This is no way to show us you can win an election, Gordon
Stephen Byers, former Cabinet minister14.04.09
GORDON BROWN has now expressed his regrets and personal letters have been sent but one important political question still has to be answered — how damaging will the untrue and offensive emails sent by Damian McBride turn out to be?
First let me declare a personal interest. I have been the victim of Mr McBride's aggressive and hostile media briefing on a number of occasions. As a result I have to admit that I made little effort to suppress a smile when I heard about his enforced departure from Downing Street.
However, this was a fleeting moment of satisfaction. Once the broad outline of the allegations contained in the email became known and the smear operation that they were to form the basis of was public then it was clear that his actions would damage politics in general and the Labour Party in particular.
To dismiss the incident as juvenile, which was the first reaction of Downing Street, totally missed the point and failed to recognise the extent of the hurt and offence caused.
If there remain people close to the Prime Minister who are thinking of fighting the forthcoming general election in a personal and dirty way then they should go, and go now.
This is the time for Mr Brown to demonstrate that as a leader he is focused on developing and implementing policies that will meet the challenges that face us as a country.
In the process, the Conservatives should not be ignored. In a democracy it is absolutely right and proper for them to be attacked on the basis of their incoherent and ill-thought-out programme.
In fact, there are many questions that the Conservative leadership need to answer. They range from the general, such as what should be the overall burden of taxation and what level of public spending would be acceptable, to
specific measures such as how marriage will be rewarded under the tax system.
On these and other key questions David Cameron would appear to have taken a vow of silence. His refusal to answer needs to be exposed at every opportunity. The public have a right to know exactly what it is that a Cameron Conservative government would do if elected to office.
The recent G20 summit in London was a success for the Prime Minister. I say that as someone who before the event took place expressed concern that the agenda was so ambitious that it was likely to fail. In fact, Mr Brown conducted it in such a skilful way that he came out of the summit with his reputation enhanced.
This is the time for Labour to be promoting a positive agenda in order to build on the success of the G20 and to make the right long-term decisions for the future of our country.
It is in this context that the McBride affair has the potential to inflict real political damage in that it will be a distraction and a continuing focus of political debate.
There is a way to stop this happening. Next week Alistair Darling will present the Budget to the House of Commons. This will provide a golden opportunity to be on the front foot and positive about the future but it will not be easy. This Budget was always going to be the most difficult for Labour since it came to office in 1997.
It is vital that it shows new ideas and fresh thinking. Labour needs to develop a clear narrative that demonstrates exactly what it is in office to do. It has to show that it is governing and using the powers that it has in the public interest.
A combination of measures is needed. They have to tackle the economic slowdown by being of a scale large enough to provide a stimulus to the economy but any old measures will not do. They need to be popular with the electorate.
The Budget has to build on the foundations that have already been laid. A programme is needed that shows Labour has more to offer in the future than it has already delivered in the past.
This is not the time for an array of worthy but small-scale initiatives that seem to be focused on gaining control of the media agenda rather than laying down a coherent set of policies.
Far better to focus on a small number of key issues that will really make a difference to people. To change public opinion and give a boost to Mr Brown's leadership they will have to be of a scale and boldness that will capture the public imagination.
So what might be possible? Let's take one practicable proposal. The two and half per cent cut in VAT may appear modest but comes at significant cost. Between April and the end of this year it will cost the Treasury around £8.6 billion to implement.
For this significant amount of money there are more popular measures that could be introduced that would go a long way to winning broad and popular support back to Labour.
Raising personal allowances for income tax purposes for the rest of this tax year by £1,520 to £7,995 would cost £8.5 billon.
This would bring a windfall to all income tax payers but perhaps more importantly would take no fewer than 1.7 million low-paid workers out of paying income tax altogether.
Such a measure would put Labour on the right side of the debate about fair taxation and is of the magnitude necessary to change the political landscape in Labour's favour.
With only a year left to convince the electorate that Labour is worth keeping in office, we must ensure that all our focus and attention is on the implementation of policies that matter to people and not on personal attacks that demean the political process.
* Stephen Byers MP was a member of Tony Blair's Cabinet from 1998-2002.
