Weather Tonight: 5°c Partly Cloudy Night Morning: 9°c Cloudy

News

NHS agency staff wages 'inflated'

3 Jan 2009


NHS hospitals are paying agency staff up to £200 an hour to cover shifts, the Tories claimed.

Figures obtained under the Freedom of Information Act showed some staff were paid hourly rates equivalent to salaries worth hundreds of thousands of pounds a year. The data also showed some agencies were taking large "cuts" in return for supplying workers to the NHS.

The Tories said NHS organisations across England were paying agency staff "hugely inflated" hourly rates to cover gaps in normal cover. The Party asked all NHS trusts to provide details of the highest amount they paid to an agency worker between May and October 2008 and received a response rate of more than 70%.

Whipps Cross University Hospitals NHS Trust said it paid £188 an hour for an anaesthetics medical consultant - equivalent to an annual salary of £366,000. Meanwhile, Trafford Healthcare NHS Trust paid £167 for an A&E doctor, equivalent to an annual salary of £326,000, and Dorset Primary Care Trust paid £158 an hour for a prison GP, equivalent to an annual salary of £307,000.

The data also showed that NHS Wakefield District Primary Care Trust paid £135 an hour for a prison GP, equivalent to an annual salary of £263,000, while Mid Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust paid £131 for a doctor, equivalent to an annual salary of £255,000.

Trusts also paid high sums for non-clinical staff, the figures showed. Tower Hamlets Primary Care Trust paid £157 an hour for a senior manager, equivalent to an annual salary of £306,000, while Wandsworth Primary Care Trust paid £147 an hour for a strategic commissioning manager.

The resulting data did not show whether the workers came from privately-run agencies or from NHS Professionals, a non-profit agency set up by the Government to provide flexible staff. However, they are most likely to be fees paid to private firms because NHS Professionals fees are standardised and comparatively low. Most organisations were unable to say how the hourly rate was split between the worker and the agency, the Tories said. But of those that did supply the information, some agencies were found to be taking large cuts.

For example, Somerset Partnership NHS Foundation Trust paid £116 per hour for a nurse but the agency took £50 (43%), and Oxfordshire Primary Care Trust paid £94 per hour for a nurse but the agency took £40 (43%). Mid Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust paid £105 per hour for a doctor but the agency took £45 (33%). Almost £800 million was spent on agency staff in 2006/07, although the Department of Health insists this figure is falling.

Shadow health secretary, Andrew Lansley, said: "Labour's dithering and chaotic, short-term planning has let down NHS staff. Some stability for them is the least we would have expected from the billions that the Government has poured into the NHS. It's incredible that agency staff can be paid such high hourly rates when jobs are being cut at the same time. This is typical of the waste that's occurred under this Labour Government".

A spokeswoman for the Department of Health said: "Temporary staff have, and continue to have, a key role in helping the NHS to respond to fluctuations in demand for services and in staff availability. Increasing the quality of, and achieving best value for money from temporary staffing is an important aspect of workforce planning in the NHS. We are spending less on agency staff year on year. The total pay bill spent on agency staff has reduced from 5.5% in 2003-04, to 4.2% in 2004-05 to 3.5% in 2005-06, 2.7% in 2006-07 and 3.2% in 2007-08."

Reader views (2)

 Add your view

Short term, Contract labour always costs more and they are paying as little as they can. If however they planned better with full time staff they could achieve savings.

Governments have always tried to 'dictate' market rates and found no-takers, and will always pay the higher rates.

- Graham, Fleet, Hampshire, 03/01/2009 15:31
Report abuse

I think all those Nu Labor agencies should be fired to save costs. Better rely on the full-time staff they are better.

- Jacqueline, Hampstead, London, 03/01/2009 08:56
Report abuse

 

  • Boris takes lead in closest ever race for City Hall Boris Johnson Exclusive poll: Boris Johnson has clawed his way back to a two-point lead in the closest mayoral race yet despite Ken Livingstone's...
  • Londoners urged to get out and vote in neck-and-neck contest Ken Boris split Poll results: Every Londoner has been urged to register to vote in the mayoral election on May 3 to take the turnout above 50 per...
  • Greek vote for more cuts boosts share prices over Europe Greece parliament Shares surged across Europe after Greece pushed through a fresh package of austerity measures needed to secure fresh bailout cash and save...
  • In pursuit of glory, women cyclists aim to be fastest ever Rowsell Two Team GB cyclists today pledged to go "faster than anyone has ever gone" in the Olympics
  • Brick Lane, not Tarmac Lane! Brick Lane A council has been accused of ruining the character of Brick Lane by laying tarmac over its famous cobbles
  • Ali Dizaei facing jail after second corruption conviction Ali Dizaei One of Scotland Yard's most senior officers is facing prison after being convicted for a second time of trying to frame an innocent man
  • Whitney Houston was dead before she went under the water Whitney o2 Singer Whitney Houston died from a mix of drugs and alcohol - and did not drown in her hotel bath, according to reports
  • Triumph for Adele as she finds her voice on tragic night at the Grammys adele Adele made a triumphant return after vocal cord surgery to win a record six Grammy Awards
  • Radical cleric Abu Qatada banned from school run Qatada A radical cleric described as Osama bin Laden's right-hand man in Europe will be banned from taking his youngest child to school when he is...
  • I was scared, says 'target' in shooting that paralysed girl Thusha Kamaleswaran The suspected target of a shooting that left a five-year-old girl paralysed for life today told a court he was "scared" before the attack
  •  

    Don't Miss