Weather Tonight: 3°c Partly Cloudy Night Morning: 6°c Cloudy

News

An eclectic a line-up as ever, but don't expect a surprise winner

David Smyth
21 Jul 2009


Complaining about the Mercury Prize shortlist is like complaining about being eaten by your pet boa constrictor - what did you expect?

Yes, there could have been a completely different list of 12 albums that is equally as eclectic and intriguing and that pits major rock bands and jazz obscurities against each other in true Mercury style, yet there are no criminal omissions from this dozen. Doves, Manic Street Preachers, Lily Allen and Little Boots will all be justifiably disappointed today, but it's not worth getting upset over when indie rock and girly pop is still well-represented.

Nor do the outsiders surprise. Freeform jazz-rock fusionists Led Bib have been well-tipped for a nod by the six people who enjoy this kind of music, and Speech Debelle's sophisticated, acoustic hip hop was the obvious choice from the small field of British rap. By nominating a jazzy soul trio called The Invisible the judges seem almost to be making a knowing joke about their love for the obscure (good album though).

The real surprise is the inclusion of Kasabian. As the only nominees with a number one album they'll be early favourites, yet they've never been noted for the artistry that the Mercury traditionally champions. Characterised as purveyors of rowdy rock for ignorant Oasis fans, this is a welcome acknowledgement of the weirder side of their third album.

Among the indie rockers, Friendly Fires also deserve good odds for their exuberant debut, a word-of-mouth success so far that merits the spotlight the shortlist will shine on it. The eventual winner ought to be female, however. A woman hasn't won the prize since Ms Dynamite in 2002, and if the judges really want to reflect what's going on in British music right now they'll have to acknowledge the recent dominance of the fairer sex.

With their love for bizarre outfits, Florence And The Machine, Bat For Lashes and La Roux all ought to make room on their person to store an acceptance speech.

Reader views (0)

 Add your view

No comments have so far been submitted.


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • Damilola killer sent back to jail Preddie Damilola One of Damilola Taylor's killers was back behind bars today - only 16 days after being released from jail. Ricky Preddie (pictured left) was...
  • 'Best of British' concert to mark end of Olympics Adele The Olympics will sign off with a spectacular concert in Hyde Park with the Rolling Stones, Adele and Blur all being courted for a "Best of...
  • Knuckle down and fight for a better life, says Lennox Lewis Lennox pic dispossessed Heavyweight Lennox Lewis hands out a tough lesson at a boxing academy that helps troubled teens. David Cohen finds out how the ring is...
  • Cameron wins hands down: Body language expert gives PM the thumbs up Cameron hands A leading expert on body language has revealed that when the Prime Minister splays his fingers he is actually taking charge of the debate
  • Stay out of Syria, Russia tells the West Syria Russia and the US are on a collision course over Syria today after Moscow gave its strongest backing yet to President Bashar Assad
  • Barclays cuts bonuses by a third to £1.5 billion Bob Diamond Barclays has bowed to public pressure and slashed the bonuses paid to its City investment bankers by a third, to a total of £1.5 billion
  • Rothschild in libel defeat over trip with Mandelson Nat Rothschild Banker Nathaniel Rothschild lost a libel action over claims he had been the "puppet master" between Lord Mandelson and Russian oligarch Oleg...
  • Ken branded 'a vulgar embarrassment' in new gay storm Ken Livingstone Ken Livingstone was engulfed in a fresh row over "offensive" comments about homosexuality today after claiming gay bankers would have their...
  • Hunt for 'brazen' thief filmed stealing mobile phone on train Phone thief Watch the video: Police are hunting a thief who was filmed by a train passenger stealing a mobile phone from a woman's handbag after...
  • Thugs to be tagged in US-style trial to tackle drunken crime Kit Malthouse Drunken thugs in London are to be fitted with electronic tags to prevent them drinking and re-offending in a US-style scheme proposed by Kit...
  •  

    Don't Miss