Reader views (12)
This is rich coming from the man who stole my father's Railtrack shares after he had worked for BR for his whole working life, man and boy.
The sooner Byers and his lot are kicked out of all power the better we will be.
- Ian, London
If Labour win it will entirely due to boundary changes which are in Labours favour.Otherwise,Brown and Labour are heading towards the political wilderness,just wait for the Euro/Council Elections in June.
With McBride what worries me but has been overlooked is that he is Civil Servant,which to my mind means he should show no political bias.....clearly this is not so...what is to be done on this,how many others are there etc?
What happens as well ,if after the June elections some MP motions a vote of No Confidence in the government.
If Labour win,they are shown as noses in the trough,self serving politicians and are left in an even weaker position...if they lose..General Election?
- Grumpy As Hell, wimbledon
Brown and labour are the most disgusting ,incompetent government ever.
Brown is a bully ,and a denier he has to go and take his carpetbsggers with him.
We want our Labour
party back
- R Macleod, London
Enough is Enough - Gordon must be left to Govern and show that the MEASURES HE ANNOUNCED AT G20 WILL BRING LASTING PROSPERITY! HES ALREADY HAD A MASSIVE POLL BOOST!
- Wayne, Herts, Uk
Interesting comments from Stephen Byers. Along with many millions of people in the UK I am sick of this rotten, wretched sham of a government - 13 years of utter incompetence, waste, unnecessary wars, punishing taxes, benefits abuse,surveillance,easy on criminals and the list goes on.
Get rid of this UNELECTED Prime Minister NOW!
And were living in a democracy are we?! What a joke!
- A.Non Pc, London,UK
New Labour is just a cabal of obfuscators - Blair and Campbell just happened to be professional obfuscators, while Brown and his lot are unprofessional.
- Andrew Farrar, Seahouses, Northumberland
Sorry is not enough - Dissolve this wretched Parliament now and Mr Brown should take all these rancid people with him. David Smith, Cannes
- David Smith, Cannes, France
A perceptive article with the author declaring his personal position right at the start which only enhances his analysis, namely that by employing the likes of McBride (and Ed Balls, Charlie Whelan, Tom Watson) Gordon Brown is focussing on tactical advantage rather than strategic gains.
The very methods used to attempt a tactical advantage have backfired, exposing Gordon Brown, the Labour Party and the Government to intense scrutiny and detailed questions. All three of the groups mentioned can only emerged with their reputations tarnished and prospects damaged.
The most serious error of judgement by Gordon Brown was his attempt to dismiss the incident and make light of it because he failed to understand the seriousness of the issue, whether within the Labour Party, amongst the other parties or with the general public.
It is not 'juvenile' gossip but a very serious matter involving matters of corruption, physical and mental healthy and sexual activity amongst consenting adults. It also broke new group by targeting Frances Osbourne, the wife of a political opponent who has no direct links to politics at all.
Having decided to parade his 'values' in the past, Gordon Brown now finds his 'moral compass' being bought onto question. Bluffing, bluster or bullying will no longer suffice as he finds himself publicly exposed, a more statesman-like response is required!
- Manny Goldstein, London, UK
Cameron needs to do exactly what Blair did in 1997 to win the election: nothing. The Tories self-destructed and allowed Bliar in with a promise "that things can only get better". He and Brown had no specific policies or points of view, other than vague, cool sounding policies (the Third Way, anyone?).
Cameron will win simply because the public is fed up of 12 years of high taxes with nothing to show, apart from a bloated civil service, a couple of unpopular wars and a wrecked economy. Anybody could win an election against a party with a record like that.
- Nobby Clark, Perth, Scotland
Brown won't be able to show anyone how to win an election. It just won't happen. He has, however, shown us very clearly that he is frightened of elections.
- Neil45, Gloucestershire, England.
Herr Brown will lose the next election no matter how many promises he makes.
If Labour managed to get back in we would be guaranteed to have the war criminal Blair as EU President, this is not something the British will allow.
- Caroline Carter, Weybridge UK
Brown's letter of 'genuine' 'regret' certainly ain't an effective way 'to bury bad news'
- Dave, Cumbria
Morning:
14°c


























