Weather Tonight: 13°c Partly Cloudy Night Morning: 21°c Mostly cloudy

News

'Right-to-die' woman awaits ruling

30.07.09

Multiple sclerosis sufferer Debbie Purdy will learn whether her fight to allow her husband to help her commit suicide has been successful.

She took her case to have the law clarified on assisted dying to the highest court in the land where a panel of five Law Lords will give their ruling.

They sit at the House of Lords where earlier in the month a measure to remove the threat of prosecution from those who go abroad to help a terminally-ill patient die was defeated by peers who preside over Parliamentary business.

The judgment also comes in the same month that the Royal College of Nursing declared it was dropping its opposition to assisted suicide and adopting a neutral stance.

At a hearing last month, the Law Lords were told that both Ms Purdy, 46, and her husband, Cuban violinist Omar Puente, wanted to know whether he is likely to be prosecuted and what criteria the Director of Public Prosecutions takes into account when deciding whether to bring a charge under the Suicide Act.

As many as 115 people from the UK have gone to the Swiss clinic, Dignitas, to die, but no-one has been prosecuted so far.

Lord Pannick QC, representing her, said if the law was clarified, she may be forced to end her life earlier than she planned because her husband would be unable to help her if she became totally dependent.

Ms Purdy, from Undercliffe, Bradford, West Yorkshire, who was diagnosed with MS in 1995, has so far failed to secure a definitive ruling on the issue at both the High Court and Court of Appeal.

Lord Pannick said: "If the risk of prosecution is sufficiently low, she can wait until the very last minute before travelling with her husband's assistance."

He said if the risk was high, she would have to go earlier while she was still fit enough to travel without assistance. "It is ironic that the policy designed to protect the sanctity of life will have the effect of shortening the life of terminally-ill persons such as Ms Purdy."

Reader views (1)

 Add your view

I support the Rigth-to-Die. The person suffering the condition only can understand their difficulty, and many times it is more psychological than physical. I am a disabled person living considerable independent life. I will opt to die when I am not able to take care of myself, rather than living helpless. Easy for onlookers to disagree, but how many time you wanted to die when you were in pain? Here we are talking of people living every day with that pain, and no one has the right to deny his/her right-to-die

- Denny, Aylesbury, UK, 03/08/2009 14:30
Report abuse


Don't Miss
  • James Palumbo

    War of the Palumbos

    Mark Hollingsworth reveals why the extraordinary Palumbo 25-year family feud is unlikely ever to end
  • Katy Perry

    Why Katy Perry's new album actually stinks

    Katy Perry’s new CD cover is infused with the scent of candyfloss in the latest attempt to win back some sales from the download market — but is it really necessary?

First film now art: Hunt is in the firing line

As the campaign against Culture Secretary Jeremy Hunt’s plan to abolish the UK Film Council attracts 30,832 members on Facebook and opposition mounts from luminaries such as Clint Eastwood and Lord Attenborough, news reaches the Londoner of another withering attack on Hunt

All stories


Promotions

Park and Glide at Gatwick

Secure parking from £5 a day. Book official Gatwick parking in the closest car parks to your terminal.


Wip a VIP trip to Jarnac, France

The home of Courvoisier. When you create your own delicious punch recipe.


Looking for great design?

MPH Creative Solutions for print, digital, 3D and more. With great July offers.


Get this season's tips from Gok Wan

And follow our London street style series, with Specsavers.


Win a break for two

To Tylney Hall, Hampshire and find out all the best the South East has to offer this summer.


Life Insurance

Get £150k life cover from just £1.08 a week