of Ken's key players are now at the heart...
  • Named: man who sank stadium deal The identity of the man behind an anonymous legal challenge that led to the collapse of West Ham's purchase of the Olympic stadium has been revealed
  • Discounts axed for second-home owners Westminster council is set to abolish council tax discounts for people who list expensive flats as their second homes, the Evening Standard has learned
  •  

    Don't Miss